On another thread about not wanting freedom but wanting Islam, there was something of a discussion on how Islam is seen as being practiced by Guyanese today as opposed to how we grew up practicing it.
We must remember that we grew up in an age where other parts of the world was distant and telecommunications was at best by the phone line. We must also remember that when our forefathers came to the Caribbean there weren't than many educated Islamic scholars. When the generation twice removed from us lost the Urdu language our understanding of Islamic literature, and especially in the absence of visiting missionaries (the Arab world was not yet rich from oil), our understanding was more tied to rote reading of the Arabic in the Quran.
We also brought with us a culture of cuisine, fashion (wearing clothing), and cohabiting with other non-Abrahamic religions like Hinduism, that is alien to Arabs. The Pakistanis had a tearing of their association with Hinduism that lasts up to today. Just look at the Bangladeshi Islamic experience.
The point is that with the heat and humidity in the Caribbean (the Arab heat is a dry one and people feel more comfortable in 100 deg F than they would 80 deg F in humid conditions), hijab and other full clothing would seem out of the normal. Likely also attendance at Hawans would seem common-place for Muslims in the Caribbean.
The Arabs of today read a Quran that was firstly "revealed" and secondly written in classical Arabic at a time centuries ago where linguistic interpretation differs from today's mores and norms of behavior. Underlying all this is the need to dress modestly and to not partake in alcohol. It may not be a productive person who submits 5 times a day and lose productivity during the month of Ramadaan, but it is seen as necessarily sacrifices to be close to God, mankind's yearning for progress notwithstanding.
So should we be debating how Guyanese Muslims in North America have reversed course in their practice of a liberal interpretation of Islam, or should we laud this as an advance in getting closer to God?