Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Brazil Discovers How To Increase Employment With Near-Zero Economic Growth

 

Brazil may be living in a labor bubble.

Not because labor costs are rising; they should be rising. Brazilian workers are in demand and have spent generations earning peanuts. The government, and private sector, are finally catching up.

But in the process of rising wages there is rising employment. Call it a job market bubble, but Brazil has discovered how to keep lowering unemployment data even when economic growth is a measly 0.2 percent.

<cite class="box_byline clearfix" style="margin: 0px; padding: 0px; border: 0px none; outline: 0px none; font-size: 0px; vertical-align: baseline; background-color: transparent; max-width: 175px; box-shadow: 1px 1px 6px #b8b8b8;">Forbes Staff</cite>

Brazil announced Thursday that the country’s May unemployment rate was just 5.8 percent, a decrease of 0.2 percentage points against April 2012, and a 0.6 percent decrease over May 2011. According to the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistic, the unemployed population (1.4 million persons) was stable in relation to the previous month, but actually posted a drop of 7.1 percent against May 2011 (or 107,000 fewer unemployed).

How the country managed to do this is unclear.  Brazil’s first quarter growth was under half a percent.  And recent Central Bank data has the economy growing less than the U.S. economy, under 2 percent growth over the last 12 months.  By comparison, the U.S. economy is expanding, but the labor market is stable to contracting. Meanwhile, the Brazilian economy is contracting, but the job market is stable to increasing the number of new hires.

Brazil’s employed population (23 million) recorded a 1.2 percent increase compared to April, and a 2.5 percent increase over the previous year, for a total of 554,000 additional jobs. The number of workers with a formal employment contract, rather than a cash only arrangement, popular in Brazil’s large and informal domestic workers and other household services segment, did not change in relation to April (11.2 million). In the annual comparison, there was an increase of 3.9 percent added to Brazilian payrolls, accounting for additional 427,000  jobs with a formal employment contract.

No changes were recorded in the real average income over the previous month, however.  Average monthly income is R$ 1,725.60 ($850), but rose 4.9 percent compared with May 2011.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Good question!

80 million people (27% of total population 300m) in the US have jobs compared to Brazil's 23 million (11% of total population 200m). This talks about the size of the US economy.

 

The unemployment figures make Brazil look much better than the US until you learn that the unemployed are measured by counting only those who look for jobs, instead of those who should be looking for jobs.

 

A better measure of the state of the economy can be obtained by counting new  jobs and deducting those who lost the jobs. This is where you can see that Brazil does better, because it has generated 2.5 million jobs in a year in comparison to around 500 thousand jobs in the US.

 

Originally Posted by baseman:

This is difficult to benchmark vs the USA for example.  How do they measure the "unemployed".

FM
Originally Posted by Lucas:

Good question!

80 million people (27% of total population 300m) in the US have jobs compared to Brazil's 23 million (11% of total population 200m). This talks about the size of the US economy.

 

The unemployment figures make Brazil look much better than the US until you learn that the unemployed are measured by counting only those who look for jobs, instead of those who should be looking for jobs.

 

A better measure of the state of the economy can be obtained by counting new  jobs and deducting those who lost the jobs. This is where you can see that Brazil does better, because it has generated 2.5 million jobs in a year in comparison to around 500 thousand jobs in the US.

 

Originally Posted by baseman:

This is difficult to benchmark vs the USA for example.  How do they measure the "unemployed".

Correct, net new jobs created would be a better barometer however, given one nation is developing and the other is developed, it's still a questionable benchmark.  Brazil is still a developing nation with large numbers of people in transition from "self-employed" to the structured economy.  The US is struggling for sure, but to say one is doing a better job than the other based of the stats you presented is probably not correct.  The problems of the US is very different from the challenges of Brazil.

FM

You Are Absolutely Right!

Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Lucas:

Good question!

80 million people (27% of total population 300m) in the US have jobs compared to Brazil's 23 million (11% of total population 200m). This talks about the size of the US economy.

 

The unemployment figures make Brazil look much better than the US until you learn that the unemployed are measured by counting only those who look for jobs, instead of those who should be looking for jobs.

 

A better measure of the state of the economy can be obtained by counting new  jobs and deducting those who lost the jobs. This is where you can see that Brazil does better, because it has generated 2.5 million jobs in a year in comparison to around 500 thousand jobs in the US.

 

Originally Posted by baseman:

This is difficult to benchmark vs the USA for example.  How do they measure the "unemployed".

Correct, net new jobs created would be a better barometer however, given one nation is developing and the other is developed, it's still a questionable benchmark.  Brazil is still a developing nation with large numbers of people in transition from "self-employed" to the structured economy.  The US is struggling for sure, but to say one is doing a better job than the other based of the stats you presented is probably not correct.  The problems of the US is very different from the challenges of Brazil.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×