RC Church, Fmr. ERC Chairman differ on racial incitement by Guyana Chronicle | | Print | |
Written by Denis Scott Chabrol |
Tuesday, 03 July 2012 22:17 |
The Roman Catholic Church on Tuesday roasted the state-owned Guyana Chronicle for seeking to incite race-hate in an editorial that sought to pit African Guyanese youths against East Indians.
“The contents of this editorial crossed by no small measure the acceptable lines of responsible opinion choosing instead to use thinly disguised inflammatory language,” states the Justice of Peace Commission (JPC) in a statement.
Guyana Chronicle Editor-in-Chief, Mark Ramotar, when contacted, declined to immediately react; instead saying he would do so on Wednesday.
However, former Chairman of the Ethnic Relations Commission, Juan Edghill disagrees that the editorial is inciting but based on well-known facts that would have been gathered over a number of years.
“Out of my experience at the Ethnic Relations Commission and the tools that we would have used to analyse statements in the past, the fact that it’s being reported in a manner in which it was reported, I don’t see the editorial as seeming to want to incite or excite.
One part of the July 3 editorial reads:
“Black youths are socialised by opposition leaders to think that Indians robbed them to get rich, so they automatically feel that they have to wrest by force, even murder, anything Indians have. Hatred of Indians is ingrained into their psyche. Many Indian persons, who grew up in the arms of black people in rural communities have today become fearful anytime a black youth gets too close to them.
So the PNC did not only make Indians their victims, but they also made their own supporters their victims, because the most innocent, clean-living black youths are just as suspect as the perpetrators as a result of the difficulty to tell the difference between a criminal and a decent person.”
The Guyana Chronicle warned PNC leaders that one young Black men would not only attack Indians but would “turn their voracious ways toward PNC supporters, which has been happening for a while now.”
Saying it was “deeply disturbed” by the state-owned newspaper’s editorial, the JPC cautioned against such comments from any source in a plural society with a continuing history of delicately poised race relations.
“The JPC believes that the reckless posture taken in the editorial represents a patent ethnic appeal and could encourage incitement,” the arm of the RC Church added.
The JPC observed that words used in the editorial seek to castigate and condemn one race to convey a particular message.
But the former ERC Chairman said all Black youths were not painted with one brush as criminals.
“It did not categorise all Black youths as being of criminal intent. It was careful not to do that and I don’t think it has bordered on incitement or excitement. It is strongly worded but I don’t think it is bordered on incitement or excitement,” said Edghill who is a now Junior Minister of Finance.
According to the commission, the Racial Hostility Act outlaws conduct tending to excite or attempting to excite hostility or ill-will against any section of the public or against any person on the grounds of their or his race.
Rather than sowing seeds of distrust, antagonism and reciprocal hatreds, the Roman Catholic organisation urges the Guyana Chronicle and all media houses to to exercise greater responsibility in putting forward opinion pieces in terms of the positions taken and how they are presented to the reading public.
“There is no justification for any such statements, appeals, or positions, at any time from any source,” states the JPC.
The JPC recommended that the emphasis should be-and could-be more appropriately focused on the struggle for consensus and harmony that has eluded us for so long.
The editorial sought to highlight the impact of opposition activism such as the ongoing protests by Lindeners against the hike in electricity rates. The newspaper argued that while Lindeners claimed that they are being disadvantaged, other Guyanese are paying to subsidise electricity in the bauxite-dependent town.
The Guyana Chronicle also noted that hatred is being vented at Guyana Sugar Corporation workers on the wrongful premise that the sugar industry workers comprise only Indo-Guyanese. On the contrary, the newspaper said there is a great number of supporters of the Peoples National Congress and Alliance For Change who work in Guysuco and are being negatively affected from the political fallout.