Skip to main content

Retired T&HD Captain says Berbice River Bridge tolls too high

 

November 12, 2012 | By | Filed Under News 

 

 

A former Ferry Captain employed with the Transport & Harbours Department (T&HD) has complained about the high tolls commuters are being made to pay for using the Berbice River Bridge (BRB).


Maheshwar Sugrim retired from T&HD as Captain of the MV Makouria and Torani several years ago and knows a lot about the inner workings of the company, even its financial position and how the financial targets were being surpassed each month.


In an interview with this newspaper Sugrim revealed that prior to the opening of the Berbice River Bridge, millions of dollars were being made each month by the T&HD and the new bridge has put a dent into the coffers of the entity.


Today, he is quite disturbed about the huge sums of money that Berbicians and the rest of Guyana are being asked to pay for tolls to cross the BRB.
Sugrim joined T&HD in 1991 as a Captain.

The fare for a car crossing the New Amsterdam to Rosignol Ferry was $200 and $20 per passenger. When fuel prices started to get higher, the company was forced to raise the fees to $500 per car and $40 per passenger.


“Transport used to give us a target to make at $19M a month, and the rest, we does get an incentive-a bonus.”


Sugrim revealed that T&HD’s operations at the N/A- Rosignol ferry routes used to make an average of $24M per month and workers benefitted from monthly bonuses.
The bonus went on for several years. “We used to get a reasonable bonus and it used to divide among the ferry and stelling workers”.


“Eventually, they cut out the bonus because the Marine Office wanted to come in for a share of the bonus and we who used to feel the pressure in the nights— it wasn’t easy, so the offer was just stopped.”

 

Ret’d Captain Maheshwar Sugrim

 

He explained that as the fuel prices continued to skyrocket, “it forced T&HD to raise the fares to $700 per car and $60 per passenger”.


“The amount of money they (T&HD) were making at that time on the ferries when the fare was $500, equivalent to $24M per month…the fares went up to $700 per car and the amount of men Transport had to pay, was 50 men and you had the stelling workers and then they had to buy fuel, so I’d like to explain to the public and ask how much fuel they buy for the bridge— none— and how many maintenance men they have on the bridge.”


“I don’t know how many workers they have on the bridge; I am sure it is not a lot of workers like T&HD had.”


“They (BRB) exploiting money from the poorer classes of people. My recommended price for crossing the Bridge should be $500 with a car,” he stated.


Sugrim believes that things might have been better if the ferry service was still in operation. Currently, only the Pontoon operates between N/A and Rosignol to facilitate workers and schoolchildren, and the vessel makes two trips per day, one in the morning and the other in the afternoon. Even this service leaves much to be desired, since commuters frequently report that the pontoon “breaks down”, leaving hundreds stranded and having to resort to using the BRB and pay over $400 to cross with a minibus.

With the introduction of the BRB, a number of employees with T&HD were laid- off and sent home from both the New Amsterdam and Rosignol ferry stellings. The pontoon only needs five or six workers to operate.


Sugrim stated that the ferry service could have continued to serve the public well and in a more cost- friendly manner if they had better systems in place, “like do more maintenance on the ferry boats and not cause any breakdowns and those kinds of things like that.”

The BRB, he related, is “easy” but “the price is too much”.

This newspaper made contact with BRB CEO, Mr. Omadatt Samaroo, who promised to send figures requested to show the number of employees employed by the entity and the total number of vehicles using the facility,

He also promised to supply data on monies acquired from vehicles traversing the bridge for the year 2011. Kaieteur News has not received this information to date.


In the past, there was public outcry against the high tolls being forced upon commuters and drivers using the structure.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Billy Ram Balgobin:

You all don't have anything else to do besides bitching and moaning everyday on GNI?

Better moan on GNI than lying on your stomach whilst big stick slides in and out of you.

Mr.T
Originally Posted by Mr.T:
Originally Posted by Billy Ram Balgobin:

You all don't have anything else to do besides bitching and moaning everyday on GNI?

Better moan on GNI than lying on your stomach whilst big stick slides in and out of you.

 Must be painful for you lying on your stomach. Thank you for sharing your experience on GNI.  We will tolerate the Bitching and Moaning.

 

Billy Ram Balgobin

the AFC dunces recycling old grievances again, now they get an uneducated former ferry captain to pronounce that the tolls too high. You would think these idiots would be referencing a study of similar projects around the world and compare the cost to toll ratio. hahahhha 

FM
Originally Posted by Wally:

BGurd people are punishing because of the toll. This bridge should be a public service not a for profit generating machine.

The bridge was built with the understanding that it would pay for itself. Private investors who financed the project would not have done so otherwise. This is the price you pay for progress, right here in the US the same fools who cry about tolls in Guyana even thought they don't live there will fork out 25US to cross a bridge without complaints. 

FM
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:

the AFC dunces recycling old grievances again, now they get an uneducated former ferry captain to pronounce that the tolls too high. You would think these idiots would be referencing a study of similar projects around the world and compare the cost to toll ratio. hahahhha 

The tolls are too high for the everyday working man.  Building a bridge with private money which is then expected pay for itself with tolls is the wrong model for such a vital infrastructure.

FM
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:

the AFC dunces recycling old grievances again, now they get an uneducated former ferry captain to pronounce that the tolls too high. You would think these idiots would be referencing a study of similar projects around the world and compare the cost to toll ratio. hahahhha 

You are certainly a brainless jackass. Are your parents siblings?

Mitwah
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Wally:

BGurd people are punishing because of the toll. This bridge should be a public service not a for profit generating machine.

The bridge was built with the understanding that it would pay for itself. Private investors who financed the project would not have done so otherwise. This is the price you pay for progress, right here in the US the same fools who cry about tolls in Guyana even thought they don't live there will fork out 25US to cross a bridge without complaints. 

You have shit in your head. But then you are a low life maggot. Get back to your latrine pit and enjoy life.

Mitwah

guyana does not have a capitalist class what it has is an economy controlled by a group of Oligarchs.  The principle role of the oligarch is to create a monopoly to protect their capital from competition.  We must ensure that the oligarch remains outside of public works.

FM
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:

the AFC dunces recycling old grievances again, now they get an uneducated former ferry captain to pronounce that the tolls too high. You would think these idiots would be referencing a study of similar projects around the world and compare the cost to toll ratio. hahahhha 

The tolls are too high for the everyday working man.  Building a bridge with private money which is then expected pay for itself with tolls is the wrong model for such a vital infrastructure.


The other option would have been no bridge. Welcome to reality. You pay for what you get. Guyanese need to get out of the entitlement mentality and realize that infrastructure cost money and is not charity. It is funny how many of you willingly pay high tolls in the US and CA and complain when you have to pay in Guyana.

FM
Originally Posted by Wally:

guyana does not have a capitalist class what it has is an economy controlled by a group of Oligarchs.  The principle role of the oligarch is to create a monopoly to protect their capital from competition.  We must ensure that the oligarch remains outside of public works.

Why is it so difficult for you to understand that without the private investment this bridge would not have been possible. The bridge have to pay for itself via tolls. Now enterprising private Guyanese investors can always provide ferry or speed boat service at a lower cost to cater for the poorer folks who need to cross the river.

FM
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Wally:

guyana does not have a capitalist class what it has is an economy controlled by a group of Oligarchs.  The principle role of the oligarch is to create a monopoly to protect their capital from competition.  We must ensure that the oligarch remains outside of public works.

Why is it so difficult for you to understand that without the private investment this bridge would not have been possible. The bridge have to pay for itself via tolls. Now enterprising private Guyanese investors can always provide ferry or speed boat service at a lower cost to cater for the poorer folks who need to cross the river.

Who are the private investors?

Mitwah
Originally Posted by Mitwah:
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Wally:

guyana does not have a capitalist class what it has is an economy controlled by a group of Oligarchs.  The principle role of the oligarch is to create a monopoly to protect their capital from competition.  We must ensure that the oligarch remains outside of public works.

Why is it so difficult for you to understand that without the private investment this bridge would not have been possible. The bridge have to pay for itself via tolls. Now enterprising private Guyanese investors can always provide ferry or speed boat service at a lower cost to cater for the poorer folks who need to cross the river.

Who are the private investors?

Surprise surprise, where are your usual "jackass"  comment, like you just return from India where they gave you a brain transplant. hahahahahahah

 

The private investors include National Insurance Scheme, Hand in Hand Insurance Company, New Building Society, Demerara Distillers Limited and Beharry Group of Companies, Automotive, Queens Atlantic Investment,
All of the commercial banks have invested in the Berbice Bridge as did some insurance companies.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Mitwah:
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Wally:

guyana does not have a capitalist class what it has is an economy controlled by a group of Oligarchs.  The principle role of the oligarch is to create a monopoly to protect their capital from competition.  We must ensure that the oligarch remains outside of public works.

Why is it so difficult for you to understand that without the private investment this bridge would not have been possible. The bridge have to pay for itself via tolls. Now enterprising private Guyanese investors can always provide ferry or speed boat service at a lower cost to cater for the poorer folks who need to cross the river.

Who are the private investors?

Surprise surprise, where are your usual "jackass"  comment, like you just return from India where they gave you a brain transplant. hahahahahahah

 

The private investors include National Insurance Scheme, Hand in Hand Insurance Company, New Building Society, Demerara Distillers Limited and Beharry Group of Companies, Automotive, Queens Atlantic Investment,
All of the commercial banks have invested in the Berbice Bridge as did some insurance companies.

Today  is diwali. I have a lighted a diya for you. It seems  to be working. Now tells us how much of the taxpayers and pensioners money is invested versus private funds.

Mitwah
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:

the AFC dunces recycling old grievances again, now they get an uneducated former ferry captain to pronounce that the tolls too high. You would think these idiots would be referencing a study of similar projects around the world and compare the cost to toll ratio. hahahhha 

The tolls are too high for the everyday working man.  Building a bridge with private money which is then expected pay for itself with tolls is the wrong model for such a vital infrastructure.


The other option would have been no bridge. Welcome to reality. You pay for what you get. Guyanese need to get out of the entitlement mentality and realize that infrastructure cost money and is not charity. It is funny how many of you willingly pay high tolls in the US and CA and complain when you have to pay in Guyana.

Gentlemen,

The Berbice river bridge was the best thing the government did for people in Corentyne. I remember when we had to wait in line for at least 6 hours to cross the river to go to Skeldon.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×