Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

US$840M Amaila Fall hydro…IMF warns govt. to ensure project makes economic sense

December 1, 2012 | By | Filed Under News

-wants “careful considerations” of risks, contingent liabilities

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has called on Government to take steps to ensure the economic viability of the multi-million-dollar Amaila Falls hydro-power project. The recommendations were noted in a statement from the fund yesterday on the recently concluded Article IV consultations with Guyana, a member state. IMF’s examinations are carried out primarily through annual consultations between Fund staff and member governments and central banks.  These meetings are known as Article IV consultations, as they form part of the IMF’s Articles of Agreement.  On November 9, IMF’s Executive Board concluded these negotiations with Guyana. Speaking on the Amaila Falls project which is expected to cost upwards of US$840M and will become Guyana’s most expensive project ever, IMF said that based on findings they are recommending “steps to ensure that the Amaila Falls Hydropower project is economically viable.” For an operation to be economically viable, it simply means that it must be able to earn enough revenues to meet its expenditure. IMF’s Executive Board also “recommended careful consideration of the risks and contingent liabilities arising from that project, and welcomed the authorities’ efforts to pursue international best practices in its management.” There have been critical concerns over the costs of the Amaila Falls project, set to be built in Region Eight. The project which will include creating reservoir, building a station and running transmission lines to the coast, has been described as a key project, by government, to help reduce electricity costs and ensure a stable supply. The peak demand in Demerara for power is around 80 megawatts. Of special concern also is whether the costs of the project and the terms of repayment of the loans that would be financing it, would not see electricity costs soaring in Guyana… never mind the savings on imported fossil fuel for generators that would be made with the advent of the hydro. Costs for financing the loans, interests and insurance take a significant portion of loans pushing the final figure now around US$840M. Fluctuations of the dollar could see the costs rising even more. The 165-megawatt project is to be built in Region Eight and according to Sithe Global, the US-based developer; IDB will be plugging in US$175M, from the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). Funding for the project is coming from a number of sources including US$100M in equity from the Guyana Government. The project has been dogged by delays ranging from financial closure to the completion of the roads leading to the project site at Amaila Falls. It will be recalled that in January, Government dismissed the contractor, Synergy Holdings, after delays and failure to acquire a performance bond in time. Government had to re-issue the road projects in four separate contracts. It is unlikely, given the weather and harsh terrain, that the mid-2013 deadline for the hydro project to start, will be met. China Development Bank will be providing US$413.2M. Sithe Global will be providing US$152.1M. The total capital costs for the project, according to the Sithe Global officials earlier this year, will be US$652.5M, taking into consideration additional construction, development, start-up, as well as a contingency. The remaining US$187.8M will go towards financing costs which include interest during construction (US$97.1M), lenders fee and advisory cost (US$34.9M), and debt political risk insurance (US$55.7M). The plant is expected to cost US$314M, with the transmission lines demanding some US$126M. The additional US$79M is for currency adjustments. At a projected average tariff of US$101M, the plant is expected to rake in more than US$2B over the 20-year period on the Build, Own, Operate and Transfer (BOOT) life of the project. The plant is slated to last for at least 75 years.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The IMF slow. Several of us on GNI have frequently pointed out the folly of the project. Most of that money intended for the plant will be stolen by PPP croonies leaving the average Guyanese to pick up the tab.

Mr.T

Without getting into details, for a nation with  GDP of some USD 2+b, which largely import all it's power needs and given the economic boost which will come, it's hard to understand why a 600 mio project with a 75 Yr life-span not making sense.

FM
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

The IMF slow. Several of us on GNI have frequently pointed out the folly of the project. Most of that money intended for the plant will be stolen by PPP croonies leaving the average Guyanese to pick up the tab.

The Chinese and IDB don't have a habit of writing personal checks.

FM
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

The IMF slow. Several of us on GNI have frequently pointed out the folly of the project. Most of that money intended for the plant will be stolen by PPP croonies leaving the average Guyanese to pick up the tab.

The Chinese and IDB don't have a habit of writing personal checks.

You have zero knowledge of the Chinese. Not only am I partly Chinese I have also been doing business with them for about two decades now. And what I have figured out is that they are after the raw material in the Guyanese soil as they are after the raw material in African soil. They look for corrupt third world leaders who would sell their own mother for a quick profit. Guyana is full of these kind of politicians. And just to make sure it will be possible the Chinese are shipping their agents to Guyana. With them are also the likes of Triad and 14K gangsters. I know that for sure. I was once married into the Triad.

the IDB lends out money because they know it will be paid back even if there is no money to pay it with. Witness the decades of poverty that has tainted Africa. The people have been left to starve so that the loans could be repaid.

The same faith awaits Guyana. That's guaranteed.

Mr.T
Originally Posted by Jalil:

US$840M Amaila Fall hydro…IMF warns govt. to ensure project makes economic sense

December 1, 2012 | By | Filed Under News
-wants “careful considerations” of risks, contingent liabilities
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has called on Government to take steps to ensure the economic viability of the multi-million-dollar Amaila Falls hydro-power project...  IMF’s examinations are carried out primarily through annual consultations between Fund staff and member governments and central banks.

Translation: the IMF transmits directives from the imperial centre to the colonial possessions (with some cheer-leading from the comprador flunkies such as the AFC.) The IMF's job is preserve Third World countries as helpless, dependent repositories of undeveloped raw materials and cheap labor.

FM
Originally Posted by Henry:
Originally Posted by Jalil:

US$840M Amaila Fall hydro…IMF warns govt. to ensure project makes economic sense

December 1, 2012 | By | Filed Under News
-wants “careful considerations” of risks, contingent liabilities
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has called on Government to take steps to ensure the economic viability of the multi-million-dollar Amaila Falls hydro-power project...  IMF’s examinations are carried out primarily through annual consultations between Fund staff and member governments and central banks.

Translation: the IMF transmits directives from the imperial centre to the colonial possessions (with some cheer-leading from the comprador flunkies such as the AFC.) The IMF's job is preserve Third World countries as helpless, dependent repositories of undeveloped raw materials and cheap labor.

Hahah...yuh a completely ignore de Chinee empire? De new colonist? 

FM

GNI CUNUMUNUS and Reading and Understanding is like Ile and Wata Now is time for Prof Nehru to heducate the DUNCES.

 

When wan Headline say " IMF ask Govt to ENSURE Proj makes Economic Sense", it does not mean it does not make economic sense.

 

now dunces, pay attention, it means the IMF s cautoning the Govt to take the right stepts to make the project a Success.

Nehru

Turkey's Ilisu hydropower plant currently being built, will generate 1200 MW and the construction cost is $1.7 billion at a cost of $1.416 million per MW.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Il%C4%B1su_Dam

 

Sudan's Merowe hydropower plant was recently built at a total cost of Euro 1.2 billion and it generates 1250 MW. Euro 1.2 billion X 1.30 = $1.56 billion. Cost per megawatt = $1.248 million per MW.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merowe_Dam

 

Ethiopia's Gilgel Gibe III is under construction and is estimated to cost Euro 1.55 billion = $2.015 billion. It will generate 1870 MW at a cost of $1.078 million per MW.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilgel_Gibe_III_Dam

 

 

Ethiopia's Gilgel Gibe II hydropower plant was recently built at a total cost of Euro 373 million = $484 million. It generates 420 MW at a cost of $1.150 million per MW.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G...ibe_II_Power_Station

 

The Kishanganga Hydroelectric Plant is being built in India at a total cost of $687 million and will generate 330 MW for a cost = $2.081 million per MW.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K..._Hydroelectric_Plant

 

 

Amaila Falls hydropower plant will cost $840 million and generate 165 MW for a cost of $5.089 million per MW.

 

The IMF is concerned that even the most corrupt countries in the world can build  hydroelectric plants at less than half of what it's costing in Guyana. PPP officials will get rich off the backs of poor Guyanese when this project is over. All you need to do is to look at the disaster with the Fip Motilall fiasco to see where this project is heading. Tiefery at it's max. 



Mars

I warned you guys from the very beginning about this "Putting all your eggs in one basket" approach to hydro in Guyana.  We should have learned from Burnham failure. We should have taken an example from how the company Canadian Hydro Developers approach their hydro development.  Having several small hydro projects (together with other small energy generators) near to cities and towns.  These could have been built one by one with government savings and are easy to service. It would have made better sense.

 

Mark my words.  The IMF and the World Bank will get back their money with interest one way or the other.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Nehru:

GNI CUNUMUNUS and Reading and Understanding is like Ile and Wata Now is time for Prof Nehru to heducate the DUNCES.

 

When wan Headline say " IMF ask Govt to ENSURE Proj makes Economic Sense", it does not mean it does not make economic sense.

 

now dunces, pay attention, it means the IMF s cautoning the Govt to take the right stepts to make the project a Success.

Talk honestly to me Brother Nehru. You really believe that $20-30 Million US won't go missing? I mean man up and talk the truth. And who controlling the payments? And don't say IMF.

FM
Originally Posted by Mr.T:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

The IMF slow. Several of us on GNI have frequently pointed out the folly of the project. Most of that money intended for the plant will be stolen by PPP croonies leaving the average Guyanese to pick up the tab.

The Chinese and IDB don't have a habit of writing personal checks.

You have zero knowledge of the Chinese. Not only am I partly Chinese I have also been doing business with them for about two decades now. And what I have figured out is that they are after the raw material in the Guyanese soil as they are after the raw material in African soil. They look for corrupt third world leaders who would sell their own mother for a quick profit. Guyana is full of these kind of politicians. And just to make sure it will be possible the Chinese are shipping their agents to Guyana. With them are also the likes of Triad and 14K gangsters. I know that for sure. I was once married into the Triad.

the IDB lends out money because they know it will be paid back even if there is no money to pay it with. Witness the decades of poverty that has tainted Africa. The people have been left to starve so that the loans could be repaid.

The same faith awaits Guyana. That's guaranteed.

You have a very simplistic and feeble mind.

FM
Originally Posted by Bruddaman:
Originally Posted by Nehru:

GNI CUNUMUNUS and Reading and Understanding is like Ile and Wata Now is time for Prof Nehru to heducate the DUNCES.

 

When wan Headline say " IMF ask Govt to ENSURE Proj makes Economic Sense", it does not mean it does not make economic sense.

 

now dunces, pay attention, it means the IMF s cautoning the Govt to take the right stepts to make the project a Success.

Talk honestly to me Brother Nehru. You really believe that $20-30 Million US won't go missing? I mean man up and talk the truth. And who controlling the payments? And don't say IMF.

Every project will have 5-8% inefficiency so 20-30 mil here and there is an acceptable norm for this project.  This does not mean fraud, though it may have some of that.  Try to eliminate all inefficiency or "leakage", you bind yourself up in expensive and cumbersome internal controls which will result in delays and added costs well beyond the built-in "waste tolerance"

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×