Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Hamas holds two Israelis in Gaza Strip

Calm reaction reflects tense but quiet working relationship that has emerged between Israel and Hamas since devastating war

By: Daniel Estrin Associated Press, Published on Thu Jul 09 2015, Source

 

JERUSALEM — Two Israeli citizens are being held in the Gaza Strip, at least one of them by the Hamas militant group, Israeli authorities said Thursday.

 

The announcement, made after months of secrecy, raised memories of the case of Gilad Schalit, an Israeli soldier captured by Hamas in a cross-border raid and released five years later in a prisoner swap, or the deadly kidnappings of three Israeli teens by Hamas militants in the West Bank last summer.

 

But Thursday’s news was not accompanied by the nationwide panic that occurred with the previous two cases — perhaps because the two missing Israelis were not violently captured but also a reflection of a tense but quiet working relationship that has emerged between Israel and Hamas since a devastating war a year ago.

 

Avraham Mangisto, an Israeli of Ethiopian descent in his late 20s, “independently” crossed the border fence into the Gaza Strip on Sept. 7 last year, nearly two weeks after the end of the Israel-Gaza war, said the Israeli defence body responsible for Palestinian civilian affairs. It gave no further details of why he crossed into the Palestinian territory.

 

The Co-ordinator of Government Activities in the Territories said the second Israeli citizen being held in Gaza is a Bedouin Arab man from Israel’s Negev desert. Officials refused to say how long he has been held in Gaza or how he got there. They also would not say which group had him in custody.

 

Bedouin make up a small group within Israel’s Arab minority, numbering about 180,000.

 

COGAT said that “according to credible intelligence,” Mangisto is being held “against his will” by Hamas. It said “Israel has appealed (to) international and regional interlocutors to demand his immediate release and verify his well-being.”

 

“This is a humanitarian matter and I expect those holding him to treat him properly and to return him in full health,” Israeli President Reuven Rivlin in a statement.

 

It was not clear why Israel decided to come forward with the news on Thursday. But Khaled Mashaal, the head of Hamas’ political bureau, may have forced its hand by telling the London-based Al-Araby Al-Jadeed newspaper late Tuesday that Israel had asked Hamas through a European mediator to release “two soldiers and two bodies.”

 

Israeli media report that the bodies of Israeli soldiers Oron Shaul and Hadar Goldin, killed during combat in Gaza last summer, are thought to be held by Hamas.

 

Mashaal said Hamas told the mediator that it would not hold negotiations with the “prisoners” Hamas has, nor would it release information about them or their condition, until Israel releases Palestinian prisoners rearrested after being freed in a 2011 high-profile prisoner swap, in which Israel released more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners in exchange for captive Israeli soldier Schalit.

 

Israeli media said Israel had turned to international channels to appeal for Mangisto’s release on humanitarian grounds because he was a civilian, not a soldier.

 

Israeli Channel 2 TV said Mengisto arrived at an Israeli beach on the Gaza border the evening of Sept. 7, left behind his bag and crossed into Gaza through a breach in the border fence apparently left from movement of Israeli tanks during the Israel-Gaza war.

 

The 50-day war last summer between the Islamic militant Hamas group and Israel left 2,200 Palestinians and 73 people in Israel dead.

 

Israel and Hamas, an Islamic group sworn to Israel’s destruction, are bitter enemies. But both sides have largely honoured a cease-fire that ended last year’s war — their third since Hamas seized control of Gaza in 2007. While they have no formal relations, both sides have worked to keep things quiet, in part to avoid another flare-up in fighting and also in recognition of a rising threat posed by extremist Salafist groups that draw inspiration from the Islamic State group.

 

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had been in touch with Mengisto’s parents and Lior Lotan, a retired Israeli army colonel, was handling negotiations to return Mengisto to Israel, Channel 2 TV reported.

 

“This is a difficult humanitarian matter, because my brother is not in the best of health,” said Ilan Mangisto to reporters. He called on Hamas to free him immediately, and asked Israel and the international community to exert pressure to lead to his release.

 

He did not elaborate on Mangisto’s health, but Israeli Channel 2 TV said Mangisto was depressed following the death of his brother.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Occupation Forces conduct military exercises near Gaza Strip for full day

July 09, 2015, 12 hours ago, National News, Source

 

The Israeli Occupation Forces (IOF) on Thursday announced their plan to conduct military exercises throughout the day in areas surrounding the Gaza strip, with the goal of preparing against Palestinian attacks on Israeli targets.

 

The official website of the Israeli Occupation Forces stated that the training would begin in the afternoon and that it would only last one day.

 

The website also stated that the training is a part of the IOF’s 2015 strategy aimed at preparing the army against potential future risks.

 

The exercise coincides with the anniversary of Operation Protective Edge, Israel’s war on the Gaza strip last summer which resulted in over 2,250 casualties, the majority of whom were civilians.

FM

ANALYSIS: Does Hamas have a bargaining chip in negotiations?

July 09, 2015, 7 hours ago, Politics, PNN/Gaza, Source

 

Israeli court’s lifting of a gag order today, concerning the disappearance of two Israeli citizens in Gaza, sheds some light on recent diplomatic attempts between Hamas and Israel, who have reportedly been holding indirect talks for months.

 

An Israeli of Ethiopian origin, Avera Mengistu, 28, was taken into Hamas custody 10 months ago when he disappeared into Gaza by jumping the Erez border fence. Less is known about the second citizen, a Palestinian Arab with Israeli citizenship who crossed into Gaza in April. The working assumption of Israeli officials is that both are being held by Hamas, but Mengistu’s whereabouts are unknown, Haaretz reports.

 

Mixed reports are emerging regarding Mengistu’s fate, and it remains unknown whether he is presently in Hamas custody, or if he was released through tunnels leading to Egypt shortly after Hamas confirmed he was not a soldier.

 

Hamas is also holding the bodies of two soldiers killed in Operation Protective Edge last year, Oron Shaul and Hadar Goldin. On Wednesday Haaretz confirmed that Israel has approached Hamas about discussing the return of the bodies, which Hamas subsequently refused to negotiate without a guarantee on the release of some 70 prisoners arrested in raids preceding the 2014 Gaza war. These prisoners were re-arrested during last summer’s hostilities despite having originally been released in the Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange.

 

Israel set a precedent for negotiating with Hamas in 2011, following an agreement with Hamas to release Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit in exchange for 1,027 prisoners held in Israeli detention.

 

That historic instance is a reliable indicator that the possible detention of two Israeli citizens, in addition to retaining the soldier’s bodies, constitutes a significant bargaining chip for Hamas in the ceasefire talks. Previously the announcement of indirect negotiations between Hamas and Israel was accompanied by minimal information and would have seemed a tabloid fabrication at best, had it not been for the confirmation from anonymous sources on both sides. The lifting of the Israeli gag order and subsequent revelation of Israeli citizens in Hamas custody provides context for these negotiations to be set in motion.

   

Avera Mengistu’s fate poses a potential threat to negotiations, as his whereabouts remain unknown with Hamas claiming he was released months ago.

 

An Israeli official told Haaretz that these claims are “intentional and organized lies”.

 

“[Hamas is] responsible for his fate,” the official said. He added that Hamas had kept the affair under wraps for two reasons: either to use him for negotiating purposes, or, “because something grave happened while he was being held”.

 

“If Hamas saw him as a bargaining chip, today’s publication will have a positive effect,” the official told Haaretz. “If the explosion of this affair leads to dialogue with Hamas on the matter, that would mean progress, as Hamas is hiding the truth.”

 

Information regarding the Arab with Israeli citizenship, confirmed in custody, remains under Israeli court gag order.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×