Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Hadiya [center) arrives at an earlier Supreme Court hearing on November 27, 2017, in New Delhi, India.

New Delhi (CNN) India's highest court has moved to strike down a ruling from a lower court that prevented a Hindu woman who had converted to Islam from living with her Muslim husband, in a landmark decision that upholds the right of inter-religious marriage.

The case had gained notoriety in India owing to allegations from the woman's family that she had been brainwashed by her husband as part of a broader Muslim plot, dubbed by right-wing Hindu nationalists as "love jihad."
Throughout the lengthy two-year court battle, 26-year-old Hadiya, who goes by one name only, consistently maintained that she acted on her own free will, despite claims from her father, Asokan K.M, that she was forced to convert to Islam by her husband.
"This was completely blown out of proportion," said Haris Beeran, the lawyer for the woman at the center of the case. "There was no element of 'love jihad' in this."
 
The Supreme Court's ruling, which was announced Monday, brings to an end her family's persistent attempts to nullify the marriage, with the three-judge panel stating that "the court has no right to annul the marriage between consenting adults."
 
Referring directly to Hadiya's battle with her parents, which began in the southern state of Kerala, the judges ruled that the wishes of her family "cannot be allowed to curtail her fundamental rights," adding that the freedom to choose a spouse and convert to another religion was both a constitutional and a human right.
 
"Intimacies of marriage, including the choices which individuals make on whether or not to marry and on whom to marry, lie outside the control of the state. Courts as upholders of constitutional freedoms must safeguard these freedoms," said the ruling.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Prince posted:
Baseman posted:

The woman is 26.  The court should have refused the case   

When the court intervenes and makes a decision, it means that the girl family cannot supersede its decision to annul the marriage. Is that what you mean by she is 26?

I meant she has far exceeded the age of emancipation and makes her own decisions.  If she has an issue, let her file her case.  

Maybe they wanted to print a precedent for future cases.  

FM
Prince posted:

Another landmark decision that upholds the right of inter-religious marriage in India. India is the largest democracy in the world and these rulings show that they are living up to the democratic standard. 

Hindus are the target of these Abrahamic religions (except Judaism which does not look for converts)  to increase their numbers in their head long pursuit of world domination. Steps should be taken in India to follow Turkey's example.  If you convert from Hinduism your full name must change, your passport, id and birth certification must show your true religion.  When you die you get a funeral of your converted religion.

Prashad
Last edited by Prashad

India's supreme court ruled in another landmark case when a 23-year-old woman was married by her parents without her consent. The woman filed for divorce from her husband and the court favored her wishes. India is moving in the right direction to do away with matchmaking tradition. Dowery has been abolished but still remains a burden to poor families. I would like to see enforcement to stop the dowery given altogether.  

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Prashad posted:
Prince posted:

Another landmark decision that upholds the right of inter-religious marriage in India. India is the largest democracy in the world and these rulings show that they are living up to the democratic standard. 

Hindus are the target of these Abrahamic religions (except Judaism which does not look for converts)  to increase their numbers in their head long pursuit of world domination. Steps should be taken in India to follow Turkey's example.  If you convert from Hinduism your full name must change, your passport, id and birth certification must show your true religion.  When you die you get a funeral of your converted religion.

You made a very bold statement that Hindus are being targeted by Muslims and Christians, that may be so or not. The bigger question you need to ask is why Hindus are fleeing from their religion.

In Guyana and especially from where Skeldonman is from, majority of Hindus converted to Christinanity. Skeldonman said that Phagwah day the place was like Ghost Town, educated Hindus are deserting their religion in droves.

Chief

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×