Minister Ramjattan has failed in the security sector and should resign
Dear Editor,
As a member of the Parliamentary Oversight Committee for the Security Sector, I have been taking special interest in the performance (or lack thereof) of the Public Security Minister, the Honourable Khemraj Ramjattan.
Apart from his arrogance and total disdain for the People’s Progressive Party, Ramjattan is someone you would want to have a beer with. He is approachable and is never afraid to speak his mind, which often gets him into trouble.
I honestly believe he wants to accomplish his goals in the security sector but lacks the vision to do so. He listens to the needs of the brave police and prison officers and appears eager to fulfill those needs, but he is powerless to do so. While Ramjattan may be accessible and approachable as a person, as the Minister of Public Security, he is a complete failure.
This is a man who despises Bharrat Jagdeo and the PPP so much, that it is said he demanded the security portfolio as part of the Cummingsburg Accord with one goal in mind, to put the “corrupt” leaders of the PPP behind bars.
This would explain his focus on working with the UK Security Expert, Sam Sittlington and SOCU to prosecute PPP officials while neglecting the urgent need to do something to end the vicious cycle of crime that is destroying lives and commerce, prompting the UK Government to issue a Travel Advisory to its citizens.
In Guyana today, people no longer feel safe in their homes. Crime is running amok everywhere, raining terror on a population that is already stressed out trying to make ends meet. More and more families are being deprived of their valuables, communities ravished and businesses left vulnerable.
In 2015, the APNU+AFC coalition campaigned on a platform to get rid of corruption and to “reduce the high rate of armed robberies and murders.”
And immediately upon gaining office, this government embarked upon a security recruitment drive and pulled several high-ranking former military and police officers out of retirement to achieve this objective. They have failed miserably!
Since Ramjattan became Minister of Public Security, he has brought the entire security sector in disrepute: In March 2016, seventeen prisoners were burnt to death and 11 others injured in what was described as the worst prison riot in our history. Then in July 2017, during the blazing inferno of the Camp Street Prison, a prison officer was murdered and eight notorious, hard-core criminals escaped, two of whom are believed to be still on the run. Since then, there have been several more well-organized prison breaks.
Every day reports of armed robberies, murders and domestic violence dominate the news. Prisoners, with the aid of some rogue prison officers, are now openly defying authority. At the New Amsterdam Prison, narcotics, alcohol and other contraband were recently discovered in the prison yard. And an inmate there flaunted the breakdown of authority in the prison system by posting a photograph on facebook with fellow inmates in a cell, cerebrating Mother’s Day with several bottles of high-end liquor. During a search of the Lusignan Prison a quantity of illegal items were also found: Improvised weapons, cellphones, cellphone batteries, phone chargers, phone cards, cannabis, cannabis seeds and a cannabis plant. Earlier, a cutlass and a knife were found outside of the north eastern fence of the holding bay of that Prison.
I am pleased that Prison Director Gladwin Samuels, a young professional whom I have tremendous respect for, has been able to identify and get rid of five of the corrupt prison wardens involved in the smuggling of contraband into these prisons, for he is often expected to manage the prison population with insufficient resources and personnel. You don’t have to be a rocket scientist to know that a basic requirement to secure any prison facility is high definition surveillance system and the use of full-body scanners at the entrance of every prison facility. Whatever the cost, these security measures must be procured and installed immediately, The Prison Director should not have to wait on the 2019 Budget to get this done. All Minister Ramjattan needs to do is to come to Parliament with a Supplementary Budget. Government does this all the time for far less urgent matters.
On June 29, Minister Ramjattan got his face on the front-page of the Guyana Chronicle. The article covered the presentation of a one-off payment by government of a meagre $100,000 each to five families of Guyanese fishermen who were brutally murdered by pirates off the coast of Suriname. But this was only done after the PPP had brought a Motion in Parliament urging the government to offer financial support to these families, for Ramjattan had made it clear to them in Suriname that they should expect none. It would have been kinder if government had increased this amount to $300,000 each, the estimated cost of a decent funeral. Nevertheless, I’m sure Minister Ramjattan was happy to be seen in a positive light at a time when just about everyone questions his ability to get the job done.
Yours faithfully,
Harry Gill
PPP/C Member of Parliament
Given the resources allocated to security sector, performance has been poor
Dear Editor,
After my last letter on security matters, a confidential source with strong ties to the APNU+AFC who will remain anonymous, called to plead with me not to be so critical of the Minister of Public Security. He said, “Harry, Khemraj (Ramjattan) means well but he’s not being given the support. He’s not getting the money he’s asking for to improve the sector and he sees money being wasted and unaccounted for in other ministries. They (APNU) want him to fail. They’re using him and (Prime Minister) Moses (Nagamootoo) as pitbulls to go after Jagdeo and his boys. Haven’t you noticed? It is the Indians in the AFC that they’re using to discredit the PPP, our hands are clean.” So after pressing for an explanation, I was told that Granger is under pressure from the PNCR Executive for giving all the important ministries to the AFC but he can’t change that now without risking the breakup of the coalition. The APNU is hoping that Ramjattan will get frustrated by his many failures and either resign on his own, or ask to be reshuffled to another ministry.
This year, $37.4 billion was budgeted for the Security Sector. This is a 10.9% increase from the $29.1 billion allocated last year. In addition, the Guyana Police Force recently received generous gifts from the People’s Republic of China of vehicles totaling US$2.6 million, and 200 bicycles (30 of these were given to the City Constabulary) valued at over US$145,000 and another US$20,000 worth of electronic equipment from the United States Government. So in fact, the Ministry of Public Security should not be short of resources to put systems in place to reduce crime and to secure our prisons. The problem is, this Administration is incapable of dealing with the management and leadership issues that exist in the sector.
Then on July 14, the Guyana Chronicle carried a bold headline that reads, “Armed Robberies down by 8%”. The Kaieteur News coverage of this story was slightly different. It reads, “The Guyana Police Force has recorded 44 murders in the past six months. And with the exception of rape and gun robberies, serious crimes were down by five percent in comparison to the same period last year.”
While Kaieteur News reported a two percent increase in robbery under arms in which firearms were used (298 as against 304 this year), the Guyana Chronicle had the figures reversed to show a decline of 2% to let the government look good. Even so, all Guyanese are aware of the almost daily reports of gun-related robberies and other crimes that terrify businesses and communities, and whether it is +2% or -2%, no one believes those manufactured figures anymore. Shouldn’t rape and gun-related robberies form part of the “serious crime” category to give us a true and accurate crime report from the police? Who is manufacturing these crime statistics to give our citizens a false sense of security? I would wager if an opinion poll is done today, only two persons would believe these statistics: The Minister of Public Security and the Acting Commissioner of Police. But oh, perhaps there is a third, Crime Chief Paul Williams, who seems willing to compromise his professionalism by defending an out-of-control government minister in hopes of getting the Police Commissioner’s job. As this matter is still being investigated by the police, I would hope the Crime Chief has the decency to recuse himself from any part of this ongoing investigation.
Whatever marginal gains the Guyana Police Force is reporting on crime statistics, even if true, is totally unacceptable to justify the huge amount of resources allocated to the security sector. We the citizens of Guyana demand results. And for the government to say that crime was also high during the PPP/C tenure is equally unaccepted. They’re the ones that gained office with all the answers to Guyana’s problems and the security experts the likes of former Police Commissioner Winston Felix and former Rear Admiral, Gary Best, but since then, crime has gotten worse. With the inexperienced Ramjattan now left on his own to hang out to dry, it seems that my source’s information may be credible after all.
Yours faithfully,
Harry Gill
PPP/C Member of Parliament
Member of the Parliamentary
Oversight
Committee of the Security
Sector