Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Sooba breaks her silence on Town Clerk issue : - says extraordinary meeting in City Hall compound was ‘tainted with illegalities’ and a ‘public relations stunt’ by the Mayor

 

Sooba breaks her silence on Town Clerk issue : - says extraordinary meeting in City Hall compound was ‘tainted with illegalities’ and a ‘public relations stunt’ by the Mayor

Georgetown Mayor Hamilton Green and Deputy Mayor Patricia Chase-Green at the extraordinary meeting in the City Hall yard, on Tuesday

 

ACTING Town Clerk of the Georgetown Municipality and Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the City Hall Administration Ms. Carol Sooba said, yesterday, that business there continues as per normal.

 

Breaking her silence on the alleged ‘illegal’ appointment of Public Relations Officer (PRO), Mr. Royston King, to the Town Clerk position by Mayor Hamilton Green, she stated that, at this point, she sits in her office undisturbed.


“Unless King has another Town Clerk office from which he intends to operate,” she wondered.


The Sixth Schedule Part I of the Municipal and District Councils Act Chap 28:01 gives the Town Clerk the responsibility of convening any meetings of the council, preparing the agenda, minutes and reports of any such meeting, which will be related to the Local Government officials.


According to her, the illegality of the decision taken Tuesday, in the absence of approval from the Local Government Minister, is null and void with immediate effect, since King is “not authorised” to sign cheques on behalf of the Town Clerk, which is one of the administrative duties of the post.


Sooba is adamant that the Tuesday meeting was tainted with illegalities, stemming from the misunderstanding, by the Mayor and Councillors, of the Acting Chief Justice’s ruling, as well as the Municipal and District Councils Act Chap 28:01.


She remarked that the Mayor held an extraordinary meeting of the City Council, which was not in keeping with the local government legislation, asserting that his action of convening it in the compound of City Hall was “a public relations stunt.”

 

NOT NECESSARY
Deputy Mayor Patricia Chase-Green, who was in attendance at the meeting on Tuesday, maintained that the symbolism of the Council Chamber is not necessary for the purpose.


She insisted that the only symbolic item which would be needed was the Statutory Mace and that was in the possession of the Mayor, who took it without permission from Sooba, who remains the custodian of such items belonging to the Council.


Sooba said the Mayor, through the Councillors, has the right to call for the convening of an extraordinary meeting of the council. However, it is the duty of the Town Clerk to sign the summons for it, providing that it fulfils the need for urgency of a matter too significant to be held off until the next statutory Council meeting.

 

GUIDING DOCUMENT
She continued that it is the duty of the Town Clerk to approve of the agenda, which is the guiding document of instruction for every meeting, such as the agenda that was not approved by the Town Clerk, but instead was imposed by the Mayor and Deputy Mayor.


Sooba told the Guyana Chronicle that Mayor Green must not have understood the principles governing a “stay of execution” which was made effective when the Local Government and Regional Development Minister, Norman Whittaker, filed an appeal, which is yet to be heard.


She said the Mayor, clearly, does not understand the meaning of a “de facto” ruling, because that of Acting Chief Justice Ian Chang meant that the status of the Town Clerk would be maintained by her, allowing her to hold office until the appeal by the Local Government Minister, against the decision in favour of King, was determined.


Sooba pointed out that King was at the extraordinary meeting and was merely trying to railroad over the appeal and she admonished him.


She said she has found it difficult to sign cheques for payment to a man she perceives has not been doing the work of the Public Relations Officer.


Sooba disclosed that she has since been advised by the Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs, Mr. Anil Nandlall that legal action will be taken against the decision favouring King.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Mayor illegally appoints King as Town Clerk

… at extraordinary meeting in City Hall compound

By Derwayne Wills, May 6, 2014, Source

THE Mayor and Councillors of Georgetown have once again moved to have Public Relations Officer (PRO) Royston King illegally appointed as Town Clerk.Yesterday they removed Carol Sooba from that position, but not by means in keeping with the provisions of the Municipal and District Councils Act Ch28:01.


The motion of removal, moved by City Councillor Hector Stoute, was approved unanimously by the quorum of Councillors, with a subsequent additional motion moved by Councillor Ranwell Jordan, which was also approved unanimously, proposing that King be appointed as Town Clerk, with immediate effect.

 

The extraordinary City Council meeting in progress

The extraordinary City Council meeting in progress

 

The motion was introduced during an extraordinary meeting of the Town Council, yesterday, convened in the presence of Georgetown Mayor Hamilton Green and Deputy Mayor Patricia Chase-Green, along with a quorum of Councillors, and in the City Hall compound.


King is no stranger to the media, after the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development, Norman Whittaker, had alleged that the PRO had fraudulently misrepresented the capacity of Town Clerk by signing tax waivers to the sum of some $36M to the Beacon Foundation, prompting the Minister to call on the Guyana Police Force and the Office of the Auditor General to investigate these waivers. This matter is still before the investigative entities.


In keeping with Article 118(1) of the Municipal and District Councils Act Chapter 28:01, which reads to the effect that the power to appoint persons to hold or act in any local government office and the power to remove any such local government officer from office shall be vested in the Local Government Commission; the Act further provides in Article 119(1) that any such decision taken by the Commission must be approved by the powers duly vested in the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

 

In the absence of the Local Government Commission, which is to be constituted by the Prime Minister, the powers of the Commission are conferred to the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

Councillor Fraser, however, was adamant that “[the] minister has no authority, power or jurisdiction over [the] council”, further adding that, “We decided we will have Mr. King assume position until [the] Commission is set up.”

 

Mayor of Georgetown, Hamilton Green closed the session with the affirmation, “We shall indicate to the appropriate authorities this decision taken”,

 

The dispute over the Town Clerk’s appointment has spanned over the tenure of three successive Local Government Ministers, Kellawan Lall, Ganga Persaud and Norman Whittaker. Once again the Council has found itself in a dilemma by seeking to override the powers of the Local Government Minister in keeping with the constitutionally provided selection process of appointing local government officers in the absence of a Local Government Commission.

 

This advance by the City officials was initially brought to the table in March, 2011 by Councillor Jordan, prompting a rejection by then Minister of Local Government and Regional Development, Kellawan Lall, who was appalled at the selection process of moving to appoint King as Town Clerk with immediate effect.


The then minister had made clear his position that “the motion collides with the Municipal and District Councils Act. You cannot appoint someone with immediate effect when, in fact, you have to make a recommendation to the minister”. Lall further added that he “cannot understand why this motion was allowed. It cannot stand scrutiny”.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:
In keeping with Article 118(1) of the Municipal and District Councils Act Chapter 28:01, which reads to the effect that the power to appoint persons to hold or act in any local government office and the power to remove any such local government officer from office shall be vested in the Local Government Commission; the Act further provides in Article 119(1) that any such decision taken by the Commission must be approved by the powers duly vested in the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

 

In the absence of the Local Government Commission, which is to be constituted by the Prime Minister, the powers of the Commission are conferred to the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

 

Councillor Fraser, however, was adamant that “[the] minister has no authority, power or jurisdiction over [the] council”, further adding that, “We decided we will have Mr. King assume position until [the] Commission is set up.”

 

Simple matter of abiding with the decisions of the Local Government Commission and, in its absence, the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

FM
Last edited by Former Member

City Mayor has no power to dispose of Town Clerk’s services : - action shows contempt of citizens – Dr. Luncheon

 

GOVERNMENT remains adamant that neither Georgetown Mayor Hamilton Green nor the City Council as a collective (M&CC) has the power to appoint a Town Clerk, because that power resides in the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

 

As such, Head of the Presidential Secretariat and Cabinet Secretary, Dr. Roger Luncheon, said the recent actions by the Mayor of Georgetown, Hamilton Green, to ignore the Acting Town Clerk, Carol Sooba, and illegally appoint Royston King as Town Clerk, reflect nothing but contempt for Guyanese.

 

Speaking to reporters on the issue during his usual post-Cabinet press briefing yesterday, Dr. Luncheon said that just this past Tuesday, Mayor Green appointed City Council’s Public Relations Officer, Royston King, as Town Clerk at an extraordinary statutory meeting.

 

“As his political career appears to be winding down, the mayor seems anxious to recreate sentiments, memories of his political past. His contempt for the sensitivities of Guyanese continues and, indeed as before, it knows no bounds,” Luncheon remarked.

 

Dr. Luncheon said the mayor and his acolytes put on a show during last Easter Monday, when he was accused of atrocious behaviour. “The mayor is certainly liable for prosecution. Not satisfied with that exhibition, he raised his contempt to new heights in summoning an extraordinary meeting of the council, at which three motions were to be dealt with.”


The motions sought to dispose of the services of the Town Clerk and of Chairman of the Finance Committee, Junior Garrett. “The mayor has no such power; has been told that he has no such power; the mayor knows he has no such power.

 

“This pathetic display obviously is more evidence of his contempt for Guyanese.”

 

Meanwhile, the motion seeking to remove the current Town Clerk from that position, moved by City Councillor Hector Stoute, was unanimously approved by the quorum of councillors present at Tuesday’s meeting called by the mayor. And there was a subsequent additional motion moved by Councillor Ranwell Jordan, which was also approved unanimously, proposing that King be appointed as Town Clerk with immediate effect.

 

King faces an allegation of fraudulently misrepresenting the capacity of Town Clerk by signing tax waivers to the sum of some $36M to the Beacon Foundation, prompting the Local Government Minister to call on the Guyana Police Force and the Office of the Auditor General to investigate those waivers.

 

This matter is still before the investigative entities.

 

In keeping with Article 118(1) of the Municipal and District Councils Act, Chapter 28:01, which reads to the effect that the power to appoint persons to hold or act in any local government office, and the power to remove any such local government officer from office shall be vested in the Local Government Commission; the Act further provides, in Article 119(1), that any such decision taken by the Commission must be approved by the powers duly vested in the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

 

In the absence of the Local Government Commission, which is to be constituted by the Prime Minister, the powers of the Commission are conferred upon the Minister of Local Government and Regional Development.

 

The dispute over the Town Clerk’s appointment has spanned the tenure of three successive Local Government Ministers: Mr. Kellawan Lall, Mr. Ganga Persaud and Mr. Norman Whittaker.

FM
Originally Posted by KishanB:

GO Shuba, bun Hammie out from the place.

rather than cheerleading PPP powah, racism and ignorance, mite i suggest u spend some of that ill-used time pointing out that a REAL solution is to hold LOCAL GOV'T ELECTIONS!!

 

Hammie is not the problem

 

but u knew dat already, rite?

FM
Originally Posted by redux:
Originally Posted by KishanB:

GO Shuba, bun Hammie out from the place.

rather than cheerleading PPP powah, racism and ignorance, mite i suggest u spend some of that ill-used time pointing out that a REAL solution is to hold LOCAL GOV'T ELECTIONS!!

 

Hammie is not the problem

 

but u knew dat already, rite?

Kishan, redux has a point here. Hamilton Green is not the real problem. He is the PPP's convenient scapegoat.

If we go back to the results of the last local government elections exactly 20 years ago we will see that the majority of Georgetown citizens didn't vote for PPP councillors. Remember, the PPP had disbanded the City Council some time before the elections and installed an Interim Management Committee headed by Dr James Rose, a personal friend of Dr Cheddi Jagan. The PPP then gave the IMC plenty money and material assistance to fix potholes, repave the streets, clean the canals and gutters, etc. All of that didn't produce the desired outcome for the PPP.

The election showed that Georgetown citizens didn't trust the PPP to manage their city. The elections produced Hamilton Green as Mayor, duly and democratically elected. The PPP didn't like that. The PPP was not generous with helping Green as it helped its handpicked IMC.

So, over the past 20 years, with businesses and homeowners failing consistently to pay rates and taxes, it was inevitable that conditions in Georgetown would deteriorate. This is what the PPP wanted. In fact, former local government minister Kellawan Lall is on record as saying that he hoped a health crisis hit Georgetown as a result of a mountain of accumulated garbage.

Hamilton Green is the PPP scapegoat.

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×