Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Minister Manickchand was taken out of context

June 1, 2012 | By | Filed Under News 

 

On Thursday, March 31, 2012, this publication carried a story with a headline “IF YOU DON’T LIKE THE SALARY, QUIT – MANICKCHAND”.
The story gave the distinct impression that teachers at a consultation in Berbice said en masse that they did not want the automatic promotion policy to continue as they were not being paid for the remedial classes and that the Minister of Education had said to teachers that if they do not want to do the remedial classes for students as a result of the automatic promotion policy then they should quit the profession.
We are satisfied that the story inadvertently misrepresented the views of both the teachers as well as the Minister of Education.
It is true that a teacher raised the issue of payment for the remediation classes citing the needs of families of teachers. The Minister received that as one of the reasons the programme was not as successful as it was envisioned to be and duly recorded the reason.
It is also true that during the course of the day the Minister did indeed have an inspirational talk with teachers, which had absolutely nothing to do with automatic promotion and/or remediation classes, where she praised teachers for being much more than teachers every day, discussed with teachers their almost sacred duty to mould minds and emphasised that what teachers do today will determine what Guyana looks like tomorrow.
It was during this session that the Minister indicated that the ministry had no space for the handful of teachers who are comfortable with turning up to school late every day, putting their heads on a desk, not teaching and the at the end of the day saying that salary was not enough while still receiving that salary.
We apologise to the Minister and to the teachers for any confusion, hurt and/or strained relations that our story would have unintentionally caused

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by martin Carter:

Here is Mitwah with his crookishness as usual.

You may not be handsome in the classical sense. Your eyes droop, your mouth is crooked, your teeth aren't straight, your nose too wide and wry, one leg is longer than the other, your back is out of alignment, your voice sounds like a PPP oligarch pallbearer, but somehow it all works.

 

Thanks for being my GNI troll.

Mitwah

Martin, I am not a crook.  Never robbed anyone. As a matter of fact, I help run an org here to help the less fortunate back in GUyana.

 

Perhaps you can explain how exactly you mean when you say: "Here is Mitwah with his crookishness as usual."

Mitwah

People here in Guyana losing jobs. My family included in the AFC/APNU cuts. You know what Ramjattan said? Its all part of the colatteral damage. He doesnt care nor do you. You all live abroad and following party line. That's crookery.    

FM
Originally Posted by martin Carter:

People here in Guyana losing jobs. My family included in the AFC/APNU cuts. You know what Ramjattan said? Its all part of the colatteral damage. He doesnt care nor do you. You all live abroad and following party line. That's crookery.    

Slavery was abolished a long time ago; yet you are still shackled to the PPP/C oligarch. You support corruption, thieves, cronyism, nepotism, rapists. That makes you morally bankrupt.

Mitwah

Mitwah and his cronies continue to eat McDonalds in America. God luck to you but the real fight in is Guyana. Not from your computer in America. The AFC and APNU dont care they want glory while people suffering. 

FM

The Manickchand “teacher remark”

June 4, 2012 | By | Filed Under Letters 

Dear Editor,
One of the most disappointing moments for me as a media practitioner came last week when KN’s editor Adam Harris violated one the most sacred principles in journalism. In journalism editors only retract their reporters’ stories when proof exists that the published version was not an accurate content.


This is a guiding principle in the profession. An editor can destroy his/her newspaper and the career of his/her journalist by denying the accuracy of the report when in fact it may be true


Mrs. Kieran Singh-Danny, a former student of mine transmitted to her newspaper, the Kaieteur News, words uttered by Education Minister, Priya Manickchand to the effect that if teachers disapprove of the type of salaries they receive they should leave the teaching profession. Minister Manickchand denied what was carried to Adam Harris who retracted Ms. Singh-Danny’s published coverage


Mrs. Singh-Danny told Mr. Harris that she sticks by what she heard, meaning that the Minister did say what was printed. As it stands it was the Minister’s words versus the journalist’s.


The matter was simple to determine because the Minister told Harris she would forward the NCN tape to him. Harris should have printed his retraction on receipt of the tape.


On Sunday morning, Mrs. Singh-Danny told me that she does not believe that at the time of speaking to me, Mr. Harris has viewed the tape. I am of the opinion that the recording is still to be handed to Mr. Harris.


Mrs. Singh-Danny told me that only NCN and the Chronicle were present for the address of the Minister. It means that Ms. Sing-Danny was the only journalist that covered the Minister’s speech from the private media. Was Mr. Harris mindful of libel? The answer has to be yes.

But since the Minister agreed to submit a filmed version of her speech, then the retraction had to printed after the viewing, not before. Libel or no libel, there was no choice facing Mr. Harris; he had to apologize after the saw he tape

As matters now stand, a reporter’s credibility is on the line. The way out of this is for media personnel to view the tape. We can know if a tape has been edited. If within two days, Minister Manickchand cannot produce the NCN item, then I am calling on Mr. Harris to defend the integrity of Mrs. Singh-Danny publicly. At the moment is it the word of a politician versus a journalist.

We have to choose or we can wait to hear/see the recording. Whatever comes out of this, it holds deep significance for the practice of journalism in Guyana, and I call upon all media practitioners to offer their comments on Mr. Harris’s decision


Frederick Kissoon  

Mitwah

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×