RAMOTAR KICKING PLAYER NOT BALL
My View – by Moses V. Nagamootoo
AFC Vice-Chairman & Member of Parliament
“Baseless”. That is how President Ramotar rubbished the AFC’s notice
of no confidence against his minority government. But hours later, his
Attorney General, Anil Nandlall, saw the notice as a “threat”, and a
move that is “vexatious”.
The Jagdeo-Ramotar cabal is in a tail spin. They were stunned by
the 2011 elections results that saw the PPP reduced to a minority
government. With seven seats, the AFC figuratively parted the Cs: PPP/
C and PNC, and has since occupied the strategic middle ground in
Guyana’s torrid power politics.
Not wanting to admit his failed, lackluster leadership, Ramotar had
initially ascribed the party’s defeat to elections rigging. Shock was to
give way to an incredulous assertiveness that, on a warped notion of
“proportionality”, the PPP ought to have a majority on parliamentary
committees. That mustered no support from the Court. Then they
snapped and pelted at us with fresh elections political balls.
Ramotar is now in mid-term, and the snap elections threat petered out
like froth in a glass of stale beer.
NO CONFIDENCE OPTION
Now, the ball is in our court, and we identified as a potent weapon the
option of a no confidence motion against the minority government.
When approved by a simple majority, the government has to resign.
The no confidence option was a petard that we threw into the PPP’s
trench. We watched the ripples. “Bring it on!” President Ramotar
shouted, as he put on the battle-gear of a “warrior”, ready for new
elections. He went into weight-loss training only to get an unexpected,
delusional inspiration. It was a “bluff”, he thought of the no confidence
mechanism, after some reflection on this option that was first mooted by
me some weeks ago.
So, the AFC Leaderer threw down the gauntlet that showed that we
meant business. We consulted with APNU’s leadership and agreed on
a raft of measures, what former Speaker Ralph Ramkarran would see
as “foreplay”, before triggering the no confidence option. Firstly, APNU’s
Carl Greenidge moved a motion of censure against the recalcitrant
finance minister, Ashni Singh, to have him tried before the Privileges
Committee for contempt of the decision of the National Assembly for
spending $4.5 billion without approval and in defiance of the order of
parliament.
Secondly, the AFC’s Khemraj Ramjattan filed a complaint with the
Guyana Police Force for criminal prosecution of the said finance
minister for unlawfully spending or causing to be spent $4.5 billion
contrary to specific provisions of the laws of Guyana.
Thirdly, the combined opposition proposed to approach the High Court
to injunct the minister of finance or any other person acting on his
instructions from further spending of tax dollars without approval by the
National Assembly, and in violation of the Guyana Constitution.
Additionally, AFC sent a 10-point proposal to President Ramotar asking
that the door of negotiation be left open and for talks on critical matters
to take place before a constitutional crisis and a government shut-
down.
President Ramotar would have known that the cards were stacked
against him. He should have sought counsel in Dr. Jagan’s recipe to
break deadlock: make any compromise once it would not result in the
loss of government.
But Ramotar chose instead the anti-Jagan path: no negotiation; no
compromise. He went further and assured that he could deal with the
consequences, which is, no government.
PRESSURE POLITICS
The no confidence option is part of Guyana’s pressure politics. There
was objective need to move the numbers game between government
and opposition from that of 32 versus 33, to power politics. In this case,
it comes down to the Power of One. The majority of One has become
the power ball. Momentarily, it may force government to hold local
government elections!
So, when President Ramotar was served notice of a no confidence
motion, he did not disappoint any one by his unimaginative,
characteristic, response:. he kicked the player not the ball. He went
after the AFC leader, ready to pull his pants down. He has lowered his
party’s cuss-down politics to trench-bottom level.
Ramotar has learned nothing from his recent jaunt to Brazil, the venue
of the just-concluded world cup that, in football, a player who kicks or
cuffs another player would get the red card, which is how I see his ad
hominem assault on the AFC leader, Khemraj Ramjattan.
The PPP would have known that people of AFC’s pedigree don’t bluff.
So, they invented new excuses why elections were not on the table:
*Elections Commission not ready;
*people don’t want new elections and, now,
*PPP ready but it is AFC that must account to the people.
For now, the no confidence ball is in the AFC’s court. But we do not
claim ownership of it by ourselves. Ownership resides in the combined
opposition. We must no longer see our one-seat majority as a technical
issue, as a numbers game. We have the power ball, and it is time that
we kick it home!
President Ramotar is the goalkeeper for the minority government. The
ball symbolizes the corruption, lawlessness and incompetence of this
government. To prevent this ball from being placed inside the PPP’s
net, Ramotar has to do lots of defending. It is he, not Ramjattan or
Hughes or Nagamootoo, who should explain why his government must
not lose out in a penalty kick for a host of wrong-doings.
These include:
Failure to make Integrity Commission fully functional to catch the corrupt
officials;
Violation of Constitution by not establishing Public Procurement
Commission to police billion-dollar contracts and the enrichment of a
few with dirty money;
Refusal to hold local government elections due 17 years ago, thereby
destroying grassroots democracy;
Sidelining state funds to a government side-pocket via NICIL and not
putting public monies into Consolidated Fund;
Spending monies, most borrowed, on mega-projects not approved by
parliament;
Justifying billion dollar bail-outs in face of massive failure of sugar
industry and electricity, and uncertainty of rice sector;
Ramotar has to say why our hospitals lack beds and medicines, and
essential care is not available to poor people and his government is
borrowing billions to build a “specialty hospital” for what they called
“medical tourism”?
How is he going to justify using up tens of million US dollars of
taxpayers money to build a Marriot hotel and casino, when pensioners
get a measly handout of US$60 per month, and why people crossing
the Berbice river bridge have to fork out over $2,000 for a car, and
government boasting that Berbicians should be happy to pay through
their noses?
Rather than opting for engagement and reconciliation, the Ramotar
regime has decided on cuss-down and confrontation. The no confidence
option is gathering momentum and, to borrow the words of Martin
Carter, “inevitably and inexorably”, this hard-headed incompetent
government would fall. I do not have a crystal ball but this I know: the
dynamics of party power politics have changed with the population
census.
We can expect more “feral blast” from the PPP against us. In the
days ahead, the PPP would lash out at all and sundry, like a caged
juggernath, galloping helter skelter.
It is time for our people to cut this wild thing loose!