NY lawyers moves to block Bisram’s extradition

Oct 29, 2017 News, https://www.kaieteurnewsonline...bisrams-extradition/

Lawyers for embattled New York-based businessman, Marcus Bisram, who has been ordered extradited from the US to face a murder charge here, is confident that he will not be sent back.

Updating Kaieteur News yesterday, Bisram’s lawyer, Mario F. Gallucci of Helbock Nappa and Gallucci LLP, in an emailed response to questions, said that a Writ of Habeas Corpus will be filed within the next 10 days.

A Writ of Habeas Corpus is used to bring a prisoner before the court to determine if the person’s imprisonment or detention is lawful.

“We expect that we will be successful on our Writ and Mr. Bisram will be immediately released. He, as always, refutes all allegations and is quite aware that he is the victim of a corrupt Government.

“He understands that the Government is making false promises to the poor family of the decedent and just hopes that someday this family will realize that he in no way, shape or form had anything to do with this tragedy,” Gallucci said.

According to the lawyer, Bisram has always been a benefactor to Guyanese “since his great success in United States”.

“It should be noted that prior to this tragedy, Mr. Bisram was Guyana’s top benefactor. He hopes that once he is released to be able to continue to assist his country both monetarily and also in removing the corruption which permeates the Government of your country.”

According to the lawyer, Bisram’s defense team is working closely with local counsel, Sanjeev Datadin, and will continue to do so until Bisram is vindicated.

On October 12, less than a year after a shocking case that alleged a police cover-up and attempted bribery of investigators into the killing of a Berbice carpenter, a New York court yesterday ordered Bisram be extradited to face the court in Guyana.

Bisram’s lawyers were told that in contrast to a criminal conviction, the certification for extradition is not directly appealable and is subject to a “limited review by way of a petition for a writ of habeas corpus to the district court.”
The lawyers were advised that Bisram’s last minute options of “Habeas Corpus” proceedings is available only to inquire whether the Judge had jurisdiction, whether the offence charged is within the treaty and, “by a somewhat liberal extension, whether there was any evidence warranting the finding that there was reasonable ground to believe the accused guilty.”
“If a habeas petition is filed, the Secretary (of State) will suspend review of the extradition matter, and will resume review only when and if the district court denies the petition. Consequently, there is no need to obtain any form of stay, provided that the habeas petition has been filed.”
Once the court has denied the habeas relief, Bisram has to surrender to Guyana. The US government also made it clear that it may oppose any application for a stay.
Bisram, well-known in Berbice for his philanthropic efforts to the police community and other charities, was expected to be handed over to the US marshals pending his extradition by the Secretary of State.

However, there are some formalities to be handled by the Secretary of State before he can be placed on a plane.
The processing of Bisram would come in seeming record time as it was only eight months ago that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs requested that he be sent back to Guyana to face a murder charge in the killing of Faiyaz Narinedatt.
Narinedatt was beaten after he allegedly rebuffed Bisram’s sexual advances early November, last year.
The carpenter was allegedly dumped in the trunk of a car belonging to an acquaintance of the businessman, driven to a public road in Berbice and the scene made to look like a hit-and-run accident had taken place.
The businessman was arrested at a New York beach front property, in Far Rockaway, Queens, in early July after a US Judge had issued a warrant for him. Prior to that, Bisram was posted on the Interpol wanted list.
New York Judge, Peggy Kuo, filed the Certificate of Extraditability and Order of Commitment, paving the way for him to be sent back.

Unusual
It is not often that the US has extradited one of its citizens to Guyana. Guyana, on the other hand, has done so in a number of cases.
The case would signal closer relations between Guyana and the US.
An extradition hearing was held on October 2, and according to Judge Kuo, after considering the evidence, in particular, the certified and authenticated documents submitted by the Government of Guyana, and the pleadings and the arguments of counsel, she has determined that her court has the jurisdiction to handle the proceedings.
Bisram’s lawyers had questioned whether there was indeed a treaty allowing the US to send back their client.
Bisram, according to filed court documents, was found and arrested on July 4, 2017, in the New York district based on a complaint filed by the United States in response to the request of the Government of Guyana.
Judge Kuo found that the extradition treaty between the US and the Government of Guyana- Extradition Treaty Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of the United Kingdom of December 22,1931,47 Stat. 2122, (“Treaty”) was entered into force upon Guyana’s independence on May 26, 1966, and was in full force and effect at all times relevant to the Bisram action.

Acting United States Attorney, Bridget Rhode, representing the Department of Justice, Guyana’s equivalent to the Ministry of Public Security, wasted no time after the Judge’s order earlier this month.
In a filed letter to Bisram’s lawyers, Gallucci and Michael DeSantis, Rhode listed the next steps that will clear the way for the businessman to be sent back to Guyana.
Rhode explained that now the extradition order has been issued, the Secretary of State then has to determine whether to surrender the fugitive to the requesting state.
It was explained that typically, the fugitive is surrendered within two months of the issuance of the order.

Other arrests
Bisram’s alleged actions last November in Berbice, caused four men to be charged for the murder of Narinedatt.
Radesh Motie, 39, an excavator operator, of Lot 124, Number 78 Village Corentyne, Berbice; Diadath Datt, 18, of Lot 98, Number 71 Village, Corentyne, Berbice; Harripaul Parsram, 49, of Lot 164, Number 71 Village, Corentyne, Berbice and Niran Yacoob, 37, of Lot 65, Number 67 Village, Corentyne, Berbice were remanded to prison when they appeared before Chief Magistrate, Ann McLennan, in November last year.
Also charged were Bisram’s mom, Shermella Inderjali, 45, a mother of two, of Number 71 Village, Corentyne, Berbice.
She and Maryanne Lionel, 25, a bank teller of Republic Bank, also of Number 71 Village, Corentyne, Berbice were arrested during a sting operation.
They were charged for willfully attempting to pervert the course of justice.

The Preliminary Inquiries are ongoing in the local court with the High Court set to make a key ruling.
It was alleged that on November 19, 2016, at Eve Leary, Georgetown, they contacted a Detective Corporal and offered him $4M in cash to forgo charges against the four murder accused, who were at the time in custody pending investigations into the matter.
Bisram, described as a multi-millionaire and the founder of the Marcus Brian Bisram Foundation, is said to have donated $2M to a Berbice community policing group late last year and pledged $200M annually to the needy of the Ancient County.

It is alleged that Narinedatt was murdered between October 31 and November 1 at Number 70 Village, Corentyne, Berbice.
According to reports, on the day of the killing the overseas-based Guyanese had a party at his home, which Narinedatt and a few others attended. At some point Narinedatt went to the back of the yard to urinate. The overseas-based Guyanese allegedly followed Narinedatt and began making sexual advances towards him.
Narinedatt reportedly slapped and pushed away Bisram who allegedly ordered his friends to kill the carpenter.
It was reported that several men beat Narinedatt at the businessman’s premises. He was then taken to a roadway and beaten until he fell into a drain. The men reportedly took the carpenter by vehicle to Number 70 Village, Corentyne, Berbice, where they dumped the body and drove over it with a car.
Narinedatt had a son with wife, Pooja Pitam. His daughter was born after his death.
Pitam travelled to the US and was in front of the Brooklyn court in early July when Bisram was arraigned, two days after his arrest.
She was in tears while calling for justice during a television interview.
Bisram’s fall would shock friends and family. Living the dream life, he reportedly had a luxury apartment in the pricy Manhattan area and was very active on the social circuit and in the mandirs.
He reportedly left Guyana when he was a teen. He is 28 now and would have spent his August 20 birthday in jail, pending his extradition hearings.
He was reportedly close to a number of high-ranking cops in Berbice, who allegedly were fingered in attempting to cover the murder up.

alena06 posted:
If this does not work out can Mrs Narinedatt file a CIVIL suit?

Civil suits in guyana does not work. Also they need more than some one saying he did it and must show he was an active conspirator and planned the murder. Only one person claims he did it.

Remember the Guy who was caught of video tape, the cricket celebrity, who walked up to a guy and shot him in the head?...he walked...then there was the Guy who suspected his wife was having and affair and he walked up on the one cuckholding him and shot him in the head in broad daylight...he walked also. Guyana charged with police making all sorts of mistake and the lawyers take the cases apart. Meanwhile...the accused are remanded to jail for as long as eight to ten years before the case comes up. I have a cousin in jail on the word of a junkie. Cannot get worse than that as evidence. His case will be won but not until he is in jail for close to a decade.

This fellow may have caused the murder but he need to be arrested on the presentation of a sound case by the DPP.

Also the PPP resisted the extradition of Dataram even thought he US had loads of evidence of drug trafficking against him.

Topics