Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Guyana should emulate South Africa in the teaching of Hindi

GUYANESE (and other Caribbean nations) could also take note of the South African Indo cultural strides.  

In Guyana and Trinidad, the new chutney songs that emerge are just like the old ones – except for the lyrics – same (very lively) beat (to gyrate), no variety, same vulgarity and same ugliness. In South Africa, the chutney music, though lively, has a distinct harmonium sound, accompanied equivocally by the dholak, and there is a wide variety of tempo. It is a joy to listen and be part of the scene – unlike in Guyana and Trinidad, where low-life and vulgarity is the rule rather than the exception. (Chutney music aspirers would do well to listen to the Bhojpuri music (available on the internet) to learn about beats, tunes, rhythm, musical instruments used, etc.)
Guyana should also emulate South Africa to allow the teaching of Hindi in schools. Considering our linguistic and cultural heritage, it is prudent to allow students to learn Hindi basics. Our Guyanese dialect has scores of Hindi-derived words, and Indian music and culture are a distinct entity in our country.

DEVANAND BHAGWAN
India

Replies sorted oldest to newest

bro, are you Mr Bhagwan too?

 

In Guyana and Trinidad, the new chutney songs that emerge are just like the old ones – except for the lyrics – same (very lively) beat (to gyrate), no variety, same vulgarity and same ugliness.

FM
Originally Posted by JoKer:
Originally Posted by redux:

when did Guyana dis-"allow" the teaching of Hindi in schools?

 

I don't believe it's offered as a part of the curriculum

different issue

FM
Originally Posted by Stinger:

bro, are you Mr Bhagwan too?

 

In Guyana and Trinidad, the new chutney songs that emerge are just like the old ones – except for the lyrics – same (very lively) beat (to gyrate), no variety, same vulgarity and same ugliness.

 

LMAO LMAO

 

No but great minds do think alike

FM
Originally Posted by JoKer:

Guyana should emulate South Africa in the teaching of Hindi

GUYANESE (and other Caribbean nations) could also take note of the South African Indo cultural strides. 

DEVANAND BHAGWAN
India

Hindi is of no use to t h general population. Spanish, Portuguese, French are all superior options. We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week. That can still happen.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Danyael:
Originally Posted by JoKer:

Guyana should emulate South Africa in the teaching of Hindi

GUYANESE (and other Caribbean nations) could also take note of the South African Indo cultural strides. 

DEVANAND BHAGWAN
India

Hindi is of no use to t h general population. Spanish, Portuguese, French are all superior options. We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week. That can still happen.

Now we learn that you were brought up a hindu?

FM
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Danyael:
Originally Posted by JoKer:

Guyana should emulate South Africa in the teaching of Hindi

GUYANESE (and other Caribbean nations) could also take note of the South African Indo cultural strides. 

DEVANAND BHAGWAN
India

Hindi is of no use to t h general population. Spanish, Portuguese, French are all superior options. We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week. That can still happen.

Now we learn that you were brought up a hindu?

I never said I was brought up a hindu. I was raised in a Hindu and Christian household. I know the rituals of both. I however was never of the hindu religion. I can say I was a christian because I attended episcopalian services most of my childhood. That the Pandit taught hindi at night and many in the village attended is a different story.

FM

do we have that many teachers who can actually teach it. One of the regrets I have when I left Guyana was that I never took an interest in learning Urdu from my Grandparents. Also the shoemaking trade from my Uncle. I was too busy playing and hustling the girls.

Amral

What is the reason for taxpayers to pay for Hindi lessons.  Every significant Indian businessman and gov't officials speaks English, and Hindi isn't the native language of all of them either.

 

Portuguese is essential given that Guyana will be a de facto province of Brazil within the next 10 years.

FM
Originally Posted by caribny:

What is the reason for taxpayers to pay for Hindi lessons.  Every significant Indian businessman and gov't officials speaks English, and Hindi isn't the native language of all of them either.

 

Portuguese is essential given that Guyana will be a de facto province of Brazil within the next 10 years.

The children in Guyana schools can hardly cope with English. Why put hem through more stress? This will only give the teachers an excuse to continue to brutalise the kids.

FM
Originally Posted by Danyael:
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Danyael:
Originally Posted by JoKer:

Guyana should emulate South Africa in the teaching of Hindi

GUYANESE (and other Caribbean nations) could also take note of the South African Indo cultural strides. 

DEVANAND BHAGWAN
India

Hindi is of no use to t h general population. Spanish, Portuguese, French are all superior options. We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week. That can still happen.

Now we learn that you were brought up a hindu?

I never said I was brought up a hindu. I was raised in a Hindu and Christian household. I know the rituals of both. I however was never of the hindu religion. I can say I was a christian because I attended episcopalian services most of my childhood. That the Pandit taught hindi at night and many in the village attended is a different story.

What a tangled web we weave when we set out to deceive. I don't see how you could claim that you were not brought up a Hindu when you clearly stated : 

We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week

FM
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Danyael:
Originally Posted by BGurd_See:
Originally Posted by Danyael:
Originally Posted by JoKer:

Guyana should emulate South Africa in the teaching of Hindi

GUYANESE (and other Caribbean nations) could also take note of the South African Indo cultural strides. 

DEVANAND BHAGWAN
India

Hindi is of no use to t h general population. Spanish, Portuguese, French are all superior options. We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week. That can still happen.

Now we learn that you were brought up a hindu?

I never said I was brought up a hindu. I was raised in a Hindu and Christian household. I know the rituals of both. I however was never of the hindu religion. I can say I was a christian because I attended episcopalian services most of my childhood. That the Pandit taught hindi at night and many in the village attended is a different story.

What a tangled web we weave when we set out to deceive. I don't see how you could claim that you were not brought up a Hindu when you clearly stated : 

We learnt hindi at he mandir at night 3 times a week

Why is the location is immediately to be assumed to be a conduit for religious indoctrination? Churches were locations for many community events inclusive of teaching language. No one has to lie about simple things as you do.

FM

Do they actually teach Hindi in South Africa?

 

Why to teach a language that Indians themselves do not want to speak? All Indians want to be English and take pride on that.

FM
Originally Posted by skeldon_man:
Originally Posted by caribny:

What is the reason for taxpayers to pay for Hindi lessons.  Every significant Indian businessman and gov't officials speaks English, and Hindi isn't the native language of all of them either.

 

Portuguese is essential given that Guyana will be a de facto province of Brazil within the next 10 years.

The children in Guyana schools can hardly cope with English. Why put hem through more stress? This will only give the teachers an excuse to continue to brutalise the kids.

True.  Increasingly when Guyanese speak what they think is standard English, subtitles are being used.  An American visited Guyana and was amused by the fact that Guyanese think that they speak English. 

 

But when the last two presidents cannot say the word "THINGS", why the shock.  One day they are going to arrive some where talking about "TINGS", and some one will offer them that Jamaican grapefruit flavored soda.

 

 

FM
Originally Posted by Lucas:

They would be amused to find out that Australians also think they speak english...but Australians are white so that's OK, that OZ dialect must be English.

Given that the Aussie dialect is derived DIRECTLY from British speech patterns it is English.  Guyanese cant make that claim.

 

Jagdeo and Ramotar make valiant attempts to speak what sometimes passes as standard internationally accepted English, but don't always succeed.  If they spent more time listening to the opposition parties, at the very least their standard of English will improve, if nothing else.

FM
Last edited by Former Member

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×