Skip to main content

In a historic decision, India's Supreme Court has ruled that gay sex is no longer a criminal offence.

The ruling overturns a 2013 judgement that upheld a colonial-era law, known as section 377, under which gay sex is categorised as an "unnatural offence".

The court has now ruled discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation is a fundamental violation of rights.

Although public opinion in India's biggest cities has been in favour of scrapping the law, there remains strong opposition among religious groups and in conservative rural communities.

But this ruling, from the top court, is the final say in the matter and represents a huge victory for India's LGBT community.

What have the judges said?

Thursday's decision was delivered by a five-judge bench headed by India's outgoing chief justice Dipak Misra and was unanimous.

Reading out the judgement, he said: "Criminalising carnal intercourse is irrational, arbitrary and manifestly unconstitutional."

Another judge, Indu Malhotra, said she believed "history owes an apology" to LGBT people for ostracising them.

Justice DY Chandrachud said the state had no right to control the private lives of LGBT community members and that the denial of the right to sexual orientation was the same as denying the right to privacy.

The ruling effectively allows gay sex among consenting adults in private.

What is section 377?

It is a 157-year-old colonial-era law which criminalises certain sexual acts as "unnatural offences" that are punishable by a 10-year jail term.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

India is a very tolerant society and culture.  They recognized a long time ago that Gays are a human condition, so they carved a place for them in custom and society.  Eunuchs, perform dances at marriage ceremonies and other celebrations.  I visited Mumbra, a Eunuch sanctuary on my way to the Mumbra Devi temple about 15 miles outside of Bombay.  It's safe, no one bothers you, they are peaceful and go about their daily business like anyone else.

FM
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

K
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

Mitwah
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

dude...repeating the same thing on multiple threads is tedious after a while

FM
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

Lord have mercy, mouth open and story jump out. Every day more and more information come out about lilly to explain why he is such a tortured soul. 

FM
Baseman posted:

India is a very tolerant society and culture.  They recognized a long time ago that Gays are a human condition, so they carved a place for them in custom and society.  Eunuchs, perform dances at marriage ceremonies and other celebrations.  I visited Mumbra, a Eunuch sanctuary on my way to the Mumbra Devi temple about 15 miles outside of Bombay.  It's safe, no one bothers you, they are peaceful and go about their daily business like anyone else.

Were the voluntarily castrated?

A
Drugb posted:
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

Lord have mercy, mouth open and story jump out. Every day more and more information come out about lilly to explain why he is such a tortured soul. 

Well all you want is your can of slop and the big black bigan. Like your cougar couldn't stand your BO.  

Mitwah
Ray posted:
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

dude...repeating the same thing on multiple threads is tedious after a while

How come you don't say that to the other posters who keep repeating their nonsense? Why are you picking on me only? Isn't that discrimination?

Mitwah
Mitwah posted:
Ray posted:
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

dude...repeating the same thing on multiple threads is tedious after a while

How come you don't say that to the other posters who keep repeating their nonsense? Why are you picking on me only? Isn't that discrimination?

Because you are posting lies,cry baby.

K
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:
Ray posted:
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

dude...repeating the same thing on multiple threads is tedious after a while

How come you don't say that to the other posters who keep repeating their nonsense? Why are you picking on me only? Isn't that discrimination?

Because you are posting lies,cry baby.

I met your Insurance buddy.... got tons of garbage to dump on you. Try me! 

Mitwah
antabanta posted:
Baseman posted:

India is a very tolerant society and culture.  They recognized a long time ago that Gays are a human condition, so they carved a place for them in custom and society.  Eunuchs, perform dances at marriage ceremonies and other celebrations.  I visited Mumbra, a Eunuch sanctuary on my way to the Mumbra Devi temple about 15 miles outside of Bombay.  It's safe, no one bothers you, they are peaceful and go about their daily business like anyone else.

Were the voluntarily castrated?

My understanding, they were castrated, voluntary or not, not my business!

FM
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:
Ray posted:
Mitwah posted:
kp posted:
Mitwah posted:

KP had threatened to bugger me. Now he can take his gay self to India.

I never said that I will BUGGER you, I don't play that game. But I know I F--ked you up over and over again. I heard you used to go to India for SERVICE, now you don't have to hide and go it is legal, you can also wear the sari. Victory for Gay Boy. You get me in your craw night and day, now you want me in your ass!

Uh Uh.  Could I pacify you with some fried rice and mauby? 

dude...repeating the same thing on multiple threads is tedious after a while

How come you don't say that to the other posters who keep repeating their nonsense? Why are you picking on me only? Isn't that discrimination?

Because you are posting lies,cry baby.

I met your Insurance buddy.... got tons of garbage to dump on you. Try me! 

I would encourage you to post the facts on me.

K

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×