Skip to main content

FM
Former Member
A 25-year-old woman is suing the doctor who delivered her when she was a baby, saying she would not have medical difficulties from erb's palsy today if he had just conducted a caesarean birth like her mother requested, according to news reports.

Halina Jane Gillett was born in 1985 in a hospital in Newcastle, Australia. Her mother, Marilyn Benson-Inglis, requested a C-section from her obstetrician Professor Jeffrey Robinson because the pregnancy was "much bigger" than her previous three pregnancies, Australia's The Telegraph reported.

However, Robinson ended up doing a forceps delivery, which Gillett says caused her erb's palsy, according to The Telegraph.

The medical condition leaves Gillett without full use of her arm. It is often caused by shoulder dystocia during birth, which occurs when the head and neck of the baby are pulled to the side while the shoulders are going through the birth canal, news.com.au reported.

Now, Gillett is taking Robinson to Australia's Supreme Court.

Source: Hoffpost.com

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Causes of Erb's Palsy
Erb's palsy most often occurs in difficult labor and deliveries, such as when a baby is too large to move smoothly through the birth canal, the baby is breech or the labor is delayed for whatever reason. In these situations, doctors may need to pull or apply some pressure to deliver the baby. The injury can result if the neck is stretched or the doctor does not take measures to free the shoulders and ensure a safe delivery. Although conditions for Erb's palsy to occur may be outside of anyone's control — such as if the baby is large — the injury is always caused by a medical error.

Source: birthinjuryinfo.com
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Cobra:
A 25-year-old woman is suing the doctor who delivered her when she was a baby, saying she would not have medical difficulties from erb's palsy today if he had just conducted a caesarean birth like her mother requested, according to news reports.

Halina Jane Gillett was born in 1985 in a hospital in Newcastle, Australia. Her mother, Marilyn Benson-Inglis, requested a C-section from her obstetrician Professor Jeffrey Robinson because the pregnancy was "much bigger" than her previous three pregnancies, Australia's The Telegraph reported.

However, Robinson ended up doing a forceps delivery, which Gillett says caused her erb's palsy, according to The Telegraph.

The medical condition leaves Gillett without full use of her arm. It is often caused by shoulder dystocia during birth, which occurs when the head and neck of the baby are pulled to the side while the shoulders are going through the birth canal, news.com.au reported.

Now, Gillett is taking Robinson to Australia's Supreme Court.

Source: Hoffpost.com
She has a case. Let the court decide. The lazy doctor ought to pay if he is responsible.
FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×