Skip to main content

 

Jagdeo's libel case witness wasn't instructed to search for offending words; Kissoon to field 12 witnessesPDF | Print |
Written by Denis Scott Chabrol   
Thursday, 05 July 2012 11:52
AddThis Social Bookmark Button
kisson_hughes
Freddie Kissoon and his lawyer, Nigel Hughes in discussion after Thursday's hearing.

Jason Abdulla-former President, Bharrat Jagdeo’s witness in the libel case against newspaper columnist, Freddie Kissoon- says he was never asked to search for the offending words “ideological racism” in the columnist’s writings.

Jagdeo has sued Kissoon, seeking GUY$10 million in libel damages for allegedly calling him an ideological racist in a June 28, 2010 Kaieteur News column titled ‘King Kong sent his goons to disrupt the conference’

Kissoon’s lawyer, Nigel Hughes, on Thursday completed cross-examination of Abdulla after he told the High Court that he was never asked by Office of the President Press and Publicity Affairs Officer, Kwame Mc Coy to look for the words “ideological racist.”

When the case resumes on July 30 before Justice Brassington Reynolds, Hughes plans to begin examining the first of more than12 witnesses to prove that Kissoon’s contention is factual. The Defence Lawyer said the witnesses would include academics and experts.

“The defence will be presenting its case on the next occasion, in excess of a dozen witnesses to confirm that the plaintiff is ideologically racist,” said Hughes. The first witness is expected to be a foreign academic. No name has been provided.

Hughes said he would not be calling on Jagdeo to appear in court because he would then become the Defence’s witness. At the same time, he said the former president’s lawyers have lost a good opportunity for him to stand in the witness box.

“We don’t want him to be our witness. He had his opportunity to come. He hasn’t come to o establish anything,” Hughes told reporters.

The case could go on for another six months.

Under pressure during cross-examination, at one time Abdulla gave a ‘suck teeth’ when he was pressed on whether, apart from the Kissoon columns, he had carried any other news about the columnist to Mc Coy. “I never said my function was to carry news to anybody and to carry news to Mr.Mc Coy. I don’t know where you got that from,” a visibly perturbed Abdulla told the court.

When Hughes grilled Abdulla on whether he believed that the lawyer was an associate of criminals because Jagdeo had said so and that it had been repeated, Abdulla retorted “you trying to put words in my mouth.”

Justice Reynolds later urged the witness to answer the questions pointedly as was required and that he was free to seek clarifications.

Abdulla has already said that he does not know the meaning of Fascist and fascist manifestation although he could spell the words.

During Thursday’s testimony, under cross examination by Attorney Christopher Ram, Abdulla said he was not trained in journalism but he possesses Grade Three in Caribbean Examinations Council (CXC) English. He said he also he pursued studies in Public Management at the University of Guyana’s Institute of Distance and Continuing Education (IDCE) and also did “a few computer courses.”

 

Replies sorted oldest to newest

 

Jagdeo's witness bungles testimony in libel case against Freddie KissoonPDF | Print |
Written by Denis Scott Chabrol   
Wednesday, 16 May 2012 22:06
AddThis Social Bookmark Button
jason_abdulla
Jason Abdulla

The new witness in former President Bharrat Jagdeo’s libel case against Kaieteur News newspaper columnist, Freddie Kissoon on Wednesday bungled his testimony under cross examination when he could not explain some basis details of his evidence. 

He is Jason Abdulla, known as ‘Taps Son.’ He told the High Court that he is employed at Office of the President as a Media Officer but works at the Government Information Agency (GINA) and reports to “everybody” in the government. Abdulla replaces Rawle Kissoon, who Jagdeo’s lawyer- Sase Gunraj- said no longer works at Office of the President. 

Abdulla said he was mandated to examine articles by Frederick Kisssoon which had contained words such as dictatorship, dictator, King Kong and Fascism with reference to Jagdeo. 

Using that as the basis, Justice Brassington Reynolds admitted six of nine photocopied columns by Kissoon between June 2010 and January 2012. Defence Lawyer, Senior Counsel, Bernard Dos Santos said he was keen on proving that Kissoon had displayed a “morbid obsession” with Jagdeo and so make out a case for exemplary damages. 

The Judge used purportedly offending sections in each article to determine their admissibility on grounds of "crossing the threshold of relevance."

Under cross examination by Defence Lawyer, Nigel Hughes, the Media Officer said he reports to Head of GINA, Neaz Subhan, Kwame Mc Coy, Clement Rohee, and Roger Luncheon. 

Abdulla, also during cross examination, told the court that while he could spell Fascism he did not know what it meant and he was unfamiliar with its origin and its context. He said he only looked for the words with reference to Jagdeo and the government. Pressed on what he understood by “Fascist manifestation” in one of Kissoon’s columns, he said “It is against the norms and it is perhaps dictatorial.” 

The Office of the President/GINA functionary told the court that “he” in one of the articles did not refer to the plaintiff or former president, Jagdeo. 

On the matter of whether Kissoon’s reference to “Fascist dictators” referred to Jagdeo, Abdulla said “No.” 

Jagdeo filed the case against newspaper columnist and academic, Freddie Kissoon, Kaieteur News Editor Adam Harris and the newspaper’s publisher, Glen Lall, claiming more than GUY$10 million in damages.


Jagdeo believes that he was libeled in a Kissoon article titled , ‘King Kong sent his goons to disrupt the Conference’, which refers to the Guyanese leader as an ideological racist. In the article published on June 28, 2010, Kissoon was alluding to the near-break up of the annual historical conference at the National Library by persons who had heckled pro-government sentiments when he was about to deliver his presentation.

Mars

Jagdeo libel witness hit by memory lapses


 

 

Jason Abdulla, the witness for former president Bharrat Jagdeo in his $10M libel suit against Kaieteur News columnist Freddie Kissoon, yesterday testified that he was unable to recall the contents of most of the articles he compiled to support the case, after an accident left him with lapses in his memory.

Under cross-examination by Kissoon’s lawyer Nigel Hughes, Abdulla said that since the last court date he fell down the stairs in his home.  “…And my recollections [are] not so clear, …..

Mars

Jason is a young man who is trapped in the situation that he is in because of circumstances beyond his control.  He has no real power but has to do what his higher ups want him to do. I feel sorry for him.

Prashad

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×