Skip to main content

Tackling suicide

FOR the past couple of years, suicide has been a problem that has bedevilled Guyana, and even though much has been said about the scourge, not much has been done to address it.

Many would recall, with shock, that prominent social activist Zenita Nicholson took her own life last year because of abuse and depression. In November of that very year, the nation read about the tragic death of teenagers Kavita Ackloo and Ramesh Persaud, who took their lives by consuming a poisonous substance. Their bodies were found on the Kingston Seawall. The young couple was said to have had a rocky relationship.

Fast forward to 2016, and with only a few days in the New Year, 14-year-old Sherryanne Alli and her adult lover, Deoraj Persaud, who under the law would have been deemed a statutory rapist, were found hanging in a bedroom of the home of a relative. Media reports suggest that their dreadful act stemmed from well-intentioned advice to end their illicit relationship.

These are just few of the many cases of suicide that have occurred over the past five years. It is important to point out that, immediately after the death of Nicholson, Ackloo and Ramesh Persaud, the Indian Arrival Committee (IAC) had issued an appeal to the Government, Opposition and religious leaders, among others, to come together and develop a national strategy to address the scourge of suicide.
Accordingly, it is refreshing to hear that President David Granger, through a multi-sectorial approach, will be mobilising experts, both local and foreign, to enquire into the real causes of suicide, and have those causes tangibly addressed.

Some of the prominent risk factors local health officials have identified include acute emotional distress, mental disorder, impulsivity, aggressive tendencies, adolescent maladaptive disorder, and alcohol abuse.

The President’s concerns are understandable, because, in Guyana, 34.7 per 100,000 deaths, and not 44.2 per 100,000 as was reported in both the local and international press, are from suicide. This is way above the global average of 11.4 per 100,000 and towers over the average 6.1 per 100,000 rate in Latin America and the Caribbean, as was highlighted at the Caribbean Public Health Agency’s 60th health research conference in Grenada last year.

While there is no cure for suicide, as people will always do as they see fit, suicide is 100 per cent preventable. The unfortunate problem we are faced with in Guyana is that, although this country has gained notoriety for its high suicide rate, no sustained strategic effort was ever undertaken by the previous administration to tackle the social debacle.

The recent announcement by President Granger is a significant step in the right direction, since it would address the travesty of the neglect of a grave problem especially affecting the East Indian community. Some 80 per cent of the victims of suicide in Guyana are of East Indian descent. That aside, the vast majority of victims take their lives by consuming poison, while a small number hang or shoot themselves.

It is imperative to note that tackling suicide must first begin by controlling the means people use to take their lives. And it cannot be overstated that the Government must do all it can to get poisonous substances out of the hands of farmers and others who are vulnerable.

We think that persons buying chemicals should simultaneously be made to pay for the services of an extension officer or any other designated professional to administer it.

But whatever measures are taken, greater attention should be paid to the East Indian community, since this is by far the most affected group.

The general impression in society is that the Afro-Guyanese slog their way out of personal relationship problems whilst East Indians turn to alcohol and resort to suicide.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Django posted:

Tackling suicide

 

The general impression in society is that the Afro-Guyanese slog their way out of personal relationship problems whilst East Indians turn to alcohol and resort to suicide.

The role of the Afro and Indo Guyanese women within both their family structures, and within society at large, accounts for a big part of the difference.

Indo Guyanese, and especially rural Indian families are very patriarchal and traditional. 

Afro Guyanese (along side virtually all of the Transatlantic Afro descendants) have a matriarchal system.  I think that women are more empowered within these structures, and also have more support from networks of other women.

In fact higher levels of mental illness among African males might well be because they are more marginal to their family structures.  Also it is likely that blacks have this notion that they must always be in control of their lives, and so bury stress.  Fewer suicides, but more mental illness.

As a mental health professional in Guyana once (unofficially) said, "blacks run mad, Indians kill themselves".  Different responses to stress.

FM
RiffRaff posted:
Nehru posted:

It has become WORST since May 11. INCOMPETENCE is the reason!!!!!!!!!

I agree...all those people committing suicide are incompetent to deal with simple everyday issues

Its just amazing that all of the data which suggests that Guyana has a very high rate of suicide refers to the era when the PPP was in control.

  When discussion of suicides occurred when the PPP was in control, the PPP clowns screamed incredulity that gov't should be held responsible for suicides.

Now with an electoral loss I guess every thing changes.  Suddenly the PNC (blackman) is responsible for the fact that Indians are 6X more likely to kill themselves than are non Indians.

FM
Django posted:

Tackling suicide

We think that persons buying chemicals should simultaneously be made to pay for the services of an extension officer or any other designated professional to administer it.

But whatever measures are taken, greater attention should be paid to the East Indian community, since this is by far the most affected group.

 

If people are suicidal they will find ways to kill themselves.  If not by poison, then by rope.

The vast majority of farmers are NOT prone to suicide, so I see no reason why unnecessary red tape should be involved.  We all know that this will only introduce a new layer of corruption, punishing the poorer farmers who will be less able to buy their way out of the bureaucracy.

What is needed is INDEPTH analysis of the problem. 

What are the root causes? 

What are the strategies which can be develop to deal with the problem? 

How can those who feel so depressed that they would kill themselves be induced to outreach to people/institutions which might be able to help? 

Does Guyana have CULTURALLY competent professionals who can offer counseling?  The pandit stooped in his traditional ways, or the creolized "bougie" G/town professional might not be able to help these people cope.

So who?

And why are Africans less suicide prone?  Are there lessons there? Given ample family dysfunction within Afro Caribbean households, and the resulting stress, one would think that these women would be more suicide prone, but they aren't.  So what coping mechanisms do poor African descendant women have throughout the Americas, that rural Indo Caribbean women seem to lack?

It seems to me as if many of the suicides involve females.  Either women killing themselves alone, or in tandem with a male lover.

FM
Last edited by Former Member
caribny posted:
Django posted:

Tackling suicide

We think that persons buying chemicals should simultaneously be made to pay for the services of an extension officer or any other designated professional to administer it.

But whatever measures are taken, greater attention should be paid to the East Indian community, since this is by far the most affected group.

 

If people are suicidal they will find ways to kill themselves.  If not by poison, then by rope.

The vast majority of farmers are NOT prone to suicide, so I see no reason why unnecessary red tape should be involved.  We all know that this will only introduce a new layer of corruption, punishing the poorer farmers who will be less able to buy their way out of the bureaucracy.

What is needed is INDEPTH analysis of the problem. 

What are the root causes? 

What are the strategies which can be develop to deal with the problem? 

How can those who feel so depressed that they would kill themselves be induced to outreach to people/institutions which might be able to help? 

Does Guyana have CULTURALLY competent professionals who can offer counseling?  The pandit stooped in his traditional ways, or the creolized "bougie" G/town professional might not be able to help these people cope.

So who?

And why are Africans less suicide prone?  Are there lessons there? Given ample family dysfunction within Afro Caribbean households, and the resulting stress, one would think that these women would be more suicide prone, but they aren't.  So what coping mechanisms do poor African descendant women have throughout the Americas, that rural Indo Caribbean women seem to lack?

It seems to me as if many of the suicides involve females.  Either women killing themselves alone, or in tandem with a male lover.

Comrade, I think u r missing an important fact. So far from what I am reading is young people killing themselves over romantic relationship. In the Afro community, it is no sweat if a young girl has several children and unmarried. Now, among rural indians, they know that is not something that goes down too well among friends and family. For the town indians, sleeping around and having children out of wedlock may be acceptable in GT. Let's say, the rural have some values to moral standards. 

Suh doan blame the indian parents. Doan blame this government nor the previous one. Young people have to stop watching too many Bollywood movies imagining themselves to starbai and stargal.

Granger should do something about getting the whole nation to start thinking different. As the comment made on this BB, he should seek international help. With that, help from the diaspora should follow. 

S

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×