Skip to main content

FM
Former Member

Texeira: Clerk is the ‘gatekeeper’ of Parliamentary procedures

 

November 3, 2014, Source - Guyana Chronicle

 

Texeira: Clerk is the ‘gatekeeper’ of Parliamentary procedures
President Donald Ramotar

 

PRESIDENT Donald Ramotar has directed that steps be taken to convene a sitting of the National Assembly within the next 14 days.

 

And Presidential Advisor on Governance and Government Chief Whip, Ms. Gail Teixeira, contends that the Clerk of the National Assembly, Mr. Sherlock Isaacs, is the “gatekeeper” of parliamentary procedures.

 

gail-teixeira
Her comments followed statements by House Speaker, Mr. Raphael Trotman, who told the Guyana Chronicle that he is not “bound” by the advice of the Clerk of the National Assembly, who denied his request for a sitting of the Assembly on November 6.


Asked to comment on the matter, Teixeira agreed with this contention, but stressed that Isaacs is obligated not to allow a breach of the Standing Orders, which according to him, places the power to call a sitting, under the current circumstances, with the Central Government.


“The Clerk is the person who advises on parliamentary procedures and business of the House and, yes, while the Speaker does not have to take the clerk’s advice,” Texeira said, adding:
“…the Clerk is obligated to protect the Standing Order of the Parliament, to ensure that they are being applied correctly. He is the gatekeeper of the Parliament, and therefore the Speaker may be making a point, but he has to consider the other side of it….the Clerk cannot do something to breach the Standing Order.”

 

Sherlock Isaacs

Sherlock Isaacs

 

According to her, the definition of the Speaker’s role is clearly defined. “It may be true that the Speaker does not have to rely on the Clerk, but the other side of the coin is that the Clerk is obligated to ensure that the Standing Orders are not breached,” she said.


CONTRAVENTION OF STANDING ORDER

The Government Chief Whip pointed out that the fact that the Speaker requested a sitting, found him in contravention of the Standing Order.

 

Amna Ally

 

“In the letter from the Speaker he requested that the Clerk set a date, but under what Standing Order was that request made. No orders allow him to make such a request. As such, the Clerk cannot accept a request or instruction that would go against the Standing Orders,” she said.


Teixeira stressed that Standing Order 8 sets out clearly the guidelines for calling a sitting of the House.


Standing Order 8 addressed the grounds on which sittings are called and states clearly where the authority to call such a sitting lies.


The ‘Ordinary Sitting of the Assembly’ is addressed in Standing Order 8 (1), which says: “(1) Save as otherwise provided by the Constitution or resolved by the Assembly upon a motion moved by a Minister, the Assembly may sit every day except Saturdays and Sundays and, unless the Assembly otherwise decide, every adjournment of the Assembly shall be to the next Sitting day.”


Standing Order 8 (2), ‘Sitting convened at the discretion of the Speaker’, adds that: “(2) If, during an adjournment of the Assembly, it is represented to the Speaker by the Government, or the Speaker is of the opinion, that the public interest requires that the Assembly should meet on a day earlier than that to which it stands adjourned, the Speaker may give notice accordingly and the Assembly shall meet at the time stated in such notice. The Clerk shall as soon as possible inform each Member in writing, or telegram or by appropriate electronic means of any such earlier meeting.”
Attempts to contact the main Opposition’s Chief Whip, Ms. Amna Ally, proved futile.

 

Speaker Raphael Trotman

Speaker Raphael Trotman

 

Additionally, the Government, since the President’s call for a sitting, has reiterated its position that the convening of a sitting of the National Assembly must be done in accordance with the Standing Orders and long cherished parliamentary practices. The Government had a number of pending legislative matters to be brought before the House prior to the annual recess. Further there are important financial papers relating to the development of the country and growth of the economy that need to be urgently addressed.

 

Source - http://guyanachronicle.com/tex...amentary-procedures/

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Cobra:

Sherlock Isaacs

The Gatekeeper of parliamentary procedures.  

 

If Trotman don't understand his role as speaker, he should step down.

The next election will determine his eligibility for Speaker.

FM
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:
Originally Posted by Cobra:

Sherlock Isaacs

The Gatekeeper of parliamentary procedures.  

 

If Trotman don't understand his role as speaker, he should step down.

The next election will determine his eligibility for Speaker.

and i think habeeb khan dead

FM
Originally Posted by Cobra:

Sherlock Isaacs

The Gatekeeper of parliamentary procedures.  If Trotman don't understand his role as speaker, he should step down.

two past speaker support the speaker and you is the smart one 

FM
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:
Originally Posted by Cobra:

Sherlock Isaacs

The Gatekeeper of parliamentary procedures.  

 

If Trotman don't understand his role as speaker, he should step down.

The next election will determine his eligibility for Speaker.

The only speaker this fool will become is the one with a megaphone outside stabroek.

FM

The past Speakers simply expressed their views, while the specific part of the constitution regarding the start of this secession, after how it went into recess, indeed are quite distinct and different matters.

FM
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The past Speakers simply expressed their views, while the specific part of the constitution regarding the start of this secession, after how it went into recess, indeed are quite distinct and different matters.

Past speakers support Trotman specifically Ramkarran and Sase Narain.

 

Clerks have no authority to do jack shit. They are order takers, they are also not lawyers much less constitutional lawyers.

 

 

FM

The specific and extremely narrow issue relates to the start of the new session after the recess which are unrelated to the general views of the past Speakers.

 

Closure without specifying a start date = President of Guyana is the only one who then determines the start date of the next session.

FM
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The past Speakers simply expressed their views, while the specific part of the constitution regarding the start of this secession, after how it went into recess, indeed are quite distinct and different matters.

the bottomline is the ppp is scare to go to the poll now with the chat3 flexing his muscle the ppp is at the bottom of the barrel  

FM
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The session will start soon and issues will then follow according to the parliamentary issues.

not what the ppp  wish for but they have no  choice 

FM
Originally Posted by warrior:
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The session will start soon and issues will then follow according to the parliamentary issues.

not what the ppp  wish for but they have no  choice 

Warria

 

Welcome back. Hope all is well.

FM
Originally Posted by yuji22:
Originally Posted by warrior:
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The session will start soon and issues will then follow according to the parliamentary issues.

not what the ppp  wish for but they have no  choice 

Warria

 

Welcome back. Hope all is well.

i drop a few pounds living on jail food but will  survive    

FM
Originally Posted by warrior:
Originally Posted by yuji22:
Originally Posted by warrior:
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The session will start soon and issues will then follow according to the parliamentary issues.

not what the ppp  wish for but they have no  choice 

Warria

 

Welcome back. Hope all is well.

i drop a few pounds living on jail food but will  survive    

 

Glad to hear that you are back and in good health. Now behave yourself.

FM
Originally Posted by HM_Redux:

Gale "Rwanda" Texiera is the second coming of the white plague to Guyana. Janet was de fuss.

Looks like white is not one of your favorite colors. Is black or brown?

FM
Originally Posted by skeldon_man:
Originally Posted by HM_Redux:

Gale "Rwanda" Texiera is the second coming of the white plague to Guyana. Janet was de fuss.

Looks like white is not one of your favorite colors. Is black or brown?

Dutty low breeds is not my favorite color. Communist red is not a favorite color.

FM
Originally Posted by yuji22:
Originally Posted by warrior:
Originally Posted by yuji22:
Originally Posted by warrior:
Originally Posted by Demerara_Guy:

The session will start soon and issues will then follow according to the parliamentary issues.

not what the ppp  wish for but they have no  choice 

Warria

 

Welcome back. Hope all is well.

i drop a few pounds living on jail food but will  survive    

 

Glad to hear that you are back and in good health. Now behave yourself.

sure i am learning from anil

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×