Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
I'm thinking of application at home. How do you balance the concept that failure = experience at the same time letting children know it's not okay to sit back and fail under the guise of "gaining experience."


Perhaps you can say when motivation + action & innovation still result in failure, we called it valuable lesson. On the other hand, inaction, self limitation & slothfulness are the 'glittering' attributes of sluggards Wink
FM
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
I'm thinking of application at home. How do you balance the concept that failure = experience at the same time letting children know it's not okay to sit back and fail under the guise of "gaining experience."


Failure is not a word thought of in our home. We believe in nothing ventured nothing gained and coming up short is not regarded as failure. For instance, when my kids played sports, my response to every play was either 'nice play' or 'nice try'. This approach has made both of them very confident in their undertakings which shows up in their grades at school.
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Mara:
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
I'm thinking of application at home. How do you balance the concept that failure = experience at the same time letting children know it's not okay to sit back and fail under the guise of "gaining experience."


Perhaps you can say when motivation + action & innovation still result in failure, we called it valuable lesson. On the other hand, inaction, self limitation & slothfulness are the 'glittering' attributes of sluggards Wink
nice...
How things buddy. Thought you were off the board permanently.
A
My 14 year old is very active in baseball and kickboxing. Just started his amateur career with a win in November. Before every game or fight I tell him the same thing. Win or lose makes no difference as long as you play hard and fight hard. Same thing for academics. However, whether it's typical teenage behavior or not sometimes he seems like the laziest person in the world.
A
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
My 14 year old is very active in baseball and kickboxing. Just started his amateur career with a win in November. Before every game or fight I tell him the same thing. Win or lose makes no difference as long as you play hard and fight hard. Same thing for academics. However, whether it's typical teenage behavior or not sometimes he seems like the laziest person in the world.


I would say great choice with relative low risk of career ending injuries, longevity and high earning potential. Plus he has Guyanese bred Mark Texiera already in the NY Yankee club house holding the door open. Wink
FM
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
The power of failing
As a kid I once worked on a rather time consuming physics problem. I knew I got it right since I cross checked my math and it all worked out well and I felt I understood very well what was going on.

When my results came back I got a C on the test. I was very upset since I need an A for the course to remain on scholarship another year. It was the second of 4 exams and we only get to dump one for our final grade.

I went to the professor and complained bitterly. He said he would not change the grade as it would mean he give me permission to fail and failure in physics often means death. If my instruction involved delivery of supplies to astronauts my astronauts would be dead. My answer was 25g. I forget to writer 25 g/cubic centimeter.

Sometimes failure is not an option and permission to fail can mean catastrophe. I "killed" my astronauts and almost killed my scholarship for a year.
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Mara:
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
nice...
How things buddy. Thought you were off the board permanently.


Tends to get bored easily these days, but still hanging in there. Presently I am in Orlando for another couple of days and may be in the NY area later next week before heading back home.
Give me a shout when in NY if you have time to buss a lime.
A
quote:
Originally posted by D2:
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
The power of failing
As a kid I once worked on a rather time consuming physics problem. I knew I got it right since I cross checked my math and it all worked out well and I felt I understood very well what was going on.

When my results came back I got a C on the test. I was very upset since I need an A for the course to remain on scholarship another year. It was the second of 4 exams and we only get to dump one for our final grade.

I went to the professor and complained bitterly. He said he would not change the grade as it would mean he give me permission to fail and failure in physics often means death. If my instruction involved delivery of supplies to astronauts my astronauts would be dead. My answer was 25g. I forget to writer 25 g/cubic centimeter.

Sometimes failure is not an option and permission to fail can mean catastrophe. I "killed" my astronauts and almost killed my scholarship for a year.
Whether an option or not it happens. I think the issue is dealing with it in such a way as not to turn the person into a victim.
A
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
quote:
Originally posted by D2:
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
The power of failing
As a kid I once worked on a rather time consuming physics problem. I knew I got it right since I cross checked my math and it all worked out well and I felt I understood very well what was going on.

When my results came back I got a C on the test. I was very upset since I need an A for the course to remain on scholarship another year. It was the second of 4 exams and we only get to dump one for our final grade.

I went to the professor and complained bitterly. He said he would not change the grade as it would mean he give me permission to fail and failure in physics often means death. If my instruction involved delivery of supplies to astronauts my astronauts would be dead. My answer was 25g. I forget to writer 25 g/cubic centimeter.

Sometimes failure is not an option and permission to fail can mean catastrophe. I "killed" my astronauts and almost killed my scholarship for a year.
Whether an option or not it happens. I think the issue is dealing with it in such a way as not to turn the person into a victim.
I do not doubt it happens but in many jobs ie structural design, aeronautics/space flight etc one gives permission only to succeed as failure is not an option. When failure is contemplated it is to build redundancies to circumvent failure.

I do agree that failure is inevitable but I think the permission to fail is a permission to kill someone in science, engineering and certain areas of medicine. I leave the permission to fail to the creative enterprise and development where one speculate on possibilities rather in areas of practical applications and process.
FM
quote:
Originally posted by antabanta:
quote:
Originally posted by Mara:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by antabanta:
nice...
How things buddy. Thought you were off the board permanently.


Tends to get bored easily these days, but still hanging in there. Presently I am in Orlando for another couple of days and may be in the NY area later next week before heading back home.
Give me a shout when in NY if you have time to buss a lime.[/QUOTE

Will do, but you may have to PM me your digits again . Every time my cell (and glasses) goes over-board I lose all my contacts ( four time in the past five years) Wifey said I need to go back to slate & pencil and daughter said she would prescribe floating cow dung specs if I keep loosing them like that. Wink
FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×