Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Political trauma in Guyana

 

ANALYSIS

Rickey Singh

Sunday, July 22, 2012

 

GUYANESE across the ethnic/political multiracial divide in the Republic of Guyana are this weekend in a mood of apprehension following the eruption of fierce clashes between angry protesters and ranks of the Guyana Police Force in the bauxite mining town of Linden, well known political base of the main Opposition People’s National Congress (PNC), 65 miles south of the capital, Georgetown.

 

What was expected to be a peaceful, orderly five-day protest, as started on Tuesday, against a Government-approved marginal hike in subsidised electricity tariff for the Linden community, shockingly deteriorated into bitter clashes the following day.

 

The conflict erupted across a bridge linking the town of Linden and the Wismar community when the police resorted to force after, as claimed, coming under physical attacks from missiles hurled by angry protesters.

 

They had refused to disperse so that the bridge could become functional again to the benefit of the public. The confrontation climaxed with three civilian deaths from police bullets and a dozen injured.


The Government of President Donald Ramotar was quick to express regret over the loss of lives and injuries suffered. It announced an immediate initiative to establish an independent commission of enquiry, with an international component, to unearth the truth of what occurred on that bloody, tragic Wednesday and committed itself to take whatever actions necessary.

 

The European Union Delegation in Georgetown and other diplomatic missions were equally quick to welcome the Government’s move for an independent probe as well as reveal their own anxieties for constructive dialogue between the Government and Opposition to diffuse tension and generate confidence-building.

 

Like the Government and the Opposition, the foreign diplomatic missions would be conscious of the haunting human tragedies of murder, rape, destruction to property, and mind-boggling dislocation of at least 3,000 individuals, including children, compelled into an exodus from the mining region with the spectre of raw racism looming large in that horrific tragedy of 1964, often despairingly recalled as the “Wismar massacre".

 

The eruption of the police/protestors conflict had coincided with ongoing political tension between the PPP-led Administration of President Ramotar and the combined Opposition of the PNC-led coalition of parties, (A Partnership for National Unity) and the minority Alliance for Change (AFC).

 

Together they control a one-seat majority in the 65-member Parliament, based on last November’s general election at which the PPP emerged with the largest bloc of votes but, unlike the four previous elections from 1992, failed to retain its overall majority.

 

The protests at Linden — which had occurred with the open support of both Opposition parties — coincided with a related major development — the temporary ruling by Chief Justice Ian Chang that the Opposition’s GUY$20 billion cuts from the country’s 2012 national budget were illegal.


Additionally, and more specifically, the chief justice authorised Finance Minister Ashni Singh to restore to the Ethnic Relations Commission (ERC), a constitutional body, the almost GUY$100 million sliced by the Opposition during the budget debate and to secure this originally allocated expenditure for 2012 from the Consolidated Fund. The cut had effectively disabled the ERC from carrying out its stipulated constitutional functions.

 

Since the Opposition had criticised the Government for involving the court on the budget cuts, on the assumption of sovereignty of Parliament, its disappointment with the chief justice’s ruling was to be expected.

 

The scenario would be even more troubling for the PNC (dominant member of APNU) as the Linden tragedies and the chief justice’s ruling on the unprecedented budget cuts occurred while the PNC is immersed in final arrangements for a crucial delegates’ congress later this week at which a new leader is to be elected.

 

APNU chairman retired Brigadier David Granger is expected to be the elected successor to Robert Corbin, who is not seeking re-election, but plans on maintaining an effective influence as a party executive.

 
Granger’s primary rival is a former PNC Administration Finance Minister Carl Greenidge, and lively, controversial campaigning is underway.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I just do not get Ricky Singh thinking here.  The country came to the brink of a racial explosion and melt down and he is saying that the PNC had a bad time.  Everyone had a bad time.

Prashad

Poor is not the word. It's worse than that. He hasn't let the facts get in the way of a good bit of political and racial blame.

 

I don't buy the idea that the country came close to a racial meltdown. I have not heard one black person blame their Indian neighbours for the price hikes. Every Lindener is being hit by this profiteering by the PPP.

Mr.T

Mr T if the killing had continued then you would have seen what I am talking about.  You are right the people of Linden are not blaming Indians for their troubles.  They are blaming the PPP whose personnel are majority indians.  If the killing had continued there is no doubt in my mind that PPP personnel and their families would have come under some serious physical attacks.   

Prashad

One thing for sure, the AFC entry into the Guyana political theater have definitely sharpened the political/racial divisions in the country.  It was never the intention, but it shows what type of results a callous and uncalculating approach brings.

 

The AFC went about their strategy brushing aside underlying traditional mistrusts and have only been successful in unearthing and ventilating this deep seated mistrust.  The AFC has unwittingly thrown back race relation to the "old days".  These shootings will cause each side to dig-in their heels and hold on for dear life.

FM
Originally Posted by baseman:

One thing for sure, the AFC entry into the Guyana political theater have definitely sharpened the political/racial divisions in the country.  It was never the intention, but it shows what type of results a callous and uncalculating approach brings.

 

The AFC went about their strategy brushing aside underlying traditional mistrusts and have only been successful in unearthing and ventilating this deep seated mistrust.  The AFC has unwittingly thrown back race relation to the "old days".  These shootings will cause each side to dig-in their heels and hold on for dear life.


The AFC's platform of change was a good selling point, but as I have always said, the AFC is primarily an anti-PPP party. Look at all the disgruntled ex-PPP executives who will do anything to bring down the PPP regime, even if it means using the race card. For the last couple of years all I have been hearing is the PPP is an Indo racist party. Even Freddie is ashamed to be an Indo. Yes, you are correct, the AFC, instead of focusing on issues, has succeeded in widening the racial rift either inadvertently or deliberately. Very poor management and strategic leadership.
FM
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

Political trauma in Guyana

 

ANALYSIS

Rickey Singh

Sunday, July 22, 2012

 

 

 

Like the Government and the Opposition, the foreign diplomatic missions would be conscious of the haunting human tragedies of murder, rape, destruction to property, and mind-boggling dislocation of at least 3,000 individuals, including children, compelled into an exodus from the mining region with the spectre of raw racism looming large in that horrific tragedy of 1964, often despairingly recalled as the “Wismar massacre".

 


We should never forget our brothers and sisters who were affected by the PNC ethnic cleansing. Shame on those who are defending the actions of the PNC and AFC.


3000 individuals were the 3000 Indo Guyanese many women and children who were raped by the PNC thugs. We must never forget this. Never.


Where was the international community then ? Three PNC thugs are killed and the PNC and AFC supporters call for International Community intervention. What madness.


The president must stand firm against the same PNC and now AFC thugs and we are firmly behind him. 

 

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

Political trauma in Guyana

 

ANALYSIS

Rickey Singh

Sunday, July 22, 2012

 
 
 

I am appalled as a renowned journalist as this doing a hack job and I dare say with intent to make the PPP look good. He lied, fudged the narrative of the events and used choice words that convey a stilted message.

There were no fierce clashes between the Police and the protesters. The riot police on all account proceed to use brute force to clear the bridge with no attempts to use standard protocol to defuse what they know had the potential to cause national harm. 

 

The PPP did not act until some 12 hours later and they did not release a message of regret and consolation of the bereaved. They immediately launched a blame game and highlighted agitators of in the opposition as being the cause. The last line of their initial press release (located on this site) promised more of their expressed intent to clear the protesters at all cost. On the the release of that message I commented it was stupid, disrespectful and of course highlighting the PPP contempt.

 

 

Mr Singh also said it was a marginal increase. This journalist lied outright. It was a 900 percent increase. The implication here is that this was an overtly political protest hence his necessity to highlight the ethnic and political divide rather than the core issue; electricity rates deemed unjust. He pressed that point home well with his reflection to an odious era some half a century ago

 

This is a political hack job and this reporter who was once an idol of mine has with this piece reduced himself to the level of the poison pen insects the PPP employ in GINA.

 

FM

 


Linden pays $ 15 per kilowatt and Berbice pays $ 53 per kilowatt. Only an insane person will defend the AFC and PNC position. Let them come forward.

 

Linden does not deserve special treatment. This matter is all about electricity rates.

 

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by yuji22:

 


Linden pays $ 15 per kilowatt and Berbice pays $ 53 per kilowatt. Only an insane person will defend the AFC and PNC position. Let them come forward.

 

Linden does not deserve special treatment. This matter is all about electricity rates.

 

 BOSAI made 119 million profit reselling its electricity at linden. GPL management has a lot to do with the cost of their electric rates.  Linden gets the treatment it earns no less than others whether they buy at lower price because their supplier is efficient ant others buy from suppliers who are efficient.

FM
Originally Posted by yuji22:

 

Stop spinning and answer the question:

 

Is it fair for Berbicians to pay $ 53 per kilowatt and Linden to pay $ 15 per kilowatt. What is so special about Linden ?

 I provide reasons why the rates are different. Spin ( rather rant) is posting rates without looking at the underlying reasons.

 

Half of that rate by GPL own accounting is to compensate for line loss and thief which they are unable to manage. They also use  inefficient heavy oil machinery some 20 years old when the brought them into service ( paying ridiculous prices for these decommissioned equipment from other over seas company as well). BOSAI use new diesel plants and they have marginal theft problem and they make a profit. The rates are not a reflection of subsidy ( going to the ones earning a profit where it exist) but on management and efficient delivery system.

FM
Originally Posted by yuji22:


Linden must now pay up like Berbice and for your information, the current rate is $ 53 per kilowatt.

 

Linden must Pay up or shut up. It is that simple.

 

 Sorry, you may think you are speaking to sheep. You are not. No one will do as the PPP commands simply because the command it. They are obscene corruptocrats to be second guessed at all times.

FM
Originally Posted by Stormborn:
Originally Posted by yuji22:


Linden must now pay up like Berbice and for your information, the current rate is $ 53 per kilowatt.

 

Linden must Pay up or shut up. It is that simple.

 

 Sorry, you may think you are speaking to sheep. You are not. No one will do as the PPP commands simply because the command it. They are obscene corruptocrats to be second guessed at all times.

 

Fact remains;

 

Current rate in Berbice is $ 53 and Linden MUST pay the same rate or stop using electricity if they cannot afford the same rate as Berbice.

FM
Originally Posted by yuji22:
Originally Posted by Stormborn:
Originally Posted by yuji22:


Linden must now pay up like Berbice and for your information, the current rate is $ 53 per kilowatt.

 

Linden must Pay up or shut up. It is that simple.

 

 Sorry, you may think you are speaking to sheep. You are not. No one will do as the PPP commands simply because the command it. They are obscene corruptocrats to be second guessed at all times.

 

Fact remains;

 

Current rate in Berbice is $ 53 and Linden MUST pay the same rate or stop using electricity if they cannot afford the same rate as Berbice.

IF they pay what you do not think is fair, complain to the delivery systems and the company. Do not heap you poison on Lindeners if they are supplied by a company who can make a profit selling cheap.

FM
Originally Posted by yuji22:

 

The current rate in Berbice is $ 53. Linden must pay up or shut up.

 

We do not see Berbicians burning and destroying like the thugs in Linden.

If they are content to close their eyes to mismanagement then so be it. Not the AFC was there to help them with their organizing. Their bonus dropped from 21 days to less than seven. The PPP as usuall accused the organizers as being on the wrong side. Maybe the AFC will begin to address this and the PPP has opened another front in the assault of their totalitarianism.

FM
Originally Posted by TI:
Yes, you are correct, the AFC, instead of focusing on issues, has succeeded in widening the racial rift either inadvertently or deliberately. Very poor management and strategic leadership.

Unfortunately, the AFC will continue to pursue that path.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×