Skip to main content

FM
Former Member
MAKE ALL HYDRO DETAILS, STUDIES AND ESTIMATES PUBLIC

September 30, 2011 | By KNews | Filed Under Features / Columnists, Peeping Tom
Source - Kaieteur News

Guyanese must stay focused. They must not be diverted or distracted. These are serious times and the closing days for the Jagdeo administration.

Now is the time for the opposition parties and the people of Guyana to be alert. Now is not the time to be blinded by the allure and promise of political power, or political diversions such as the possible impending sanction of CNS 6 television station.

Months ago the nation was told that within one week the television station would have received a response about the sanction it would face.

The one week passed and then another and then another. Now we are hearing that a meeting has been convened for today to which Mr. Sharma is invited.

Why now? Why was the action to be taken against CN Sharma not announced earlier? Why only now? Is this action a smokescreen to divert the public’s attention from the shocking announcement that there has been a dramatic increase in the projected cost of the Amaila Falls Hydroelectric Project (AFHEP)?

It is now being claimed that the cost of the project has escalated by some US$200M from what was announced last year. Now how in heaven’s name can the cost of a project escalate so high in such a short period of time?

This only confirms the fears of those who all along felt that there was something wrong about this project, that it lacked transparency and ought to have been abandoned.

Guyana needs hydroelectricity. But Guyana does not need hydroelectricity at such an enormous cost. If this project goes ahead at the projected billing, then the children and grandchildren of all Guyanese are going to have to repay for it until the end of time.

This is a project that represents an overbearing burden on future generations. It needs to be paused immediately. It has not passed muster, it smells rank and it requires greater transparency and disclosure.

The President has essentially said that this project is aboveboard. Yes, aboveboard!

But based on the cost escalation over a short period of time this project has gone overboard. Even before a bolt is riveted, even before the road is completed – a road that is itself besieged by controversy – the project costs have mounted by more than $200M. Given this mind-boggling development, one must wonder what is going to be the final cost overrun when the project is completed. Are we then going to eventually learn that the final project actually cost one billion United States dollars?

Already there are concerns as to whether, given the escalation of the project’s costs, the AFHEP will be able to sell electricity to the national grid at the cost that was promised – one that would allow electricity tariffs to be slashed by over 40 per cent. This now seems off the cards.

The people of Guyana should find no comfort in the words of the President that this project is aboveboard. Every major initiative of the Jagdeo administration has been beset with controversy, from the National Stadium at Providence to the Skeldon Sugar Factory to the road to the Amaila Falls Project.

Guyanese are yet to learn the full details about the Amaila Falls Hydro Electric Project. So why should they accept the President’s word that everything is aboveboard? If everything is aboveboard, make all the details of the contract and the feasibility studies and the cost estimates public so that they can be scrutinized and the people of Guyana can make up their own minds as to whether the AFHEP is aboveboard or has gone overboard.

And in order to know whether the AFHEP is aboveboard or overboard, it is also necessary to know the names of those who are onboard.
The AFHEP needs to be put on pause right now. The Jagdeo administration cannot be entrusted to continue with this project, and more so at this time when the President is about to demit office.

The opposition parties need to pause this project. This does not require any protest or demonstration, but a simple statement that no new opposition government is going to respect the terms of a deal which it knows little about. This is all it will take for the equity investors to rethink their role.

There are too many unanswered questions about this deal. As such, this project should not be allowed to see the light of day, unless there is greater transparency.

The government, so close to election however, wants to move ahead. And given the controversies already surrounding this project, moving forward will attract greater attention and criticism. What do politicians do in such a situation? They create diversions.

The present diversion is C.N. Sharma. The Sharma issue is intended to blindside the public from this controversial deal.

The opposition parties should not fall for this. They should make it known that far from being aboveboard, the Amaila Falls Hydroelectric Project is overboard and the people of Guyana, the main stakeholders, are definitely not onboard.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hydro cost jumps US$385M in five months -
Gov’t says cost bloated by price hikes


September 29, 2011 | By KNews | Filed Under News
Source - Kaieteur News

The government yesterday linked the bloating cost of the Amaila Falls Hydro Project to added interest costs and price hikes for materials that would be used in the construction. It said that it was not ruling out pushing more money into the project.

President Bharrat Jagdeo, on Tuesday, stated that project could end up costing US$835M. This amounts to more than US$100M in excess of the cost that the developers, Sithe Global, had indicated earlier this year.

In fact, the new price tag cited by the President is more than US$300 higher than the cost cited by the state-owned Guyana Chronicle earlier this year.

On October 8, 2009, Prime Minister, Samuel Hinds, signed for the original developers of the project – Synergy Holdings – to transfer its 13-year-old interim licence to Sithe Global for the development of the Hydro Project.

Since then, Dr Luncheon said there have been obvious price increases. He referred to price increases on commodities such as metals, steel and cement, noting that these price escalations feed back into an increase in the construction costs.

He said also that the increased construction cost is linked to the financial arrangement that would attract a different interest charge.

“The cost that originally was captured in the contract and the escalation of the associated and related costs for arranging the financing, interest, insurance, those are responsible for driving up the costs to what it is today,” Dr Luncheon told reported.

With a range of financiers involved in the project, Dr Luncheon said that “there are a number of interests that have to be reconciled” before financial closure could be met.

The Chronicle reported on April 3, last, “The hydropower project is estimated to cost in the vicinity of US$450M, which includes US$305M for the plant, and approximately $140M for the transmission lines.”

The Project will be financed through debt from the China Development Bank as per an agreed upon funding schedule over the course of the construction period, and equity from Sithe Global and the Guyana Government.

Sithe Global expects to ultimately contribute around US$200 million of equity. The Guyana Government has said that it will use funds from the US$250 million forest-saving deal with Norway to invest in project. None of the funds under that deal have yet reached Guyana.

However, Dr Luncheon yesterday did not rule out that the government could be prepared to raise the amount of funds it commits to the project given its importance to the government.

“For us, this project is so integrally tied into the (ruling) PPP/Civic vision of Guyana and its economic development that a consideration such as that should not be excluded,” Dr Luncheon said when asked about the possibility of the government raising its equity contribution.

He said that the government anticipates financial closure by the end of the year, “but I would be the first to concede we had similar anticipations earlier.”

“We are more confident as we go forward and the parties who contribute to the financial closure are more and more now in synch and allowing us to be confident that we are looking at closure hopefully by the end of the year and commencement of construction activities early next year.”

The Amaila Hydropower Project is a planned hydroelectric project (approximately 165MW capacity) to be located in western Guyana.

The project also includes a new 270 km transmission line and new substations near Georgetown.

Currently, nearly all electric generation in Guyana is provided through small units burning either diesel or heavy fuel oil.

The planned Amaila Project is touted as a substitute for the expensive generation facilities.

The developers say it would not only provide a clean renewable energy source, but also represent important foreign exchange savings for the country by reducing Guyana’s dependence on expensive imported fuels.

This year, the Guyana Power and Light will spend US$100 million on fuel for the company.

“The reliable and more economic source of electricity would also encourage investors to assess possible investments in the mining sector in Guyana, which has often been identified as having substantial potential,” Sithe Global says.

Less than six months after Synergy Holdings under Fip Motilall realised he could no longer develop the Amaila Falls Hydro Project and agreed to have the licence granted to Sithe Global (October, 2009), Government awarded him a US$15.4 million contract to build roads and bridges leading to the project site.
FM
This whole amalia falls hydro project is another big scam.

The tax payer is going to get screwed royally on this deal they will not even realize what has hit them when the bill comes in for this project.
J
The problem with this project is that Flip is a middle man. He is contracting out the services to build the project. That approach works for some but for me I would have prefered the government hire a company that did everything. It would have cost more but it would have got done faster.
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Wally:
The problem with this project is that Flip is a middle man . He is contracting out the services to build the project. That approach works for some but for me I would have prefered the government hire a company that did everything. It would have cost more but it would have got done faster.



Is this like the childrens' song "The cat came back, the very next day"

Flip tarasss, hehehehe
cain
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:
Project Managers always exist for large projects which include those for hydroelectric developments.

This is excuse making SO absurd that it calls into question any commitment to truth and decency on your part.

Hang your head in shame . . .
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:

The government yesterday linked the bloating cost of the Amaila Falls Hydro Project to added interest costs and price hikes for materials that would be used in the construction. It said that it was not ruling out pushing more money into the project.

So they paying interest on material they ain't buy yet? Sounds like a scam to me.
Mr.T
quote:
Originally posted by redux:
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:

Project Managers always exist for large projects which include those for hydroelectric developments.


This is excuse making SO absurd that it calls into question any commitment to truth and decency on your part.

Hang your head in shame . . .


When you are directly involved with these types of project, then your views might be considered.
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:
quote:
Originally posted by redux:
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:

Project Managers always exist for large projects which include those for hydroelectric developments.


This is excuse making SO absurd that it calls into question any commitment to truth and decency on your part.

Hang your head in shame . . .


When you are directly involved with these types of project, then your views might be considered.

Like YOU!! eh?

What a tool . . .
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:
quote:
Originally posted by redux:
quote:
Originally posted by Demerara_Guy:

Project Managers always exist for large projects which include those for hydroelectric developments.


This is excuse making SO absurd that it calls into question any commitment to truth and decency on your part.

Hang your head in shame . . .


When you are directly involved with these types of project, then your views might be considered.



DG, if I decide to be involved with a project such as this,does the project have to be completed or just lef by the side, even though Iman got paid?
cain
quote:
Originally posted by cain:

DG, if I decide to be involved with a project such as this, does the project have to be completed or just lef by the side, even though Iman got paid?


What are the specific statements of the agreement relative to your question, Cain?
FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×