Skip to main content

The Editor
Stabroek News
46/47 Robb Street
Georgetown
Dear Editor,
Re: Bar Council not forthright in its vituperation of Gecom.
I refer to a statement issued by the Guyana Bar Council published in the Friday, April 17, 2020, edition of your Stabroek News papers under the caption, ‘’Bar Council calls for GECOM to expedite the process for accurate, transparent poll results -says failure after six weeks disgraceful, inexcusable.’’
Its a half-truth to tell Gecom that Guyana would fall into a Constitutional abyss if its attempt under article 162 (1)(b) of the Constitution to deliver an impartial and free election in compliance with the laws of Guyana takes it beyond the 30th April 2020.
The Bar Council says the Constitution is the Supreme Law of the land, but does not disclose its provisions are interpreted by the Courts and become the Law of Guyana.
The Bar Council had a duty to fully disclose that though Article 69 of the Constitution provides that on dissolution the next session of Parliament must be convened no later than four months from the end of the preceding session, the Court of Appeal of Guyana in 2006 upheld the decision of the Chief Justice Carl Singh, that the four months timeline was directory and not mandatory.
This case Civil Appeal No.79 of 2006 was appealed by the Leadership of the AFC, challenging the PPPC's convening the new Parliament, not on the 2nd day of September 2006 (four months after dissolution) but on the 28th of September, 2006 almost five months later. The Bar Council did not make any alarm about a constitutional abyss then.
In the 2006 elections there was no pandemic that required social distancing, nor Court challenge before the declaration of the results of the elections as at present and the evidence showed a deliberate intention on the part of the PPPC to ignore the four months timeline in Article 69.
Jagdeo had thrown the kitchen sink at Article 69 at the 2006 elections; He was sworn in on the 2nd day of September 2006, the date on which Parliament should have been convened; He appointed Ministers before their names were extracted by the Representative of the PPPC’s list, and before the first session of Parliament commenced.
Despite this blatant noncompliance with Article 69 by these actions coming after the four months required therein, the Court held that they were valid and Constitutional.
I trust that Gecom's lawyers would respond to the vituperation and abuse directed towards it, by the Bar Council, but that it would not be distracted from its constitutional mandate envisaged in Articles 62 and 162 of the Constitution to independently supervise and conduct elections in Guyana, in order to deliver credible elections.
In conclusion as in 2006, Guyana would not in 2020 descend into any constitutional abyss were Gecom in all the prevailing circumstances in the pursuit of democracy is unable to meet the 30th April 2020 timeline.
Regards,
Basil Williams SC
Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Bar Association calls on GECOM for swift final election result to enable new Parliament by constitutional deadline

-slams laid back approach as `disgraceful and inexcusable'

The Guyana Bar Association today called on GECOM to act expeditiously to enable an accurate and transparent declaration of results from the March 2 elections noting that a constitutional deadline for the convening of a new Parliament was fast approaching on April 30th.

In a press release today, the Bar Association also hammered GECOM’s laid back approach to the declaration of a final result as “disgraceful and inexcusable”

The release by the Bar Association follows:

PRESS RELEASE

Article 69 of the Constitution of Guyana mandates that, on dissolution, the next session of Parliament must commence no later than four (4) months from the end of the preceding session. The last session of Parliament was dissolved on December 30, 2019 . The next session of Parliament must therefore begin no later than April 30, 2020.

It is in pursuance thereto , that the Bar Council of The Bar Association of Guyana calls on the Guyana Elections Commission (GECOM) inclusive of its Secretariat to do all acts and things necessary in the shortest possible time to ensure the accurate, credible and transparent declaration of the results of the General and Regional  Elections  held on March 2, 2020 so that the next session of Parliament can commence as constitutionally prescribed, that is, no later than April 30, 2020.

Effect can only be given to the provisions of the Constitution for Parliament to be summoned by the constitutionally mandated timeline  if GECOM and its Secretariat act immediately in a manner evincing transparency , impartiality and fairness .

Time is of the essence . The Constitution of Guyana is the supreme law of Guyana to which all persons and bodies are subject. Timelines laid down by the constitution are not merely matters of principle which one can simply choose to abide by or ignore. The failure to abide by the constitution has far reaching consequences , both nationally and internationally ,  inter  alia  for   good  governance   and  the  rule  of   law.

Prior to the dissolution of Parliament on December 30, 2019, the National Assembly (which comprises Parliament) last sat on May 23, 2019. That is, almost eleven (11) months ago. Soon, it will be one year since the last sitting of Parliament. Such a record is not one for which any country would wish to be known.

Guyana is a parliamentary democracy based on the rule of law. The absence of parliamentary oversight of those who purport to exercise executive powers, whether de facto or de jure , is of grave concern as it places the rule of law under siege.

The Bar Council is deeply concerned by what appears to be a laissez faire approach taken by GECOM and its Secretariat. The absence of a declared election result some six weeks after the General and Regional Elections, in addition to being outside of the

statutory prescribed period, is disgraceful and inexcusable. Court proceedings in the interim were dealt with dispatch. Counsel for all the parties adhered to timelines and both the High Court and Court of Appeal even sat on Sundays to ensure the timely determination of the matters. Despite the reported decision of GECOM over a week ago to effect a recount of the votes cast in all ten districts , same has not yet even begun as it continues to grapple with mundane decisions while precious time continues to be lost. The integrity of any system is as good as the integrity of the persons who operate the system . The recent open disregard for truth and decency by certain members of the GECOM Secretariat leaves a feeling of great distaste in the mouths of ordinary Guyanese who have been subjected to scorn, disdain and ridicule by the rest of the world even as we struggle to come to terms with the COVID-19 disaster . More will be said later about the continued relevance or function of GECOM when this chaos is over.

We once again remind that time is of the essence . The constitutional clock is ticking. There are a mere fourteen (14) days left before Guyana delves further  into the constitutional abyss to which the country was pushed by GECOM on March 21, 2019 when it failed to hold General and Regional Elections within the constitutionally mandated period on the valid passing of the ‘No Confidence Motion’ on December 21 , 2018 .

The Bar Council urges GECOM and its Secretariat to put aside the imbroglio of the last six weeks by ending the impasse over results, with a declaration that permits the Constitution to be honoured and provides the people of Guyana with a freely and fairly elected Government.

April 16, 2020

Django
Demerara_Guy posted:

United Nations can be involved in addressing issues in a countries or between countries.

However, the United Nations cannot suspend the country's constitution

Isn't it true that if there is no president and the next in charge does not want to take the position, the UN can suspend Guyana's constitution and run Guyana until the matter is resolved? Just asking.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×