Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Green Pension Bill “shocking, obnoxious” – GHRA

… calls for it to be withdrawn

As outrage continues to mount over the proposed Hamilton Green Pension Bill 2016, which was tabled in the National Assembly, the Guyana Human Rights Association (GHRA) said it is “utterly shocked” at the proposal.
The Bill, which will be read for the first time on Monday, provides for Green to be paid a pension “based on the salary paid to the Prime Minister, as though he actually earned the said salary, taking into consideration his record of service as a legislator.”

Former Prime Minister Hamilton Green
Former Prime Minister Hamilton Green

It also provides for Green to receive all benefits provided for by the Former President (Benefits and Other Facilities) Act 2015. The value of these benefits are an annual pension of G$20,580,000, others benefits to the value of G$3.1 million annually, two vehicles provided and maintained by the State and two first-class annual airfares free transportation provided by the State.
Additionally, the former Prime Minister, who served in the position from 1985 to 1992, also qualifies for an ex-parliamentarian pension together with whatever benefits accrue from his period of Mayor of Georgetown.
In a statement on Saturday, the GHRA said the Prime Minister Hamilton Green Pension Act 2016 on the Order Paper is utterly shocking and called for the non-submission of what it called an “obnoxious” Bill.
In fact, the Rights Association went as far as to list several ground why the proposed Bill should not be submitted to Parliament, including the fact that there is no justification for the provisions of the Bill except for “cronyism”.
It was added too that the Bill is insulting to Guyanese taxpayers of this generation, who are prominently wage-earners, (rather than businesses or private professionals who mostly don’t pay taxes according to the GRA) to shoulder the burden of excessive pension for people who have so curtailed this generation’s life chances.
The GHRA also outlined that to date, Green, a former Mayor of Georgetown, never apologised for the humiliation, hardship and violence to which the Guyanese people were subjected during his harrowing term of office, adding that had Dr Jagan in 1992 not ‘drawn a veil’ over the past in the interests of social peace, Green would have found himself facing the courts.
Another ground proffered by the Rights Association is that the idea that former Presidents and senior politicians deserve to be treated as ‘Princes of the City’ with excessive pensions and benefits, reinforces rather than undermines the repugnant notion that the purpose of politics is to enrich politicians.
The GHRA statement went on to say too that a personalised Bill to reward Green for a lifetime of politics marked by incompetence and divisiveness is provocative in the context of the current Administration’s anti-corruption campaign. It also noted that the Guyanese Parliament is still to distinguish itself for the quality of its contribution to public life; while adding that if the Bill under discussion is entertained; its reputation would be further eroded by the ridicule it would justly attract.
Moreover the GHRA pointed out in the release that since Green’s entire political career reflects the attributes that have kept Guyana ethnically polarized and, for this reason, securely anchored at the bottom of all Caribbean indicators of social and economic progress in the modern era.
“As a young and ruthless politician in the early 1960s, his name figured prominently in the violence from which this society has still to recover. During the 1970s and 1980s he was a leading Government figure in the political repression reflected by Guyana heading the list of countries with most refugee applications to Canada and mass exodus of Guyanese of all backgrounds to any other country they could find respite.
Those years saw bizarre hardships imposed on the Guyanese people including being criminalised for possession of onions and garlic, blocks-long queues around gas stations due to gasoline shortages and outbreaks of beri-beri,” the statement from the commission details.
Moreover, it was pointed out that during the last two decades, Green, as Mayor of Georgetown, had presided over its physical decay. Despite a career marked by incompetence and divisiveness, Hamilton Green, now well over 80 years of age, was appointed as Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Central Housing and Planning Authority (CH&PA), the release added.
“Thanks to the legacy of economic and social turmoil for which he and other leaders were responsible it is ironic that Guyanese of the same age group as Hamilton Green are now condemned to live on old-age pensions of G$17,000, while he complains at having to eke out a living on his pension of G$100,000 plus his benefits from being Mayor,” the rights body noted.
This bill has raised many eyebrows, with many denouncing the fact that the former Prime Minister, under the People’s National Congress Demond Hoyte rule, name was included in on the Bill. In fact, current Prime Minister Moses Nagamootoo said on Friday that singling out Green for a legislative package that statutes pension and other benefits of a former Prime Minister might not have been the best course of action since the package should have been tailored to suit all former Prime Ministers of Guyana.

http://guyanatimesgy.com/green...king-obnoxious-ghra/

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Nagamootoo prefers to erase Green’s name from former Prime Minister’s pension bill

 
Former Prime Minister, Hamilton Green.

Former Prime Minister, Hamilton Green.

Prime Minister Moses Nagamootoo on Friday said the draft law to facilitate a pension and benefits to former Prime Minister, Hamilton Green probably should not have named him but left open for all current and future ex-prime ministers.

“It may be an issue that we may want to re-look as to why it was the Hamilton Green pension bill and not former Prime Minister pension bill… If you want something to be seen as equitable, it has to have a broader rubric that allows it maybe to have it as a futuristic piece of legislation rather than simply trying to go back to correct an anomaly,” he said.

Green, who is the only surviving former Prime Minister, has expressed concern that the Bill to be tabled by Finance Minister, Winston Jordan next Monday in the House has named him specifically. Samuel Hinds receives a former President’s pension and other benefits having served as Head of State and Head of Government from March to December, 1997 when President Cheddi Jagan died.

Nagamootoo also announced that steps would soon be taken to ensure that all former parliamentarians and ministers receive pensions that are at current levels. “There is representation before Cabinet for adjustment to the pensions of those who survived since Independence in our National Assembly and who are still getting pension based on the salary at that time,” he said.

In apparent reference to Green’s association with the People’s National Congress (PNC)-led dictatorship that ended in 1992 with the first free and fair elections since 1964, the Prime Minister urged Guyanese to bury the hatchet. “This nation has to be able to put aside its own bitterness that has contaminated all of us and become part of our political culture, of hate and being judgmental and being angry when we deal with people who had held offices in this country,” Nagamootoo said. He added that “apart from all the political postures that we may assume about each other, he held the position of Prime Minister and therefore I believe this is  a once for all piece of legislation because you couldn’t do it otherwise to allow him to enjoy the pension of a Prime Minister and that a Prime Minister ought to get.”

Nagamootoo said when the Bill is passed in favour of Hamilton Green, it would not be retroactive to 1985 or 1992 when Green was Prime Minister but from when it is approved by the House.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×