Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Govt. in talks with Amaila Falls Chinese contractor to build new DHB

Mar 13, 2022 News -- Source -- Kaieteur News Online -- https://www.kaieteurnewsonline...or-to-build-new-dhb/

By Davina Bagot

Kaieteur News – The Government of Guyana is currently in talks with the company that will be constructing the Amaila Falls Hydropwer Project, China Railway First Group, to also build a new bridge over the Demerara River to link Regions Three and Four.

On Saturday, Minister within the Ministry of Public Works, Deodat Indar explained that a consortium of companies have been engaged as they were the second lowest bidder for the new Demerara Harbour Bridge (DHB).

He was keen to note that the discussions with the companies are not yet complete and that there was still a long way to go in finalising an agreement.

The companies are China Railway Construction Corporation International Limited in joint venture with China Railway Caribbean Company Limited; and China Railway Engineering Bureau Group Company Limited.
Three financial proposals were submitted by the firms for the project of US$260,852,464, US$260,852,464 and US$300,000,000.

It is understood that China Railway First Group, China Railway Construction Corporation International Limited, China Railway Caribbean Company Limited and China Railway Engineering Bureau Group Company Limited are all subsidiaries of the parent company ‘China Railway Group Limited’.

Research conducted by Kaieteur News show that the company is headquartered in Beijing, China. The firm said on its website that China Railway Group Limited “is a super-large corporate conglomerate engaged in engineering survey, design and construction, industrial equipment manufacturing, real estate development, resources and mining development, financial investment, and other fields.”

It also boasted of being one of the world’s largest construction and engineering contractors, being listed among Fortune Global 500 for 16 consecutive years.

This publication also found that the major shareholder of the company is the state-owned China Railway Engineering Corporation (CRECG).
The Chinese company said it has long enjoyed a good reputation in the global market and since the construction of the 1,861-kilometre Tanzania-Zambia Railway in the 1970s, the company has successively built a large number of “excellent projects” in countries such as Asia, Africa, Europe, South America and the Atlantic. In fact, it said it presently has representative offices and carries out projects in more than 90 countries and regions around the world.
About the new DHB

The contract for the new DHB was first awarded to another Chinese firm, China State Construction Engineering Corporation Limited to the tune of $53.7B. Vice President, Bharrat Jagdeo announced earlier in February, during an interview with a foreign media house that the contract was pulled from the firm as the cost of financing was too high.

During the interview, the Vice President said, “we have just terminated the negotiations with them (CSCEC) because the cost of financing is too high.”

The Chinese firm had secured the contract to build the new bridge under a Design-Build-Finance (DBF) model.

During the reading of the Budget 2022, however, Senior Minister with responsibility for Finance, Dr. Ashni Singh had announced that this year, some $21.1B has been allocated for the project.

The government was aiming to start construction of the new four-lane fly-over bridge by the end of 2021.

With a contract still to be signed, the proposed location for the New Demerara River Bridge will see the structure being laid between Nandy Park on the East Bank Demerara and La Grange on the western end of the Demerara River.

Amaila Falls Hydropower Project
The Amaila Falls Hydropower Project has been marred in controversy ever since its proposal more than 10 years ago. The previous administration had completely thrown out the project, as it believed the venture was not feasible.

However, the People’s Progressive Party (PPP) government is running full speed ahead with this project, to be executed by China Railway First Group.

The project is expected to cost some US$700M, but Guyanese will not be paying for the project up front. Instead, the country will be purchasing electricity from the plant at an average cost of $7.7 cents, as the project is being pursued under a Build Own Operate Transfer (BOOT) model, in which Guyana would, in 20 years’ time, take over ownership of the project.

Under this agreement, the owner—China Railway—will assume all of the debts and equity and that power will be purchased by the Guyana Power and Light Inc. (GPL).

“GPL will buy all of the power under a PPA (Power Purchase Agreement),” and the contractor will have to assume the majority of the risks in the project, Project Head, Winston Brassington said.

Even though this assurance has been given, Guyana is still burdened by six of the most dangerous risks associated with the project. For instance, the Guyana Power and Light Incorporated (GPL) in addition to agreeing to purchase all of the power to be delivered to Georgetown from the 156 megawatt (MW) Plant has also agreed to assume the hydrological risks involved in the project.

As such, it would mean that GPL would bear the incurred liability whenever the Amaila Falls runs dry or if the 23 square kilometres reservoir is unable to feed the hydro plant. Secondly, Guyana will be responsible for political force majeure, that is, if the government changes its mind about the project, it would still have to pay the Chinese contractor for its investment.

The third risk Guyana will stand, along with China Railway, is ‘other force majeure’. This relates to damage to the plant, by unforeseen circumstances.

Two other risks will be borne by GPL if the Amaila Falls project fails to meet the electricity demand.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Oiiii Trench_Crapo ...

Focus is BOOT, BOOT, B-O-O-T

B - Build

O - Own

O - Operate

T - Transfer

For the Amaila Hydroelectric Power project.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
@GTAngler posted:

For some reason I seem to remember this being the same contractor who pulled out of this project before.

The previous contractor was the famous Fip Motilall who never build a latrine in he life…

sachin_05
@Former Member posted:

Oiiii Trench_Crapo ...

Focus is BOOT, BOOT, B-O-O-T

B - Build

O - Own

O - Operate

T - Transfer

For the Amaila Hydroelectric Power project.

Bigger the BOOT the more shit it holds.

GTAngler

Solar power can cost US$200M less than Amaila hydro project – Economist

May 03, 2022 News -- Source -- Kaieteur News Online -- https://www.kaieteurnewsonline...o-project-economist/

Kaieteur News – Citing an overall reduction in the cost to develop solar power generation across the globe today, Economist Elson Low estimates that Guyana can save at least US$200 million if it pursues this renewable option, rather than the hydropower project at Amaila, Region Eight.

A solar power plant in Barbados (PC: XenogyRE)

He presented this argument during a weekly commentary aired on the social media platform, Facebook.

Low, who holds a Bachelor’s Degree in political Science and Economics from a United States College, Amherst, explained that government will be pursuing 38 megawatts (MW) of electricity through a solar power project that is estimated to cost US$83.5 million. Using these figures, the Economist calculated that a 165MW solar power facility could cost around US$500 million, saving Guyana US$200 million when compared to the US$700 million Amaila hydro project. This US$500 million, according to him, would be the overall expenditure factoring in the land and cost to distribute the electricity.

He said that not only could Guyana save on cost, but also avoid some of the financial risks involved in the proposed hydropower project.

A prefeasibility study for the Amaila Falls project was conducted between 1974 and 1976. The Economist argued, therefore, that solar costs have reduced by over 80 percent in some cases since Amaila was conceived.

The Economist reasoned, “The cost of hydro versus solar, Amaila is supposed to be at seven cents per kilowatt hour that the government will purchase power from the Amaila at, however solar should be at two cents per kilowatt hour, maybe three cents, but around there, so even in that situation, solar is twice as cheap, twice as cheap, in some cases, three times cheaper rather than having hydro.”

He explained that the advancement of technological development has resulted in the massive reduction in costs to generate solar power. Low referenced a statement by the Head of the Guyana Energy Agency (GEA), Dr. Mahender Sharma, who told the International Energy Conference back in February that two hours of sunshine in Guyana can power the country for an entire year.

To this end, he said, “So clearly, the sun is shining, clearly, there is opportunity here, the question is why we are not making use of this glaring opportunity, rather we are going to go all the way across the country to Region Eight…and bring that electricity all the way back across to Georgetown. It truly boggles the mind.”

Low said that the government can set up a solar plant at the Wales Estate, West Bank Demerara where the Gas-to-Energy project is expected to be constructed.

According to him, “You can have a solar plant right there on the coast. You have all the land available to you, you don’t have to worry about the mountains and the rivers and the heavy rainfall and the forest; you have all of the infrastructure there already. You can produce the same amount of electric power and you don’t have to run all of these risks and it is in fact cheaper.”

After analysing the project, the Economist concluded that the Amaila Falls hydropower project is one of the worst he has ever come across.

He argued, “I am not using numbers from another country. I am not using numbers from another project in the past. I am not using estimates from some expert, I am using the government’s number from another project to show what this cost.”

The 165MW Amaila Falls project is pegged at US$700 million. It is being pursued under a Build Own Operate Transfer (BOOT) model, in which Guyana would be buying electricity from the hydro project at an estimated cost of about 7.7 cents per MW.

Although the government will not be investing in the project with upfront costs, Guyanese will have to carry the burden of that project, and after 20 years, the ownership would be transferred to Guyana from the Chinese contractor, China Railway First Group.

At the Energy Conference, Winston Brassington, the project head, while providing an update on the project said that, “like any large project, there is a lot of risks in these projects but most of these risks have been put to the developer.”

He, however, glided over the burdens Guyana will bear as a result of the project, even though the country is bracing to face six of the most dangerous risks associated with the project.

These include hydrological, which means if the falls run dry due to climate change, or if the 23 square kilometres reservoir is unable to feed the hydro plant, the Guyana Power and Light (GPL) would bear the incurred liability.

Secondly, Guyana will be responsible for political force majeure, that is, if the government changes its mind about the project, it would still have to pay the Chinese contractor for its investment.

The third risk Guyana will stand, along with China Railway, is ‘other force majeure’. This relates to damage to the plant, by unforeseen circumstances.

Two other risks will be borne by GPL if the Amaila Falls project fails to meet the electricity demand.

FM
Last edited by Former Member

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×