Skip to main content

 

 

Pakistan's national airline has been mocked after a goat was sacrificed to ward off bad luck following one of the country's worst air disasters.

Pictures went viral showing PIA ground staff slaughtering a black goat next to an ATR-42 aircraft which was about to leave for a domestic flight.

It was the first such flight since PIA grounded its ATR fleet for tests after a 7 December crash killed 47 people.

In Pakistan killing a black goat is supposed by many to ward off evil.

But the move by ground staff in Islamabad prompted hoots of incredulity once it was established the images were genuine and had not been photo-shopped.

A Pakistan International Airlines spokesman was swift to point out the goat had been slaughtered by employees on their own initiative and the airline management had no hand in it.

The Dawn newspaper covered the event in a front page story headlined "PIA: on a wing and a prayer". The headline of the Express Tribune newspaper read: "PIA lampooned for bizarre goat slaughter".

The Express Tribune commented that the "ritual sacrifice shows fear besetting the PIA employees associated with flight operations, especially those assigned to ATRs".

Comments on social media were mixed - while many mocked PIA for indulging in superstition, others defended the slaughter as a practice endorsed by Islam.

"Good move. Fresh mutton on flight menu," joked Nadeem Farooq Paracha, a Dawn blogger and columnist, in a tweet.

Another journalist, Fasi Zaka, tweeted: "PIA sacrifices a black goat before resuming ATR services, they take their historical nickname 'Please Inform Allah' (PIA) very seriously."

Television anchor Ejaz Haider tweeted: "When Charles Perrow was working on his theory of normal accidents, he totally missed out on 'kala bakra' [black goat] as a hedge against accidents."

Meanwhile, one Twitter user by the name of MisBis spoke for many when she wrote: "There's nothing wrong in giving Sadqa [sacrificial offering]â€Ķ Sadqa bari balao se bachata hai [it hedges against many troubles]â€Ķ stop making it a joke".

PIA had 11 ATR-42 planes in its fleet - the one that crashed in the Havelian region on 7 December killed all those on board.

Days later, the pilot of another ATR had to abort take-off due to a malfunction in one of the engines, leading PIA to ground the rest of its ATRs for tests.

This affected PIA operations to smaller destinations such as Chitral, Gilgit, Gwadar and many other destinations in Balochistan, Sindh and Punjab where small air strips and lack of technical cover do not allow larger planes to land.

Did Sunday night's sacrifice help?

All we can say is the flight departed safely for Multan, and later returned to Islamabad.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

In Pakistan, killing a black goat is supposed by many to ward off evil?

This is another insult to Islam and let me tell you why. Pakistan is an Islamic state where children must read the holy Qu'ran backward and forward and memorize it over their academic textbook in school. They uphold Allah as the one and only God of all mankind. Who does not believe in Allah and against the teachings of the Qu'ran, considered infidel, which means that you're bound to die by the hand of a Muslim.

Here comes the insult. A black goat is warding off evil in place of Allah, the most merciful God of all mankind. Could this be the reason why Muslims are so confused and corrupted?

From my point of view, this is not Islam since I started read the Holy Qu'ran. Muslims are dwelling with evil and they're not bound by Allah's teachings. (?) What have we here?

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Prince posted:

In Pakistan, killing a black goat is supposed by many to ward off evil?

This is another insult to Islam and let me tell you why. Pakistan is an Islamic state where children must read the holy Qu'ran backward and forward and memorize it over their academic textbook in school. They uphold Allah as the one and only God of all mankind. Who does not believe in Allah and against the teachings of the Qu'ran, considered infidel, which means that you're bound to die by the hand of a Muslim.

Here comes the insult. A black goat is warding off evil in place of Allah, the most merciful God of all mankind. Could this be the reason why Muslims are so confused and corrupted?

From my point of view, this is not Islam since I started read the Holy Qu'ran. Muslims are dwelling with evil and they're not bound by Allah's teachings. (?) What have we here?

You are 1000% correct.

I have said this before , probably you missed it. Islam are in every country of the world and it is diluted by culture from those countries.

That's why when Guyanese are complaing that Muslims from Guyana change, they are wrong. just like you , they are reading the holy Qu'ran and come to the realization that some of the practises were heavily influenced from Indian culture.

Things like jaaray or damage karay ,  those things are no longer practised by Muslims.

Chief
Chief posted:
Prince posted:

They uphold Allah as the one and only God of all mankind. Who does not believe in Allah and against the teachings of the Qu'ran, considered infidel, which means that you're bound to die by the hand of a Muslim

You are 1000% correct.

I have said this before , probably you missed it. Islam are in every country of the world and it is diluted by culture from those countries.

That's why when Guyanese are complaing that Muslims from Guyana change, they are wrong. just like you , they are reading the holy Qu'ran and come to the realization that some of the practises were heavily influenced from Indian culture.

Things like jaaray or damage karay ,  those things are no longer practised by Muslims.

Ôi chief what Da Prince said here is true story?

cain
Last edited by cain
Chief posted:
Prince posted:

In Pakistan, killing a black goat is supposed by many to ward off evil?

This is another insult to Islam and let me tell you why. Pakistan is an

You are 1000% correct.

I have said this before , probably you missed it. Islam are in every country of the world and it is diluted by culture from those countries.

That's why when Guyanese are complaing that Muslims from Guyana change, they are wrong. just like you , they are reading the holy Qu'ran and come to the realization that some of the practises were heavily influenced from Indian culture.

Things like jaaray or damage karay ,  those things are no longer practised by Muslims.

There is nothing wrong with a lil culture...it's like going to see a therapist in the US, them Pakis just prefer to kill a goat

BTW, some of them Muslims from Guyana are pretentious...just give a lil liquor, and they start behaving like Nehru

FM
Chief posted:
Prince posted:

In Pakistan, killing a black goat is supposed by many to ward off evil?

This is another insult to Islam and let me tell you why. Pakistan is an Islamic state where children must read the holy Qu'ran backward and forward and memorize it over their academic textbook in school. They uphold Allah as the one and only God of all mankind. Who does not believe in Allah and against the teachings of the Qu'ran, considered infidel, which means that you're bound to die by the hand of a Muslim.

Here comes the insult. A black goat is warding off evil in place of Allah, the most merciful God of all mankind. Could this be the reason why Muslims are so confused and corrupted?

From my point of view, this is not Islam since I started read the Holy Qu'ran. Muslims are dwelling with evil and they're not bound by Allah's teachings. (?) What have we here?

You are 1000% correct.

I have said this before , probably you missed it. Islam are in every country of the world and it is diluted by culture from those countries.

That's why when Guyanese are complaing that Muslims from Guyana change, they are wrong. just like you , they are reading the holy Qu'ran and come to the realization that some of the practises were heavily influenced from Indian culture.

Things like jaaray or damage karay ,  those things are no longer practised by Muslims.

Fortunately, I don't believe this mythical trash, aka (obyah), even when I was in Guyana, I had my doubts, but respect for the elders comes before criticism. I always believe in my conviction to serve one master, and I chose the Almighty God for spiritual guidance. For my medical guidance, I put my trust in medical science. 

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×