Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Senior management was not told of dire GuySuCo situation – sources

By Pushpa Balgobin On May 28, 2015 @ 5:16 am In Local News

Chief Executive Officer of the Guyana Sugar Corporation, Dr Rajendra Singh met with senior management last week to expand on its three-year strategy but made no mention of the dire financial straits that the company was in, sources say.

He later blindsided many in management by subsequently revealing to the sugar unions that if financial assistance wasn’t received, operations of the ailing company would cease by Sunday coming.

The new APNU+AFC government is evaluating the current status of the corporation in light of Singh’s pronouncements to the unions.

Dr Rajendra Singh Dr Rajendra Singh

Stabroek News was reliably informed that many company officials were not privy to the immediate and dire financial situation that was exposed by the Guyana Agricultural and General Workers Union (GAWU) and the National Association of Agricultural, Commercial and Industrial Employees (NAACIE) in a joint statement to the press on Monday. That statement urged immediate action by the government to prevent the shutting down of the industry.

This newspaper was told that in the meeting last week with GuySuCo management, the first crop figures were discussed by the CEO in detail along with the corporation’s three-year plan. Subsequent to that meeting, Singh, who was a candidate for the now opposition PPP/C in the May 11 general elections, met with the two sugar unions and explained that waged and salaried employees could not be paid after May 31, 2015.

Head of GAWU Komal Chand told Stabroek News yesterday that while he was made to understand that the government was also informed, newly appointed Agriculture Minister Noel Holder was not aware that the “situation was so grave.”

Chand said that “an immediate and urgent intervention is needed,” to ensure that the out-of-crop work is not stalled. He said immediate financial assistance from the government was necessary to stave off the severe repercussions should operations cease.

The GAWU head also noted that “this (crisis), it didn’t happen just now this have been a long time in the making.”

Komal Chand Komal Chand

He said that “we know that the industry was operating on the basis of shipment of sugar and then receiving of payment”. Chand told Stabroek News that GuySuCo was reliant on money coming in “week by week.”

He said that the shipments were now finished and as a result payments were not coming in. He noted that the US$15M loan from National Commercial Bank of Jamaica was being used to finance wages and operational costs. The loan agreement was for one year and GuySuCo was supposed to pay it back in full in 2015. The status of the repayment is unclear.

GuySuCo recently revealed that the first crop saw 81,194 tonnes of sugar produced which missed the modest 86,201 target by 5007 tonnes.

Chand noted that the out-of-crop season was when the factories and field husbandry were assessed and given the neglect due to financial constraints in the past, further abandonment could not be allowed.

According to one source, many were surprised that the corporation did not raise the issue earlier as the CEO would have known that the financial crisis was imminent. During the CEO’s meeting with staff the possibility of an industry shutdown was not brought up.

The source told Stabroek News that GuySuCo was forced to disclose the extent of the financial calamity because the politically controlled state-owned corporation could not now rely on a bailout with the change in government. The source said that many within the corporation were not expecting the People’s Progressive Party/Civic, which has kept a tight grip on the corporation, to lose the May 11, General and Regional Elections and as a result the current state of its finances had not been exposed earlier.

For several years, critics had said that the corporation was severely in debt and not viable in its current configuration. It has not presented annual reports on a timely basis for full vetting of its status.

Another source told Stabroek News that the CEO provided to the new Agriculture Minister paperwork on the current state of sales while adding that “GuySuCo is too big to fail”. He noted that the government would need to intervene immediately and the corporation was already expecting a bailout as the lives of 16,000 workers, their families and all of the indirect businesses associated with the state- owned corporation would drastically be affected.

Meanwhile, Finance Minister Winston Jordan could only say yesterday that any talk of a bailout for the corporation was “under consideration.”

Last year, a $6B subvention was approved in the budget to assist the ailing sugar industry. The political opposition at the time had stated that the approval of the subvention was based on ensuring that enhanced competence and less politicisation of the board and the management was achieved. Since then, former PPP/C minister Shaik Baksh was appointed Chairman of the Board in a move that was criticised as rewarding PPP-aligned persons with high level positions.

The Chairman of the Board told Stabroek News that he would not be commenting on whether or not the board was privy to the situation and of a possible industry shutdown by the end of the week.

Former Agriculture Minister Dr Leslie Ramsammy when contacted said that the new government and the CEO would be the ones to determine what the way forward was.

As of June last year, GuySuCo’s debt was at a whopping $58B equivalent to 31.6% of the 2014 National Budget.

Stabroek News was unable to reach Singh for comment up to press time yesterday.

 

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Like Singh has been in cahoot with the PPP to use GuySuCo as a cash cow to rip off the tax payers. I hope he is not allowed to leave Guyana before a proper investigation and audit is done. We all want to know what he had done with the money.

Mr.T
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

Like Singh has been in cahoot with the PPP to use GuySuCo as a cash cow to rip off the tax payers. I hope he is not allowed to leave Guyana before a proper investigation and audit is done. We all want to know what he had done with the money.

Isn't Guysuco Audited by Independent auditors?

FM

GuySuCo debt at $58B

By Staff Writer On July 18, 2014 @ 5:20 am In Local News

The Guyana Sugar Corporation is currently $58 billion in debt with $22.4 billion (US$112M) stemming from loans needed to build and operate the beleaguered Skeldon Sugar Factory.

GuySuCo’s current debt was made public during a meeting of the corporation with the Economic Services Committee (ESC) of Parliament yesterday, the second in less than a week. The company’s Finance Director Paul Bhim stated that currently GuySuCo’s short-term debt was $19.4 billion which meant payments needed to be serviced on a monthly basis.

Bhim revealed that the company was behind on payments to the National Insurance Scheme (NIS) by over $729 million. He noted that the sum did not include the interest that is supposed to be surcharged. In fact, Bhim stated that there has been no interest incurred over the course of the four months that GuySuCo has fallen behind on payments to the NIS.

He did state that just this week GuySuCo was able to repay one third of the amount owing to the NIS. As it stands, however, the state-owned company‘s finances are far worse than expected. Bhim stated that the company owned $2.7 billion to the Government of Guyana inclusive of payments to the Guyana Revenue Authority (GRA) and PAYE income tax.

Paul BhimPaul Bhim

Making for an even more dire situation, GuySuCo was forced to take out a US$15 million loan from the National Commercial Bank of Jamaica to cover the operating costs of the company. The loan is to be paid back in a year. Bhim revealed that while GuySuCo has been able to repay the seven commercial banks in Guyana $800 million, there is an outstanding debt of $2.2 billion.

Neither GuySuCo’s Finance Director nor the Chief Executive Officer, Rajendra Singh could tell the committee just how the company would be repaying these loans considering that it owes in excess of $3 billion in corporation taxes.

GuySuCo’s debt of $58B is equivalent to 31.6% of this year’s budget before cuts by the opposition or 26.3% of the original presentation by Finance Minister Dr Ashni Singh. GuySuCo’s production has slumped over the last decade and international market conditions have not been attractive.

The corporation has also been buffeted by higher expenses, the underperforming Skeldon factory, industrial relations issues and severe weather.

Chairman of the ESC, APNU MP Carl Greenidge was stunned at the size of GuySuCo’s debt. He referred to the situation involving the amount owed to the GRA, NIS, PAYE and in corporate tax beyond worrying.

When asked about their plans to repay the debts, Bhim stated that in relation to PAYE it was not feasible for the company to be up-to-date due to the world market prices for sugar. Greenidge however remarked that the current low market price was the reality of the situation and moving forward the company needed to address the fact that sugar prices were not going anywhere and that preferential pricing was coming to an end very shortly.

 

Skeldon

 

The troubled Skeldon factory continues to be problematic. The US$200 million project has been rife with problems since it was commissioned in 2009, never delivering on production promises. It has proved to be a financial drain on the industry. The factory was supposed to have the capacity to produce 110,000 tonnes of sugar annually with the ability to grind 350 tonnes of cane per hour. Instead, the grinding capacity has never exceeded 250 tonnes an hour and in 2013 Skeldon produced less than 25,000 tonnes of sugar.

Bhim stated that long-term debts were all directly related to the Skeldon Modernization Project including US$56 million owed to the World Bank, US$32 million owed to the Export-Import Bank of China, and US$24 million owed to the Caribbean Development Bank for agriculture expansion.

With the corporation struggling to service short-term debt there was very little to be said on the tackling of long-term debt. Greenidge stated that when the ESC meets again in October, GuySuCo would need to be prepared to answer on the cost of production and the long-term measures to be in place to cut the massive debt.

 

Subventions

 

He stated that GuySuCo had to accept the reality of the current world sugar price which hovers around US$0.16 per pound and production costs needed to be cut. Greenidge said that GuySuCo had to make firm commitments and it needed to be reminded that subventions from the treasury were not permanent options for the industry and the company needed to address how they would be repaying that as well.

Bhim was asked to break down how the state-owned company utilized the $10 billion given to it via subventions in 2013 and 2014. He said that of the $6 billion approved in 2014, none went to operating expenditure. Instead the money went directly to capital expenditure: $1.2 billion for infrastructure including land conversion, $1 billion for machinery, $1.1 billion in factory maintenance, just under $1 billion for tillage and the replanting programme, $350 million to factor spares, $270 million to rehabilitate cane punts and $100 million to service the fleet of generators.

For 2013, Bhim revealed that $1.5 billion was directed toward improving drainage and irrigation, $437 million went into land conversion. Bhim noted that the weather held up land conversion last year and the company did plan on converting more land for mechanization however it was not possible. He noted that $250 million was spent on field machinery and an additional $231 million was spent specifically on cane punts.

During the meeting of the ESC, the company was once again told to be prepared to showcase just how production costs will be adjusted to facilitate the turnaround of the industry. This is the second time GuySuCo was brought before the committee in recent days, the last being on Friday when it was found that the company was not prepared for a presentation on the 2013-2017 Strategic Plan.

Yesterday’s meeting was revealing and members of the committee stated that with this new information they would be better equipped to formulate specific questions including how mechanization will work in conjunction with the dwindling labour force.

 

 

 

 

FM

Guysuco is behind on payments to the National Insurance Scheme (NIS) by over $729 million.

 

Yet Raj Singh teking home over US$10,000 a month.

 

Why don't we not pay him for the rest of time he is on the job?

FM
Last edited by Former Member

GuySuCo swamped in debt; owes NIS, GRA, local Banks

July 17, 2014 2:54 pm Category: Politics A+ / A-

 

By Kurt Campbell

Minister of Agriculture, Dr L eslie Ramsammy flanked by CEO of GuySuCo, Dr Rajendra Singh [right) and Finance Director, Paul Bhim. [iNews' Photo]

Minister of Agriculture, Dr L eslie Ramsammy flanked by CEO of GuySuCo, Dr Rajendra Singh (right) and Finance Director, Paul Bhim. [iNews’ Photo]

[www.inewsguyana.com] – The Guyana Sugar Corporation (GuySuCo) owes some GYD $19.4 billion in short term debt, among which is $700 million owed to the National Insurance Scheme (NIS) after the corporation failed to pay insurance for hundreds of workers over the last four months.

 

According to GuySuCo’s Finance Director, Paul Bhim the company which is one of the largest employers in Guyana also owes the Guyana Revenue Authority (GRA) $2.7 billion in PAYE and property taxes. The Corporation also owes local banks some $2.5 billion.

Bhim along with other senior Officers of GuySuCo and Agriculture Minister Dr. Leslie Ramsammy were at the time addressing the Parliamentary Sectoral Committee on Economic Services.

Bhim explained that by the end of the year GuySuCo hopes to become current with its payment to the NIS but said it will not be able to do the same for GRA.

Meanwhile, the Finance Director pointed out that in the long term the company has a debt of US $112 million which is primarily related to the Skeldon Factory. Of the US$112 million, $56M is owed to the World Bank, $32M to the China Exim Bank and $24 million the Caribbean Development Bank.

He said the Corporation is current in meeting its weekly and monthly labour commitments with regards to paying employees and assured that that will remain as it is.

Bhim gave a breakdown of how the subvention which was given to the Corporation in 2013 and 2014 was and is intended to be spent.

With regard to the $6 billion 2014 subvention, Bhim outlined that $2.1 billion would be spent on upgrading infrastructure, just over $1 billion will be spent to procure tractor and fuel machinery, $1.1 billion on factory works and repairs. Also $350 million will be used to repair pumps, $270 million to procure punts and $30 million will be used to buy generator sets.

Bhim said most of the 2013 subvention was used on improving field and factory standards.

In recent time there has been much debate surrounding the viability of GuySuCo with calls being made for it to stop sugar production. Over the last three years government has had to provide subsidies to the Corporation in wake of reduced production.

 

 

 

---------------------------

 

 

ALL OF THIS HAPPENED UNDER THE JAGDEO PPP.

FM

T, you foolish. For your information ...the PPP did reduce the national debt. However, they allowed the sugar industry to slide in the negative. Sugar is not competitive, its a bad investment. They need to be honest, SHUT IT DOWN, give the land to workers and focus on more productive industries that will drag us into the technology world.  

V
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

T, you foolish. For your information ...the PPP did reduce the national debt. However, they allowed the sugar industry to slide in the negative. Sugar is not competitive, its a bad investment. They need to be honest, SHUT IT DOWN, give the land to workers and focus on more productive industries that will drag us into the technology world.  

So then, was the diversification "Other Crops" division of LFSB not a smart move?

FM
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

T, you foolish. For your information ...the PPP did reduce the national debt. However, they allowed the sugar industry to slide in the negative. Sugar is not competitive, its a bad investment. They need to be honest, SHUT IT DOWN, give the land to workers and focus on more productive industries that will drag us into the technology world.  

Oi you CUNUMUNU Vish Mahabir.  Only now you want to shut down sugar.  Granger/Nagamootoo will turn it around and make it profitable again.

 

 

 

Sit tight in your chair and watch.

FM

GUYSUCO a company with all this debt supporting

16000+ employees mostly Indos,and managed by

Indos and they have the gall to say other ethnicity

can't run a cake shop.These guys have poor

management skills.

Django

Diversification is an option, but we simply cannot pump more and more money into the factory at Skeldon when its not productive to do so. There are too many sugar substitutes, cane sugar is losing its appeal. And, we are not competitive at this time. We cannot let emotions tie us to the industry. Trinidad made this decision a long time ago and give the Caroni land to the workers. All I am saying is we need to come up with a workable plan and diversify or shut it down. Brazil is producing ethanol, they diversified because they realized a long time ago that sugar as a commodity is not a good crop to sell on the international market. 

V
Originally Posted by Ramakant-P:

With the help from a communist state Guysuco will florish.

 

APNU/AFC does not know the difference between water grass and cane.

 

 

you mus have a sugar rush or something

FM
Originally Posted by Ramakant-P:

With the help from a communist state Guysuco will florish.

 

APNU/AFC does not know the difference between water grass and cane.

 

 

If PPP so smart, why is this a shambles

FM

The elections are over. Time to tell the truth. And the truth is the sugar is no longer a financially viable industry in Guyana. It cannot be fixed. The new government must do the right thing and gradually phase out sugar. There will some hardships for sugar workers and their families. But they'll survive.

 

Rev

FM
Originally Posted by RiffRaff:
Originally Posted by Ramakant-P:

With the help from a communist state Guysuco will florish.

 

APNU/AFC does not know the difference between water grass and cane.

 

 

you mus have a sugar rush or something

Sugar after it is fermented and distilled, aka rum,

Mars
Originally Posted by Django:

GUYSUCO a company with all this debt supporting

16000+ employees mostly Indos,and managed by

Indos and they have the gall to say other ethnicity

can't run a cake shop.These guys have poor

management skills.

I doubt it's one on management skills more political will.  In it's current form and scale, the industry in hardly viable.  What is needed is an evaluation of the strategic alternatives  and the political will to make the choice, to be or not to be and at what price.

 

No amount of "medication" will save a naturally dying organism, and if it not a natural death, then the proper medication need to be administered.  Like Bauxite, the Sugar industry needs tough actions and choices at a strategic and political level.  It's out of the hands of operational management.

FM
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

Like Singh has been in cahoot with the PPP to use GuySuCo as a cash cow to rip off the tax payers. I hope he is not allowed to leave Guyana before a proper investigation and audit is done. We all want to know what he had done with the money.

Isn't Guysuco Audited by Independent auditors?

Crooks cook de books.

S
Originally Posted by VVP:
Why is Rajendra Singh still on the job under a new government?  Is he under a contract?  What do they pay him?

GoG should declare the company bankrupt and start all over. Fire everybody and repay all loans at US$0.02 to the dollar. 

S
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

And T....the coalition needs to send Raj Singh back to New Jersey where he belong.

He probably has an iron clad contract for life. It may not be that easy.

Mitwah
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

Diversification is an option, but we simply cannot pump more and more money into the factory at Skeldon when its not productive to do so. There are too many sugar substitutes, cane sugar is losing its appeal. And, we are not competitive at this time. We cannot let emotions tie us to the industry. Trinidad made this decision a long time ago and give the Caroni land to the workers. All I am saying is we need to come up with a workable plan and diversify or shut it down. Brazil is producing ethanol, they diversified because they realized a long time ago that sugar as a commodity is not a good crop to sell on the international market. 

PPP waited too late.  The PNC, under "my Avatar" started the diversification program which was always stymied by PPP's GAWU as canecuttah powah is what mattered, not strategic outcomes.  Baseman always contend the PNC's blueprint for Guyana's economic development had very solid strong points.  I never got what the PPP's blueprint was!

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by seignet:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

Like Singh has been in cahoot with the PPP to use GuySuCo as a cash cow to rip off the tax payers. I hope he is not allowed to leave Guyana before a proper investigation and audit is done. We all want to know what he had done with the money.

Isn't Guysuco Audited by Independent auditors?

Crooks cook de books.

Not sure what you mean.  I mean "Independent Auditors".

FM
Originally Posted by Brian Teekah:
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

T, you foolish. For your information ...the PPP did reduce the national debt. However, they allowed the sugar industry to slide in the negative. Sugar is not competitive, its a bad investment. They need to be honest, SHUT IT DOWN, give the land to workers and focus on more productive industries that will drag us into the technology world.  

Oi you CUNUMUNU Vish Mahabir.  Only now you want to shut down sugar.  Granger/Nagamootoo will turn it around and make it profitable again.

 

 

 

Sit tight in your chair and watch.

Dey doan have a clue how to do it. Dey in a rocking chair-lots of movement but dey ain going anywhere.

S
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by seignet:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

Like Singh has been in cahoot with the PPP to use GuySuCo as a cash cow to rip off the tax payers. I hope he is not allowed to leave Guyana before a proper investigation and audit is done. We all want to know what he had done with the money.

Isn't Guysuco Audited by Independent auditors?

Crooks cook de books.

Not sure what you mean.  I mean "Independent Auditors".

They said whatever the previous government wanted them to disclose.

S

While you're all haggling over the pros and cons of shutting down sugar vs diversification, lemme introduce two burning questions: How soon will the current GuySuCo Board of Directors be dissolved? Who is in favour of Tony Vieira being Chairman of the next GuySuCo Board?

FM
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

Diversification is an option, but we simply cannot pump more and more money into the factory at Skeldon when its not productive to do so. There are too many sugar substitutes, cane sugar is losing its appeal. And, we are not competitive at this time. We cannot let emotions tie us to the industry. Trinidad made this decision a long time ago and give the Caroni land to the workers. All I am saying is we need to come up with a workable plan and diversify or shut it down. Brazil is producing ethanol, they diversified because they realized a long time ago that sugar as a commodity is not a good crop to sell on the international market. 

PPP waited too late.  The PNC, under "my Avatar" started the diversification program which was always stymied by PPP's GAWU as canecuttah powah is what mattered, not strategic outcomes.  Baseman always contend thePNC's blueprint for Guyana's economic development had very solid strong points.  I never got what the PPP's blueprint was!

Bai yuh sure yuh want to talk with the other side of yuh mouth suh soon...yuh nah want to with fuh the keera cause by de PPP milk to heal...

sachin_05
Originally Posted by Rev:

The elections are over. Time to tell the truth. And the truth is the sugar is no longer a financially viable industry in Guyana. It cannot be fixed. The new government must do the right thing and gradually phase out sugar. There will some hardships for sugar workers and their families. But they'll survive.

 

Rev

Doan agree wid yuh.

S
Originally Posted by Gilbakka:

While you're all haggling over the pros and cons of shutting down sugar vs diversification, lemme introduce two burning questions: How soon will the current GuySuCo Board of Directors be dissolved? Who is in favour of Tony Vieira being Chairman of the next GuySuCo Board?

Good grief-not Veira.

S
Originally Posted by seignet:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by seignet:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by Mr.T:

Like Singh has been in cahoot with the PPP to use GuySuCo as a cash cow to rip off the tax payers. I hope he is not allowed to leave Guyana before a proper investigation and audit is done. We all want to know what he had done with the money.

Isn't Guysuco Audited by Independent auditors?

Crooks cook de books.

Not sure what you mean.  I mean "Independent Auditors".

They said whatever the previous government wanted them to disclose.

WHO are the "Independent" auditors.  They have Audit standards to comply with and is answerable to these, something which the new Gov could demand.  So, request the work papers and interview the partner and staff who documented the audit.  Or better, have a peer review done.

FM
Originally Posted by sachin_05:
Originally Posted by baseman:
Originally Posted by VishMahabir:

Diversification is an option, but we simply cannot pump more and more money into the factory at Skeldon when its not productive to do so. There are too many sugar substitutes, cane sugar is losing its appeal. And, we are not competitive at this time. We cannot let emotions tie us to the industry. Trinidad made this decision a long time ago and give the Caroni land to the workers. All I am saying is we need to come up with a workable plan and diversify or shut it down. Brazil is producing ethanol, they diversified because they realized a long time ago that sugar as a commodity is not a good crop to sell on the international market. 

PPP waited too late.  The PNC, under "my Avatar" started the diversification program which was always stymied by PPP's GAWU as canecuttah powah is what mattered, not strategic outcomes.  Baseman always contend thePNC's blueprint for Guyana's economic development had very solid strong points.  I never got what the PPP's blueprint was!

Bai yuh sure yuh want to talk with the other side of yuh mouth suh soon...yuh nah want to with fuh the keera cause by de PPP milk to heal...

Nah bai, you can go back and check my posts from years back, this is a point I always made here, in particular regarding the FCH drive.  Baseman's key criticisms of the PNC were/are their racism, military aided rule and their brand of corruption/cronyism.  Baseman also believed they made some tactical errors, but those are part of a learning curve and could be rectified.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Rev:

The elections are over. Time to tell the truth. And the truth is the sugar is no longer a financially viable industry in Guyana. It cannot be fixed. The new government must do the right thing and gradually phase out sugar. There will some hardships for sugar workers and their families. But they'll survive.

 

Rev

ethanol bhai,they should look in to the cost of

production.Brazil is big in this product.

Django
Last edited by Django
Originally Posted by Django:
Originally Posted by Rev:

The elections are over. Time to tell the truth. And the truth is the sugar is no longer a financially viable industry in Guyana. It cannot be fixed. The new government must do the right thing and gradually phase out sugar. There will some hardships for sugar workers and their families. But they'll survive.

 

Rev

ethanol bhai,they should look in to the cost of

production.Brazil is big in this product.

With the oil discovery, ethanol will take a long shot back seat.

FM
Originally Posted by seignet:
Originally Posted by Gilbakka:

While you're all haggling over the pros and cons of shutting down sugar vs diversification, lemme introduce two burning questions: How soon will the current GuySuCo Board of Directors be dissolved? Who is in favour of Tony Vieira being Chairman of the next GuySuCo Board?

Good grief-not Veira.

Why not? Tony Vieira's father owned two sugar estates, he is a trained agronomist and he has advocated diversification that could include aquaculture.

Vieira has more sugar industry credentials than Raj Singh and Donald Ramotar.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×