Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Project Engineer responds to criticism of Agriculture Road repairs

Aug 04, 2017 Letters, http://www.kaieteurnewsonline....ulture-road-repairs/

Dear Editor,
Please allow me space in your newspaper to respond to the letter penned by Rev. Gideon Cecil under the caption ‘Work on Agriculture Road is not being properly done’ and published in your Friday, July 21, 2017 edition.

For the benefit of the Reverend and the general public, please be informed that the rehabilitation of Agriculture Road, Mon Repos/Triumph, is being undertaken by the Ministry of Public Infrastructure under its Miscellaneous Roads Programme, 2017. The Contractor is K.P. Thomas and Sons Incorporated, the Project Engineer is Anthony A. Haynes, the contract sum is $59,031,149 and the site extends a distance of approximately 1230m. Carriageway works include the upgrading of the road structure with mixed loam and/or crusher run and sealing using asphaltic concrete. The contract is scheduled to end in September of 2017.

Based on the content and tone of his missive, Rev. Gideon Cecil purports to have excellent knowledge in road construction and would have been on the site with the current contractor for the duration of the contract, which commenced on July 6, 2017. His forecast, I suppose, emanates from his experiences over the last two decades, when shoddy construction and poor supervision was the order of the day.

However, the reverend’s description of the execution of the works is incorrect. Agriculture Road, having been initially constructed in the early 1960’s, is older than Independent Guyana. While the surface of the road was in a very poor state, due to poor drainage caused by residents encumbering the road shoulders, the road base remained in an impeccable state. At the moment, the focus is on upgrading the worst stretch of the carriageway, that is, between the East Coast Demerara Highway and the Access to Block ‘CC’ Housing Scheme. It should be noted that while there were numerous potholes within this section, none of those holes exceed 200mm in depth nor did any of them exceed the existing loam fill in the road structure.

To allow for safe, unimpeded construction, an access road was constructed to divert traffic from the critical area through Khan Street, Triumph. The construction procedure being followed is to remove excessive vegetation and other encumbrances from the road shoulders, remove deleterious materials from the carriageway, reshape/scarify potholed areas and mixed loam fill/ crusher-run fill depressed areas.

Subsequent to the relevant quality control procedures, that section of the works will be paved. The works that are required south of the Access to Block ‘CC’ Housing Scheme will be executed in like manner, subsequent to the completion of the initial area.

To allay the fears of Rev. Cecil, it should be pointed out that the current road structure has successfully carried the loads of the construction traffic for the two housing schemes located along the Access Road since 1997. Contrary to his prophecy of doom, the current intervention shall enhance an already tried and proven road structure, resulting in a finished product that will be there for the next two decades, with minimum maintenance.

That being said, I would like to invite the reverend to use his influence to encourage the residents not to encumber the road shoulders with their land fill/construction materials or other solid waste. We at the Ministry of Public Infrastructure would also be willing to provide more information on the project, if necessary, and we encourage Rev. Cecil, and the public at large, to help us monitor our projects.

Anthony A. Haynes
Project Engineer
Ministry of Public Infrastructure

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Project Engineer responds to criticism of Agriculture Road repairs

Aug 04, 2017 Letters, http://www.kaieteurnewsonline....ulture-road-repairs/

Dear Editor,

Based on the content and tone of his missive, Rev. Gideon Cecil purports to have excellent knowledge in road construction and would have been on the site with the current contractor for the duration of the contract, which commenced on July 6, 2017. His forecast, I suppose, emanates from his experiences over the last two decades, when shoddy construction and poor supervision was the order of the day.


Anthony A. Haynes
Project Engineer
Ministry of Public Infrastructure

While a reasonable reply, it is absolutely uncalled-for and unethical for an Engineer to pen a letter with such supposition; highlighted in the above, who is registered in an independent established professional organization.

FM

DG how about when BJ, Anil, Priya who when in the limelight ran their dirty mouths. Now that is unprofessional.

Is there an article penned by the Rev sometime during the last two decades when shoddy work was done? Probably not.

It is called putting the so called Rev in his place.

cain
Last edited by cain

No..really?

Anyway, do you think Rev Giddy Cecil had his head stuck up somewhere that is why he never saw shoddy workmanship while the previous govt were in office?

The engineer was too kind to him. I would have thrown in a few choice words to that blasted Rev Giddy. He must be related to the other PPP Rev Guan Hedghill, that's another one who was blind but can only now see.

cain
Last edited by cain

Cain. The present and previous governments have asked citizens living in areas where government work is being instituted to help with quality control. This individual should be commended for doing it instead of being insulted in spite of what media he used to make his observation known. He should be lauded.i am surprised that you will go after him for this, inspire of what you assume his intentions are/were.

Also, I remember there were lots of criticism of priya, Anail and Jagdeo in the news media when they made mistakes. There criticisms continue to this day.

Furthermore, I know this area and I find it difficult to understand why it cost so much. Approximately $60 million for less Han a mile of road, basically filling in the potholes? Also, why the need for the access road? There are several access roads to the area.

Z
cain posted:

No..really?

Anyway, do you think Rev Giddy Cecil had his head stuck up somewhere that is why he never saw shoddy workmanship while the previous govt were in office?

The engineer was too kind to him.

I would have thrown in a few choice words to that blasted Rev Giddy. He must be related to the other PPP Rev Guan Hedghill, that's another one who was blind but can only now see.

1. If this person is using a reference as an unqualified engineer, he can use words of his choice.

2. However if he is a Registered Professional Engineer the unrelated referenced words have absolutely no place in the language of such person.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×