Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Alarms raised over undercurrents of Hardt’s ‘take up arms’ comment

AMBASSADOR Brent Hardt on Wednesday night referenced the move by Americans, pre-independence, to take up arms to challenge the positions taken by King George, the Monarch of the United Kingdom (UK) who ruled is today the United States of America (USA).

He said: “He (King George) refused his assent to laws. He refused to pass laws for the accommodation of large districts of people. He dissolved representative houses repeatedly and refused for a long time, after such dissolution, to cause others to be elected.”

 

“…in a short space of time the loyal citizens of the colonies came to feel that their unalienable rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness had been eroded or even usurped.

 

“The ability to attend to their own affairs in their local legislatures has been suspended and not restored…in taking this historic and courageous stand (the fight against King George) back in July 1776, the citizens of the American colonies came together to form what would be a great nation.”
According to him, one of the core strengths of our nation has been the “vital role” that state and local governments have played in “giving people the opportunity to participate directly in their governance” – something that Guyanese could be able to do through the holding of local government elections.

 

“The American history we celebrate serves as a valuable reminder of the importance of respecting rights to local representation. For among the American colonialists’ lament, we do well to recall that the elimination of local representative houses and the refusal for a long time, after such dissolution, to cause others to be elected, were the wellsprings of discontent that convinced once loyal British subjects to declare their independence,” Hardt said.

 

It is the latter comment, in particular, that struck a chord with some persons in different factions of society, who on the condition of anonymity shared the sentiment that the undercurrents of Hardt’s comments are troubling and cause for alarm.

 

One commentator told the Guyana Chronicle, “He (Hardt) is calling for people to rise up against the Government. Does he know the bloodshed he can cause? The Ambassador is calling for something that can put in the country’s stability in jeopardy and it will not be tolerated. Guyanese should condemn this and condemn it strongly.”

 

The US Ambassador has been one of the most vocal in the diplomatic corps calling on the current administration to hold local government elections, vocal to the point where he flayed the Head of State, Donald Ramotar for “selectively” abiding by Guyana’s constitution, even as the country awaits long-overdue local government elections.

 

It was this comment that constituted a ‘red line’ for the Government and resulted in Acting Foreign Affairs Minister, Priya Manickchand, taking Hardt to task at the same event where the US Ambassador repeated his call for the “restoration of effective, elected local government” in Guyana.
Manickchand stated that Hardt’s reference to King George and his power made her smile, particularly since the prevailing situation with the US’ hegemony is anything but democratic.

 

She concluded that his “nuanced resort” to justifying the insurrection in his remarks is profoundly disturbing.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

If this message goes into action, many on this board will be held guilty of appeasing America and causing pain unto their own people and country. What you hope for may be too much to handle. Many here are calling for riot, killing and bloodshed. Your wishes may be come through.

FM

US Ambassador was expressing universal views

July 6, 2014 | By | Filed Under News 

Manickchand’s incident was “vulgar and crass” – Granger

Leader of the parliamentary Opposition, Brig. David Granger, has deemed the incident in which Acting Foreign Affairs

Opposition Leader, David Granger

Opposition Leader, David Granger

Minister, Priya Manickchand lashed out at the outgoing US Ambassador during a July 4 Independence reception, as “vulgar and crass.” Prior to the “unprecedented send off” on Wednesday last for Ambassador Brent Hardt, he had made comments supporting the call for Local Government Elections in Guyana and had also said that President Donald Ramotar is an inconsistent defender of the Constitution. The government subsequently issued a statement which chided the Ambassador for meddling in the internal affairs of the country. When asked to what extent he would say the envoy’s comments amounted to some degree of meddling, Granger said, “I do not see things that way. There are two issues here, the first one being whether he did in fact say or do things that were in contravention of normal diplomatic practice. “I do not think so because the views he expressed were not only those of the State department and his government, they are universal views. “Specifically, Local Government election is a constitutional requirement and everyone in Guyana except the government wants these elections. It is normal for a democratic country to have Local Government elections. It is abnormal and undemocratic not to do so. I think the response of persons at the reception indicated that there was support for the Ambassador’s position.” He added, “The second issue is of course the nature of international relations. In my entire life I have never come across such

Education Minister, Priya Manickchand

Education Minister, Priya Manickchand

a crass and vulgar incident which occurred that night. You don’t conduct international relations like that and use such a forum for that purpose. “It is counterproductive; it is not going to improve our reality…we have been beneficiaries of some assistance from the USA and I am not saying because of that we should keep our mouths closed but I am saying that there are diplomatic channels that could have been used. What occurred was just vulgar.” The Minister was roundly booed by the invitees during her presentation at a reception held at the Ambassador’s residence in observance of America’s 238th anniversary of its independence. During his weekly press conference, Dr. Roger Luncheon, Cabinet Secretary, came out in defence of the style and line of verbal attack on the outgoing envoy. He said that it was Cabinet that prepared the speech and that the event was considered ideal since Ambassador Hardt was leaving Guyana today.

Mitwah

It is time that the people take up arms and rid Guyana from the PPP cartel. The PPP has shown its true face: thieves and murderers who refuse to abandon its communist one party state oppression.

Mr.T

These crooked people are something else. The man cannot give an over view of their independence struggle at their independence struggle without the PPP taking offense!

 

If they were not the crooks they are they would not see a disgruntled Guyanese behind every bush and all story telling about good and evil would not be taken as an attack on them.

FM
Last edited by Former Member

It is the latter comment, in particular, that struck a chord with some persons in different factions of society, who on the condition of anonymity shared the sentiment that the undercurrents of Hardt’s comments are troubling and cause for alarm.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×